Housing bill boosts tenant protections

Summary#

Bill 184, the Protecting Tenants and Strengthening Community Housing Act, 2020, amends the Building Code Act, 1992, the Housing Services Act, 2011 and the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006. It also enacts the Ontario Mortgage and Housing Corporation Repeal Act, 2020, which dissolves that corporation. The stated goal is to protect tenants and strengthen community housing; the Act does not guarantee those results. It received Royal Assent, but some provisions require a proclamation to take effect.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may designate an Ontario not-for-profit corporation to administer specified parts of the Building Code Act. The corporation would have to follow an agreement with the Minister, and the Minister could oversee it, issue directions and set approved processes for fees.
  • Service managers must provide prescribed housing assistance and have an access system for it. They must also make local eligibility rules on prescribed matters.
  • Housing providers and service managers can move housing projects into or out of a new category through agreements and prescribed steps. The Minister may issue directives about how those projects are run and governed.
  • The Ontario Mortgage and Housing Corporation is dissolved; its assets, liabilities, rights and obligations transfer to the Crown. The Minister may sell or otherwise dispose of its real property, or transfer it to the municipality where it is located without the municipality’s consent.
  • The Act changes tenant and landlord rights, including compensation for some evictions, claims against former tenants, rent increases and enforcement.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants: A landlord giving notice for a purchaser’s personal use must pay one month’s rent or offer another unit the tenant accepts. Similar compensation applies in some demolition, conversion and renovation cases in buildings with fewer than five units.
  • Tenants: If the Landlord and Tenant Board finds a landlord acted in bad faith in certain eviction cases, it may order general compensation of up to 12 months’ rent. In eviction cases involving rent arrears, tenants must give advance written notice to raise other issues at the hearing, unless the Board accepts their explanation for not doing so.
  • Tenants: A rent increase that would otherwise be void for lack of proper notice can become valid after the tenant pays it for 12 straight months—unless the tenant applied within one year of the first charge to challenge its validity.
  • Landlords and former tenants: Landlords may seek certain amounts from former tenants, including unpaid rent, damage, unpaid utility costs and costs from interference with the landlord’s rights. Most of these claims must be brought within one year after the tenant leaves. The Act also sets notice requirements for claims against former tenants.
  • Some employee tenants: The Residential Tenancies Act does not apply to a land-lease home site owned by an employer and provided to an employee under a tenancy first entered into on or after Royal Assent. The exemption lasts until that tenancy ends.
  • Housing service managers and providers: Service managers must follow prescribed rules for housing assistance and access. Providers and service managers that enter agreements for Part VII.1 projects must follow them and applicable ministerial directives.
  • General public: The Act allows a building-code administrative authority to be set up, but does not itself make a corporation the authority. The corporation would not be a Crown agency, and its workers would not be Crown employees.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The building-code administrative agreement must set financial terms, including possible payments to the Crown, licence fees, royalties and reimbursements. The authority may set fees and charges under processes and criteria approved by the Minister, including permit fees in areas where it is not the principal authority.
  • The authority may employ or retain qualified people. No staffing level or cost estimate is given.
  • The Minister may dispose of the dissolved corporation’s real property, but the material gives no estimate of proceeds or related costs.

What is unclear#

  • The material does not give proclamation dates for provisions that require them, or say whether a building-code authority has been designated. No publicly available information.
  • Many housing assistance details—including levels, eligibility rules and access-system requirements—are left to regulations. The material does not provide those regulations.
  • The Act does not set out the full process, timelines or appeal rights for housing-project agreements and exits; some details are left to regulations.
  • The Act does not say which building-code provisions would be delegated, or what fees or staffing would follow. The administrative agreement and later regulations would matter.
  • The supplied material gives summaries of earlier rules but not the full parent Acts. I could not independently verify all changes against current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to add tenant compensation and a larger potential remedy for certain bad-faith evictions.
  • Requiring landlords to consider payment arrangements in some rent-arrears eviction cases could encourage efforts to resolve arrears before eviction. The Board must consider whether the landlord tried to negotiate; the bill does not require a deal.
  • A shared access system and prescribed assistance rules could make housing assistance more consistent, though the details depend on regulations.
  • A building-code authority could administer delegated provisions under ministerial oversight, with reporting, audits and public-interest duties required by the Act.

Case against#

  • Some protections depend on regulations or later decisions, so the Act alone does not show how much assistance tenants would receive or which building-code duties would be delegated.
  • Allowing certain rent increases to become valid after 12 months of payment may make it harder for tenants to challenge an increase they did not contest in time.
  • The Act gives landlords more ways to seek compensation from former tenants and extends the time to bring some claims. That may mean claims arise after a tenant has moved.
  • The building-code authority could set fees, and its money would not count as public money. Oversight is provided for, but the text does not specify the authority’s eventual costs or fees.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2020072102

    Passed94 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 184

    FOR · 63AGAINST · 31

    63For

    • PC62
    • Independent1

    31Against

    • NDP24
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2020072103

    Passed94 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 184

    FOR · 63AGAINST · 31

    63For

    • PC62
    • Independent1

    31Against

    • NDP24
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2020052702

    Passed71 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 184

    FOR · 53AGAINST · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    53For

    • PC53

    18Against

    • NDP14
    • Liberal3
    • Green1