Summary#
Bill 104, the 10 Paid Sick Days for Ontario Workers Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000. Its stated goal is to support workers’ health and workplace safety while helping employers provide leave.
- It would replace separate sick leave, family responsibility leave and bereavement leave rules with one entitlement: up to 10 paid personal emergency leave days per calendar year, for employees employed at least one week.
- The leave could be used for an employee’s illness, injury or medical emergency; the death, illness, injury or medical emergency of specified family members; or an urgent matter concerning those family members.
- Employers would have to pay for the leave using the bill’s wage rules. They could ask for reasonable evidence, but could not require a certificate from a qualified health practitioner.
- The Minister would have to set up an employer support program and consult industry leaders. The program could include financial support, but only if the Legislature appropriates money for it.
- It would raise paid infectious disease emergency leave from three days to 10, according to the bill’s explanatory note.
What it means for you#
- Employees: You would need to tell your employer you are taking leave. If you have to start before giving notice, you must tell the employer as soon as possible afterward. Employees with less than one week of service would get unpaid leave; those days would count toward the 10-day total once they qualify for paid leave.
- Employees: The 10 days would be one shared yearly limit across the listed reasons. An employer could count part of a day as a full day. Leave pay would generally match wages you would have earned, subject to the bill’s rules; it would not include shift premiums or certain overtime or public-holiday premiums.
- Employees and employers: The bill names the family members covered, including spouses, children, parents, siblings, grandparents and dependent relatives. Employers could require evidence that is reasonable in the circumstances, but not a health-practitioner certificate.
- Employers: You would have to provide and pay for qualifying leave. The Minister’s program would have to provide resources and support to help employers, but the bill does not guarantee financial support.
- Minister and government: The Minister would have to implement the support program and consult industry leaders. The bill does not itself set aside money for that program.
Money#
The bill requires employers to pay for qualifying leave and requires a support program, but the available material gives no cost estimate.
- The bill sets out how leave pay is calculated, including a minimum-wage floor for some employees paid by commission or piecework.
- The program may offer financial support to employers only if the Legislature appropriates money. No amount or eligibility rules are stated.
- No estimate is given for public spending, employer costs or staffing the program.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out the support program’s services, how employers would access it, or who would qualify for any financial support.
- It does not specify how the 10-day infectious disease leave interacts with the new personal emergency leave entitlement.
- It refers to prescribed circumstances and classes of health practitioners but does not say what they would be.
- The parent Act was not supplied, so other current-law details and interactions could not be checked against the full Act.
- The bill would start on Royal Assent, but the available material does not say when that would happen.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that paid time off could let employees recover or care for family without choosing between lost wages and taking leave.
- The bill covers several personal and family emergencies under one entitlement, and does not allow employers to demand a health-practitioner certificate.
- The support program is intended to help employers provide leave; financial support could be included if money is appropriated.
Case against#
- One concern is that illness, bereavement and family emergencies would all draw from the same 10-day annual limit.
- An employer could count a partial day as a full day, reducing an employee’s remaining entitlement.
- The bill requires a support program but leaves its services, funding and access rules open. Employers would still have to pay for leave, and the bill does not establish that they would receive financial support.