Summary#
Bill 239, Stay Home If You Are Sick Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000. The bill text’s short-title clause instead says “Stay Home If You Are Sick Act, 2020”; the supplied materials do not explain the difference. Its stated goal is to make more leave paid and to provide financial support to employers.
- It would replace the Act’s separate sick leave, family responsibility leave and bereavement leave provisions with one personal emergency leave: up to seven paid days and three unpaid days per calendar year.
- That leave could be used for an employee’s own illness, injury or medical emergency; the death, illness, injury or medical emergency of a listed person; or an urgent matter concerning a listed person.
- It would make the first 14 days of leave under the Act’s declared-emergency and infectious-disease-emergency provisions paid each calendar year. Those days would be in addition to the personal emergency leave days.
- The Minister would have to implement a financial support program for employers. The Minister may provide funding, but only if the Legislature appropriates money.
- I could not verify these proposed changes against current law because the Employment Standards Act, 2000 itself was not supplied.
What it means for you#
- Employees covered by the Act: For personal emergency leave, the listed people include a spouse; parents, step-parents and foster parents of the employee or spouse; children, step-children and foster children of either; children under either’s legal guardianship; the employee’s siblings and step-siblings; grandparents, step-grandparents, grandchildren and step-grandchildren of either; the employee’s in-laws who are siblings or step-siblings; sons- and daughters-in-law of either; aunts and uncles of either; nieces and nephews of either; and the spouses of the employee’s grandchildren, aunts, uncles, nieces or nephews. It also includes a person who considers the employee like family, if prescribed conditions are met, and any other prescribed family member.
- Employees taking personal emergency leave: The seven paid days must be used before the three unpaid days. An employee who has worked for the employer less than one week is not entitled to paid days yet; unpaid days taken during that period count toward the yearly limit. An employer may count part of a day as a full day.
- Employees taking either kind of leave: For paid personal emergency leave, employers must pay wages the employee would have earned, subject to special rules for performance-based pay and limits on overtime, shift-premium and public-holiday premium pay. Employers may ask for evidence that is reasonable in the circumstances, but cannot require a certificate from a qualified health practitioner.
- Employers: They would have to provide the paid leave and advise employees to tell them before taking personal emergency leave—or as soon as possible if advance notice is not possible. The bill does not guarantee that an employer will receive financial support.
- Taxpayers: The bill does not set an amount for employer payments. Any payment under the program would depend on the Legislature appropriating money.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the supplied material; the bill requires a financial support program, but payments can be made only if the Legislature appropriates money.
- The program’s stated purposes are to help employers cover the costs of paid emergency leave and temporarily help them adapt to increased personal emergency leave costs.
- The bill does not set a total budget, payment amounts or how much of an employer’s costs might be covered.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out how employers would apply for support, how payments would be calculated, or which employers would qualify.
- It does not say how much money the Legislature would appropriate, or when the program would begin.
- “Urgent matter” is not defined in the supplied text. The bill also leaves some family-member conditions and possible additional family members to rules made elsewhere.
- The bill does not provide details about enforcement, appeals or reporting for the new leave rules or financial support program.
- The supplied explanatory note describes the provisions being replaced, but without the parent Act I could not confirm how the bill would interact with current law or other leave entitlements.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to let employees take time away for illness or family emergencies without losing all their pay.
- A possible argument for paid emergency leave is that employees may have a better chance to stay home when sick, rather than lose wages.
- The separate employer-support program could help employers manage some of the added costs, if money is appropriated and support is provided.
Case against#
- Employers would have to provide paid leave, while the bill does not guarantee that they will receive financial support or explain how much support they could get.
- The bill leaves important limits and procedures unclear, including what counts as an “urgent matter” and how employer funding would be allocated.
- The yearly limits, the rule that paid days must be used first, and the option to count part of a day as a full day may leave some employees with fewer usable days than they expect.