Summary#
Bill 79, the Working for Workers Act, 2023, became Chapter 15 of Ontario’s 2023 statutes. It amends seven existing laws; it does not create a new agency or a stand-alone benefits program. Its apparent goals include stronger protections and penalties in some workplace matters, and changes to how employment and social-benefit programs use personal information.
- Foreign workers: For certain passport or work-permit contraventions, the Ontario Labour Relations Board must reduce a penalty if it finds the penalty excessive or punitive in the circumstances. A court conviction can bring higher maximum fines.
- Employees and employers: The Employment Standards Act adds a reservist-leave entitlement for some treatment, recovery or rehabilitation, and makes some rules treat an employee’s private residence as an employer’s establishment. It also adds notice requirements and changes recruiter-related licensing rules.
- Regulated professions: Professions must consult the relevant minister about ensuring adequate numbers of qualified professionals. They may count Canadian experience toward registration only if they also accept alternatives that meet criteria set by regulation.
- Employment and social-benefit programs: The Ministry of Labour may share some personal information with organizations delivering or evaluating funded employment programs, and with the ministry responsible for Ontario Works and disability support. Separate changes allow collection and sharing for Ontario Works and disability-support administration.
- Workplace safety: The maximum fine for a corporation convicted under the Occupational Health and Safety Act rises from $1.5 million to $2 million.
What it means for you#
- Foreign nationals and recruiters: A person convicted of taking or keeping a foreign national’s passport or work permit can face a fine of up to $500,000, up to 12 months in jail, or both. A corporation can face a fine of up to $1 million. Recruiter licensing rules also cover collecting fees that a recruiter charged unlawfully.
- Employees: Some reservists who are in treatment, recovery or rehabilitation for an illness, injury or medical emergency resulting from specified operations or activities gain access to reservist leave. The bill does not set the full list of qualifying activities here; leave also depends on an employment-duration rule.
- Employees working from home: For specified Employment Standards Act rules, an employee’s private residence counts as an establishment if the employee works there and does not work at another location where the employer carries on business. The bill does not make a home an establishment for every purpose under the Act.
- Employers: Employers covered by the notice rules must provide prescribed information to the Director, post it at the establishment and give it to affected employees on the first day of the notice period. Some temporary help agencies must provide notice information to each affected employee on that day or as soon as reasonably possible.
- Regulated professionals: Registration rules require professions to accept qualifying alternatives if they use Canadian experience as a registration qualification. The new consultation duty does not itself guarantee that more professionals will become available.
- Ontario Works and disability-support applicants or recipients: The changes allow personal information to be collected indirectly and shared for program administration. The Labour minister cannot access information collected on behalf of the social-services minister unless otherwise authorized by law. The amendments do not change benefit eligibility or amounts.
Money#
No publicly available information on the law’s total implementation cost or expected savings.
- The law raises the maximum corporate workplace-safety fine and sets higher maximum fines for certain foreign-national offences; it does not say how much will be collected.
- It authorizes information-sharing and new administrative purposes, but provides no staffing, system-cost or funding estimate in the supplied material.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not give the date of Royal Assent or the actual start date of every change. Some provisions depend on other amendments coming into force.
- The rules do not specify here which activities qualify for the added reservist leave, or any prescribed leave period or employment-duration period.
- The bill does not set out what personal information may be shared in each program, how long it may be kept, or the detailed safeguards and oversight.
- The criteria for alternatives to Canadian experience are left to regulations; the supplied material does not provide those criteria.
- The bill does not explain how regulated professions and ministers will carry out the consultation duty, or how progress toward adequate numbers will be judged.
Case for#
- The changes create stronger penalties for certain passport and work-permit violations and require a reduction when a related administrative penalty is excessive or punitive.
- Requiring alternatives to Canadian experience may allow qualified applicants to meet registration requirements through other routes.
- Sharing information among employment and social-benefit program administrators may support administration of those programs.
- Counting some employees’ homes as establishments may make workplace rules apply more clearly where work is done only at home.
Case against#
- Higher maximum fines and new information-sharing authority do not, by themselves, ensure effective enforcement or better services.
- The information-sharing changes permit indirect collection and disclosure of personal information, while the supplied text gives few details about data limits, retention or oversight.
- The consultation duty for regulated professions does not set a clear result, timetable or measure for whether Ontario has enough qualified professionals.
- Important details, including leave eligibility criteria and alternative registration requirements, depend on regulations not included here.