Summary#
Bill 305, 10 Paid Sick Days for Ontario Workers Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000. It would replace the Act’s sick leave, family responsibility leave and bereavement leave provisions with a personal emergency leave entitlement, and increase paid infectious disease emergency leave from three days to 10, according to the bill’s explanatory note. Its stated goal is to help employees and employers keep workplaces safe and productive.
- An employee employed for at least one week would be entitled to up to 10 paid personal emergency leave days per calendar year for their own illness, injury or medical emergency, or for specified family situations.
- The family situations include a family member’s death, illness, injury or medical emergency, and an urgent matter concerning that family member. The listed family members are spouses; parents, step-parents and foster parents; children, step-children and foster children; grandparents, step-grandparents, grandchildren and step-grandchildren; the spouse of the employee’s child; siblings; and relatives dependent on the employee for care or assistance.
- The Minister would have to set up an employer support program and consult industry leaders. Financial support could be part of the program only if the Legislature appropriates money for it.
- An employer could ask for evidence that is reasonable in the circumstances, but could not require a certificate from a health practitioner.
- A partial day of leave could count as a full day. Leave taken before the employee has worked one week would be unpaid, but would count against the yearly entitlement once the employee qualifies for paid days.
What it means for you#
- Workers: If you have worked for your employer for at least one week, the bill would provide up to 10 paid days per calendar year for the listed personal or family reasons. You would have to tell your employer you are taking leave; if you cannot do so beforehand, you must tell them as soon as possible after it starts.
- Workers taking leave: You could be asked for reasonable evidence, but not a health practitioner’s certificate. A part-day absence could use up a whole day. Leave pay would generally be based on wages you would have earned, with a different calculation for performance-related pay.
- Workers and employers: The bill would also raise paid infectious disease emergency leave from three days to 10, as described in the explanatory note. The bill does not explain how this entitlement interacts with the new personal emergency leave entitlement.
- Employers: You would have to pay eligible personal emergency leave and follow its notice and evidence rules. Leave pay would not include overtime pay or a shift premium; it would not include premium pay when leave falls on a public holiday.
- Minister and employers: The Minister would have to establish an employer support program. The bill does not require financial aid unless money is appropriated.
- General public: The bill does not create a new independent agency, tax, fine, or general right to time off for reasons outside the listed leave situations.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- Employers would pay for eligible personal emergency leave.
- The Minister would have to implement an employer support program, but the bill gives no staffing or operating-cost estimate.
- That program may include financial support for employers only if the Legislature appropriates money. The bill itself does not set an amount.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the Employment Standards Act, 2000. I could not independently verify current law or check how the amendments fit with the rest of the Act.
- The bill does not explain whether personal emergency leave and infectious disease emergency leave can be used separately or how they interact.
- It does not set out the support program’s budget, form of support, eligibility rules, application process or timeline.
- The bill does not define “urgent matter” or explain how employers should judge what evidence is “reasonable in the circumstances.”
- It does not say how the Minister would consult industry leaders beyond requiring that consultation.
Case for#
- A paid leave entitlement could let workers stay home when ill or care for a family member without losing that day’s wages.
- The bill’s coverage includes urgent family matters as well as illness and injury, which could help workers deal with some immediate family needs.
- The required employer support program could help employers meet the new leave requirements; the bill leaves room for financial support if money is appropriated.
- Increasing infectious disease emergency leave could give workers more paid time away from work during an infectious disease emergency.
Case against#
- Employers would have to pay for up to 10 personal emergency leave days, but the bill does not estimate those costs or specify how employer support would work.
- The bill permits an employer to count a partial day as a full day, which could use up a worker’s entitlement faster than the time actually taken.
- Key limits are left open: “urgent matter” is not defined in the bill, and the evidence standard could be applied differently by different employers.
- The bill does not explain whether the two 10-day leave entitlements overlap, so the total leave available in particular circumstances is unclear.