Tightens skilled trades regulation

Summary#

Bill 288, the Building Opportunities in the Skilled Trades Act, 2021, was enacted as Chapter 28 of Ontario’s 2021 statutes. It creates a new statutory system for trades and apprenticeships, repeals the Ontario College of Trades and Apprenticeship Act, 2009, and continues the Ontario College of Trades as Skilled Trades Ontario, a Crown agency—not a new independent body. The Act’s stated goal is to support trades and apprenticeship; it does not guarantee particular results. Most of the Act was to start on a date set by proclamation, which is not given in the supplied material.

  • The Minister may prescribe trades, set their scopes of practice, and classify trades as compulsory. Individuals may not practise a compulsory trade, and employers may not hire or engage them to do so, unless the person is an apprentice under an active registered training agreement, holds an unsuspended certificate, or is exempt under regulations.
  • Skilled Trades Ontario must establish apprenticeship programs. The Registrar handles certificates and, under changes made within the Act, registers training agreements, administers examinations and issues apprenticeship certificates.
  • Where a trade is subject to an apprentice-to-journeyperson ratio, the default limit is one apprentice for each journeyperson unless regulations set another ratio. Regulations may also allow exemptions or different ratios for a person.
  • Inspectors may examine and demand relevant records, take copies and recordings, question people, and enter non-residential premises at reasonable times without a warrant. A warrant can authorize entry and search; a dwelling cannot be entered without consent under the ordinary inspection power.
  • Inspectors may issue compliance orders and notices requiring administrative penalties for certain breaches. The Ontario Labour Relations Board may review a penalty notice.
  • The Act amends the Infrastructure for Jobs and Prosperity Act, 2015 to link its apprentice requirements to this Act’s rules, and repeals the Modernizing the Skilled Trades and Apprenticeship Act, 2019.

What it means for you#

  • Workers in compulsory trades: You must meet the certificate or apprenticeship rules to practise, unless regulations exempt you. Certificate holders and apprentices must carry proof and show it when properly asked.
  • Apprentices and sponsors: A training agreement is subject to registration. Sponsors must follow applicable training requirements and ratios. Apprentices who complete a program receive a certificate of apprenticeship; if their trade requires a certifying exam, they also receive a provisional certificate of qualification.
  • Employers: You must not employ or otherwise engage someone to do work in a compulsory trade unless an allowed certificate, apprenticeship, or regulatory exemption applies.
  • Training providers: Providers approved for in-class training must deliver it according to the apprenticeship program’s requirements.
  • Taxpayers: The province may fund Skilled Trades Ontario through loans. The Act also provides for provincial payment of a judgment against the agency if it cannot pay after reasonable efforts.
  • The public: Skilled Trades Ontario must keep a public register with names of apprentices and certificate holders in compulsory trades, along with specified certificate details.

Money#

The Act authorizes fees, staffing and provincial loans, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate.

  • The Minister and, subject to the Minister’s approval, Skilled Trades Ontario may charge fees for applications, examinations and other functions.
  • Skilled Trades Ontario may employ staff; its directors and chief executive officer receive remuneration or benefits.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may authorize loans to the agency. No loan amount or operating budget is provided.
  • Administrative penalty amounts are left to regulations. Certain listed offences, including knowingly making false statements in specified cases, carry fines of up to $10,000.

What is unclear#

  • Which trades are prescribed, which are compulsory, and what scopes of practice and ratios apply are not set out here; these depend on regulations.
  • The supplied material does not give the penalty schedule, fee amounts, inspection framework, or detailed rules for many applications and hearings.
  • The Act allows collection and disclosure of personal information for stated purposes, but the supplied material does not show how those powers are applied in practice.
  • The exact general start date is not provided. The Act says most provisions start on a proclaimed date.
  • The earlier Ontario College of Trades and Apprenticeship Act, 2009 and relevant regulations were not supplied, so the full change from the prior system cannot be verified here.

Case for#

  • The Act sets out one statutory structure for apprenticeship programs, certificates, compulsory trades, inspections and penalties.
  • A possible argument for the certification and training rules is that they set common requirements for who may do work in compulsory trades.
  • Skilled Trades Ontario’s duties include promoting trades, researching training, and promoting inclusivity and diversity.
  • The Act provides a route for reviewing administrative penalty notices through the Ontario Labour Relations Board.

Case against#

  • The Minister and regulations have substantial influence over which trades are covered, their scopes of practice, exemptions, and some certification and ratio rules. The supplied material does not show what those rules will be.
  • Inspectors receive broad powers to demand records, question people and inspect non-residential premises. A possible concern is whether the rules and oversight will provide enough clarity and protection in practice.
  • Fees and public costs are authorized but not estimated in the supplied material, so the financial effect is uncertain.
  • The Act sets out powers and duties but leaves many practical details—such as penalty amounts and the enforcement framework—to regulations.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2021060201

    Passed57 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 288

    FOR · 57

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    57For

    • PC39
    • NDP13
    • Liberal4
    • Green1

    0Against