Petroleum Pricing Fairness Bill

Summary#

Bill 7, the Fairness in Petroleum Products Pricing Act, 2018, would create a new law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would give the Ontario Energy Board (OEB) powers over weekly petroleum-product prices and set rules for retailers and wholesalers. Its stated goal is to make prices more predictable and transparent and to support stable, competitive markets, including in remote, rural and northern areas.

  • The OEB may set a weekly maximum retail price and a weekly minimum retailer mark-up (the difference between the wholesale price paid by a retailer and the price charged to a consumer). The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations that govern price-setting or set prices, mark-ups and areas.
  • Retailers must not charge above the maximum price. Wholesalers must not sell at a price that leaves less than the required minimum mark-up.
  • Retailers and wholesalers must keep sale records for at least five years, unless the OEB sets a different period.
  • The OEB may receive complaints and make inquiries. It may appoint inspectors who can inspect business premises and records without a warrant, subject to limits on entry into dwellings.
  • The OEB may impose administrative penalties of up to $100,000 per day, and may add the financial benefit gained from a contravention. A separate offence can carry a fine of up to $500,000.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: If the OEB or regulations set prices, retailers could not charge more than the applicable maximum. The bill does not require prices to fall or guarantee a particular price.
  • Retailers: They would have to follow the maximum price and keep sales records. They could face inspections, administrative penalties or prosecution for breaking the price rules.
  • Wholesalers: They would have to sell at prices that allow the required retailer mark-up, and keep sales records. They could face inspections and penalties or prosecution.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new consumer benefit, tax or fee. It creates price-setting and enforcement powers. The bill does not explain how those powers would work alongside current rules; the supplied material does not include the current law for comparison.
  • Status: The bill text says it would start on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not say whether it received Royal Assent.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require wholesalers and retailers to keep records, but gives no estimate of their costs.
  • The OEB may appoint inspectors and administer complaints, inspections and penalties. The bill gives no estimate of staffing or other public costs.
  • Penalties and fines are authorized, but the material does not say how much would be collected or how that money would be used.

What is unclear#

  • What prices, mark-ups or areas the OEB or regulations would set, and how often they might change, are not stated.
  • The bill does not set out a process for setting prices, including notice, public input, reasons or appeals.
  • The rules for administrative-penalty procedures, reviews and possible reductions are left to regulations.
  • The definition of petroleum product includes furnace oil or stove oil only if regulations prescribe them. The material does not say whether they would be included.
  • The bill does not explain how its price rules would interact with existing rules or programs. The supplied material does not include the current law to check that.
  • The bill gives broad objectives, such as price “reasonableness,” but does not define them.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address unpredictable pricing and practices that may weaken competition or market stability.
  • A maximum retail price could limit how much retailers charge, while a minimum mark-up could protect a minimum difference between wholesale and retail prices.
  • Allowing different prices and mark-ups in different areas could let the rules account for differences between parts of Ontario.
  • Record-keeping and inspection powers could help the OEB check whether sellers follow the rules.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how prices or mark-ups would be calculated. Without that detail, the effect on consumers and sellers is hard to judge.
  • Price limits could affect how wholesalers and retailers set prices, but the bill does not explain how the OEB would balance consumer prices with market stability and competition.
  • The OEB would have broad inspection powers, and penalties could reach $100,000 for each day or part of a day, plus the financial benefit gained. The bill leaves important penalty procedures to regulations.
  • The bill does not provide cost estimates or explain how the OEB would be staffed and funded.