Equity Education for Young Learners

Summary#

Bill 35, the Equity Education for Young Ontarians Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Education Act. Its goal is to add equity-related learning across school grades and create a Ministry branch to receive annual reports from school boards. The bill says it would start three months after Royal Assent.

  • The Minister of Education would have to ensure that curriculum guidelines include age-appropriate information, from junior kindergarten through Grade 12, about colonization and its effects on Indigenous and racialized people’s rights; ongoing racial and social inequities in Ontario, including disparities in health care, justice and education; and how pupils can help build an inclusive and equitable Ontario.
  • The Minister would have to consult people and organizations with specialized knowledge of those topics, and groups representing Black, Indigenous and people of colour, when developing the guidelines.
  • The Minister would have to provide teachers and other school-board staff with training and support on those topics.
  • The bill would create the Education Equity Secretariat Initiatives Branch as an administrative division within the Ministry—not as a separate agency.
  • Each school board would have to send the branch’s director an annual report by December 31. The report must cover systemic barriers, equity and human-rights needs and issues, board measures to improve policies and practices for racialized pupils and staff, and recommendations and feedback on equity, accessibility, inclusion and anti-oppression measures.
  • The director would have to recommend to the Minister ways to address issues or disparities identified in the reports. The bill does not require the Minister to adopt those recommendations.

The supplied material does not include the current Education Act, so it is not possible to verify which related curriculum or reporting requirements already exist.

What it means for you#

  • Pupils: The curriculum would have to include the listed topics in an age-appropriate way across grades. The bill does not create an individual pupil benefit, complaint process or appeal.
  • Teachers and other board staff: The Minister would have to provide training and support, but the bill does not set its format or amount.
  • School boards: Every board would have to prepare and submit the specified annual report. The bill does not set a report format.
  • Ministry of Education: It would have to develop the curriculum guidelines with the required consultation, provide staff training and support, and establish the branch within the Ministry.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires training and support for school staff, annual reports from boards, and an administrative division in the Ministry, but gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • It does not specify a funding source or an appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define terms such as “racialized,” “systemic barriers,” “age-appropriate” or “equity needs.”
  • It does not set out how consultation must happen, or how the Minister must use what is heard.
  • It does not specify how reports should be prepared, what evidence they should contain, or how the information will be protected.
  • The director must make recommendations, but the bill does not require the Minister to respond or act on them.
  • The supplied material does not explain how these requirements would fit with existing curriculum, reporting or equity programs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that required curriculum content across all grades could make learning about colonization and present-day inequities more consistent.
  • Requiring consultation with people and organizations with relevant knowledge, including groups representing Black, Indigenous and people of colour, could inform how the curriculum is developed.
  • Annual reports could give the Ministry information about barriers and equity-related needs across school boards, while the director would have to recommend responses to identified issues.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires training, support and annual reporting but does not provide a budget, staffing plan or implementation details.
  • The bill does not define key terms or set standards for reports, so what boards report could vary.
  • The director must recommend action, but the bill does not require the Minister to respond. Reporting therefore would not guarantee that identified issues are addressed.
  • Because the current Education Act was not supplied, it is unclear how much of this would add to or overlap with existing requirements.