Protecting Vulnerable Road Users Act

Summary#

Bill 158, the Protecting Vulnerable Road Users Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. It would create a new offence and mandatory sentencing rules for certain drivers who cause or contribute to a vulnerable road user’s death or serious bodily harm by breaking specified road rules. Its stated goal is to address the legal consequences of such collisions.

  • The offence would cover drivers of motor vehicles, other than motor-assisted bicycles, whose listed rule-breaking causes or contributes to death or serious bodily harm.
  • The listed rules cover matters such as intoxication, phone use, speeding, careless driving, traffic signs and lights, sharing the road, and safety near emergency vehicles.
  • A convicted driver would face the penalty and other consequences for the rule they broke, plus mandatory probation for up to one year. The probation must require a driving course and 50 to 200 hours of community service that includes work related to driving safety.
  • The driver’s licence would be suspended for the probation period. The driver must attend sentencing, and the court must consider relevant victim impact statements.
  • The bill would let regulations add other protected individuals and set requirements for driving courses.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers: The offence could apply if you cause or contribute to a listed person’s death or serious bodily harm by breaking one or more listed road rules. The bill says the offence is not one of absolute liability (a conviction would not follow automatically just from proving the rule was broken). A conviction would bring the rule’s existing penalty and consequences, plus the new mandatory probation conditions.
  • People protected by the offence: The listed groups are pedestrians; people riding bicycles or motor-assisted bicycles; people using qualifying wheelchairs or other mobility devices; people doing construction, maintenance, repair, or similar work on a highway; and specified police, fire, ambulance, and emergency-response workers acting in their duties and outside the listed vehicles. Regulations could add other individuals.
  • Drivers on probation: A breach of the probation order could lead to a fine of up to $50,000; a licence or permit suspension of up to two years may also be imposed. A court may extend probation by up to one additional year if the driver fails to complete the course or service but shows good cause.
  • Courts: Sentencing proceedings must be started by laying an information, not by filing a certificate of offence. The bill does not create a new agency or a compensation payment for injured people.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change ordinary road users’ duties unless they are drivers covered by the new offence.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires driving courses and community service after conviction, but does not say who pays for the course or how service placements would be arranged.
  • Court and enforcement costs, and any public staffing needs, are not estimated. The bill does not set an appropriation or a new fee.

What is unclear#

  • The current Highway Traffic Act was not supplied, so the existing penalties and consequences for the listed rule violations, and how the new offence would interact with current law, could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define “serious bodily harm.”
  • It does not set course requirements itself; regulations may do so. It also does not explain who provides courses or arranges community service.
  • The bill does not state who pays for the course, or estimate the public cost of the new court and enforcement work.
  • The supplied material does not establish whether the bill passed or received Royal Assent. It would start six months after Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address serious harm caused when drivers break road rules, by adding consequences beyond the penalty for the underlying violation.
  • A possible argument for the mandatory course and safety-related community service is that they connect the sentence to driving behaviour and public safety.
  • Requiring licence suspension during probation and personal attendance at sentencing could make the consequences more direct for convicted drivers.

Case against#

  • The added probation, course, community service, and licence suspension would be mandatory after conviction, even though the bill does not set out how courts should tailor those conditions to different circumstances.
  • The bill does not explain how courses or community service would be provided or paid for, leaving important practical and cost questions open.
  • The new offence covers many different road rules and protected groups; without the parent Act, it is not possible to assess fully how its added penalties would fit with existing consequences.