Summary#
Bill 235, the Cannabis Licence Amendment Act, 2020, would amend Ontario’s Cannabis Licence Act, 2018. Its stated goal is to make municipal council resolutions evidence of residents’ needs and wishes when the Registrar considers retail store authorization applications.
- Unless there is evidence to the contrary, the Registrar must treat a relevant municipal council resolution as proof of residents’ needs and wishes for a criterion in the existing Act.
- A resolution may apply to one application, one or more areas of a municipality, or the whole municipality.
- A resolution may include guidance about the concentration of cannabis retail stores.
- The bill does not make a council resolution binding on the Registrar or guarantee that an application will be approved or refused.
What it means for you#
- Retail store applicants: If the municipality has passed a relevant resolution, the Registrar must treat it as proof of residents’ needs and wishes unless there is evidence to the contrary. The bill does not say this is the only factor in the decision.
- Municipal councils: A council may pass a resolution with the scope described above, but the bill does not require it to do so.
- Registrar: The Registrar would have a new duty about how to treat a municipal resolution when applying the existing criterion.
- Residents: The bill does not create a direct right to make a submission or a process for residents to shape a council’s resolution.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill provides no cost estimate and does not set out new funding, fees, fines, or an appropriation.
- It does not specify whether the change would require extra staff or other resources.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so the full current licensing process and how this criterion fits with other criteria could not be verified.
- The bill does not define what counts as “evidence to the contrary” or explain how the Registrar should weigh competing evidence.
- It does not explain how the Registrar should handle overlapping or conflicting municipal resolutions.
- It does not set out how residents would be involved in creating a council resolution.
- The text says it would come into force on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not show whether it became law.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it gives the Registrar a clear way to consider a municipality’s stated view of residents’ needs and wishes.
- Resolutions could be tailored to a particular application or area, rather than applying across the whole municipality.
- The resolution is evidence, not a binding decision: the Registrar must also consider evidence to the contrary.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill gives council resolutions a default evidentiary weight without defining what evidence would be enough to rebut it.
- It is unclear how the Registrar would resolve conflicts between a resolution and other evidence, or between resolutions covering overlapping areas.
- The bill does not set a process for residents to contribute to resolutions, even though the resolutions are treated as proof of residents’ needs and wishes.
- The bill does not explain how this rule would interact with the other parts of the retail store authorization process.