Summary#
Bill 287, the Equity Education for Young Ontarians Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Education Act. Its stated goal is to include equity-related education in school curricula and create an Education Equity Secretariat Initiatives Branch within the Ministry of Education; the bill does not create a separate agency. It would require curriculum content, teacher training and support, and annual reports from every school board.
- The Minister must ensure age-appropriate curriculum information from junior kindergarten through Grade 12 covers colonization and its effects on Indigenous and racialized people; ongoing racial and social inequities in Ontario, including disparities in health care, justice and education; and how pupils can help build an inclusive and equitable Ontario.
- When developing the curriculum guidelines, the Minister must consult non-governmental people and organizations with specialized knowledge, and groups representing Black, Indigenous or people of colour.
- The Minister must provide training and support on these topics for teachers and other board staff.
- Every school board must send the Branch director a report by December 31 each year. Reports must cover systemic barriers, equity and human rights needs and issues, measures the board considers appropriate, and recommendations and feedback on equity, accessibility, inclusion and anti-oppression measures.
- The Branch director may recommend that the Minister address issues or disparities identified in those reports. The bill does not require the Minister to act on a recommendation.
What it means for you#
- Pupils and families: Schools would be required to include the specified topics throughout the grades, in an age-appropriate manner. The bill does not set out individual pupil rights, complaint procedures or remedies.
- Teachers and other board staff: The Minister must provide training and support on the topics. The bill does not specify what that training or support must include.
- School boards: Each board must prepare and provide the annual report. The bill does not set out a reporting format or require boards to adopt every measure or recommendation in their reports.
- Ministry of Education: It must establish the Branch as an administrative division, develop the curriculum guidelines with the required consultation, and provide staff training and support.
- Current law: The supplied material does not include the existing Education Act, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against the current law.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires the Ministry to establish a Branch and provide training and support, but gives no staffing levels or cost estimates.
- Boards must prepare annual reports, but the bill gives no estimate of the cost to do so.
- The bill does not set a tax, fee or fine.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define terms such as “racialized,” “systemic barriers” or “age-appropriate.”
- It does not specify the curriculum content in detail, how training and support will be delivered, or how their quality will be checked.
- It does not set report formats, how reports will be assessed, or whether reports or recommendations will be made public.
- It does not say how the Minister must respond to the Branch director’s recommendations, or what happens if a board misses a reporting deadline.
- The bill would start three months after Royal Assent, but the available material does not say when it would receive Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address gaps in pupils’ understanding of colonization and ongoing inequities, including disparities in health care, justice and education.
- Requiring age-appropriate curriculum content across all grades could make these topics part of education throughout a pupil’s school years.
- Consultation with people and groups with relevant knowledge is required when the Minister develops the guidelines.
- Annual board reports could give the Ministry information about barriers and needs across school boards.
Case against#
- The bill sets broad topic requirements but leaves much of the curriculum, training and reporting process unspecified.
- The Branch may recommend action, but the bill does not require the Minister to follow its recommendations.
- The bill requires new work by the Ministry and school boards without estimating its cost or specifying staff and resources.
- The reports must cover sensitive issues affecting pupils and staff, but the bill does not explain how information will be gathered, protected or used.