Summary#
Bill 252, the Housing is a Human Right Act, 2021, would create a new Act and amend the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing Act. Its stated goal is to make housing a human-rights principle that guides how the Ontario government interprets laws, regulations and policies.
- The Ontario government would have to be guided by that principle when interpreting all Acts, regulations and policies.
- The Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing would have to establish a nine-member Housing Inequities and Disparity Working Group. Members must have specified housing-related expertise and knowledge; appointments must have regard for reflecting Ontario’s diversity.
- The Working Group would study housing disparities, eviction impacts, overcrowding, housing as a human right, housing policies and access, barriers to affordable home ownership, possible interventions to address income and wealth inequality, and the effectiveness of existing policies. Its studies would consider disparities linked to the identity and income groups listed in the bill.
- The bill would establish an Office of the Independent Housing Commissioner through the ministry’s Act. The Minister may appoint a Commissioner and set their terms of reference. The Commissioner must collect housing-disparity data relating to race, immigration status and socioeconomic status, research eviction-prevention strategies, and report findings to the Minister.
What it means for you#
- Ontario residents: The bill would guide the provincial government’s interpretation of laws, regulations and policies. It does not expressly create an individual right to housing, a process for claiming housing, or a remedy if housing is unavailable.
- Tenants and people facing housing barriers: The Working Group would study eviction impacts, overcrowding and other listed issues. The Commissioner would research ways to prevent evictions. The bill does not change eviction rules or require a particular prevention strategy.
- People in groups named in the bill: The Working Group’s studies would cover disparities linked to Indigenous identity, race, immigration status, gender, sexual orientation, age, disability and income. The Commissioner’s data duty names race, immigration status and socioeconomic status.
- Property owners, landlords and housing providers: The bill does not directly change rent, property rights, housing standards or eligibility for housing programs.
- Government: The Minister must establish the Working Group. The Commissioner’s office would have research and data duties, but the bill does not create a service for people to apply to.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- The bill allows the Lieutenant Governor in Council to set the Commissioner’s remuneration and expenses, but only if the Legislature appropriates money for that purpose.
- The bill gives no budget, staffing level or cost estimate for the Working Group or Commissioner’s office.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define what it means for housing to be a “human right” or explain how that principle would affect a specific government decision.
- It sets no deadlines or rules for the Working Group’s studies, and does not require it to publish findings or recommend actions.
- It does not set the Commissioner’s appointment term, explain the office’s independence in practice, or require public release of the Commissioner’s reports.
- It does not say how the government must act on the findings, or how the Working Group and Commissioner’s work would connect to existing housing programs.
- The Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing Act was not supplied, so the existing Act’s provisions and how this office would fit with them could not be verified.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that requiring the government to consider housing as a human-rights principle could bring that perspective into decisions across laws, regulations and policies.
- The Working Group’s required studies cover several stated housing problems and include both policy research and the effects on specific groups.
- The Commissioner’s required data collection and eviction-prevention research could provide information for later government decisions.
- Requiring members to have relevant expertise, while having regard for Ontario’s diversity, could help inform the Working Group’s studies.
Case against#
- The bill does not define the human-rights principle or set out a way for a person to enforce it, so its practical effect on government decisions is uncertain.
- The bill requires study and research but does not require the government to adopt recommendations or change housing policy.
- The Commissioner’s data duty names fewer identity and income categories than the Working Group’s study duties.
- The bill does not set deadlines, public reporting rules, staffing or funding levels, making it unclear how much work the new duties would lead to.