Summary#
Bill 89, the Teach the Reach Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its goal is to make the Dutch reach method part of driver education and testing; it does not require drivers to use the method.
- The Ministry must ensure the method is recommended in official driving handbooks, manuals or study guides it prepares or endorses.
- Approved or licensed in-car and classroom driver education courses must teach the method as a preferred way to open a door when leaving a vehicle parallel parked on a highway.
- The Ministry must include the method in the written driver’s examination where appropriate, as part of questions about safe driving around bicyclists.
- The method involves checking for traffic, reaching across the body to open the door, checking again, then opening the door fully and exiting. Variations are allowed.
- The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- People learning to drive: If the bill became law, the method would be included in the specified learning materials and approved courses. The written test would cover it where appropriate.
- Drivers generally: The bill does not require drivers to use the method and creates no new offence or penalty for opening a door another way.
- Driver education providers: Approved or licensed courses must teach the method as a preferred way to exit a parallel-parked vehicle.
- Ministry: It must ensure the method is included in the specified materials, courses and, where appropriate, the written examination.
- Cyclists: The bill states that the method is intended to reduce the risk of injury to bicyclists approaching from behind. It does not create a new right or service for cyclists.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.
- The Ministry would have to ensure the required changes to learning materials, courses and examinations. The bill provides no cost estimate or staffing details.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current Highway Traffic Act, so I could not verify what driver education or testing rules already require.
- The bill does not explain what makes including the method on a written examination “appropriate.”
- It does not set out how the Ministry would check that approved or licensed courses teach the method, or report on whether the requirements are met.
- It does not say how much updating materials, courses or tests would cost.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it gives learners consistent guidance on checking for approaching traffic before opening a vehicle door.
- Including the method in both instruction and written testing could make it more likely that learners encounter it as part of safe driving around bicyclists.
- The bill allows variations on the listed steps, rather than requiring only one exact sequence.
Case against#
- The bill does not require drivers to use the method after learning about it, so its practical effect would depend on whether people apply it.
- The phrase “where appropriate” leaves uncertainty about when the written examination must include the topic.
- The bill requires changes to materials, courses and testing but gives no cost estimate or details about how compliance would be checked.