Public to be notified of water discharges

Summary#

Bill 198, the Cootes Paradise Water Accountability Act, 2020, would amend the Ontario Water Resources Act. Its goal is to make the public aware when polluting material is discharged or escapes.

  • After the Ministry is notified of a discharge or escape, it would have to notify the public “forthwith” (without delay), in the manner set by regulations.
  • Regulations could set how the Ministry must notify the public and what information it must share.
  • The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • The Ministry: Would have a new duty to notify the public after receiving notice of a discharge or escape. The bill does not itself set the notice method or the information to be shared.
  • The public: Would be entitled to notice under the rules set by regulations. The bill does not say which channels the Ministry must use.
  • People or organizations that must report a discharge or escape: The bill does not change the reporting rule in subsection 30(2). The explanatory note says that rule already requires the Ministry to be notified.
  • People responsible for a discharge or escape: The bill does not add a new ban, fine, cleanup duty, or other penalty.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of the bill.

  • The bill creates a Ministry notification duty, but gives no estimate of staffing or other costs.
  • It does not set a fee, fine, tax, or spending amount.

What is unclear#

  • The regulations that would set the notice method and required information are not included. The bill does not say when they must be made.
  • The bill does not specify a notice channel, such as a website or direct alerts, or say exactly how much detail the public would receive.
  • The Ontario Water Resources Act itself was not supplied, so the full current legal rules and their interaction with this amendment could not be verified. The explanatory note describes the existing reporting requirement.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the public should receive timely information about pollution incidents after the Ministry is notified.
  • Setting the details by regulation could let the Ministry’s notice method and information requirements be specified separately from the Act.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key details to regulations, including how notice is given and what information is shared. Until those rules are set, the practical scope of public notification is unclear.
  • “Forthwith” requires prompt notice, but the bill gives no fixed deadline or process for handling delays.