Democracy education and voting reforms bill

Summary#

Bill 96, the Democratic Participation Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Education Act, Election Act, Municipal Elections Act, 1996 and Taxation Act, 2007. Its stated goal is to support informed democratic participation. The supplied material does not say whether the bill became law, so this describes proposed changes, not confirmed current law.

  • The Education Minister would have to require democracy education in each grade and mock elections during general federal or provincial elections. Mock-election materials would cover parties that received at least 10 per cent of the vote in the previous election.
  • The bill would lower the provincial voting age to 16 starting January 1, 2022. Municipalities could, but would not have to, lower their own voting age to 16 by bylaw, no earlier than that date.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer would become Ontario’s single address authority. Municipalities would have to cooperate, and the Chief Electoral Officer could make rules for the system, subject to the Lieutenant Governor in Council’s approval.
  • Elections Ontario would have to study several possible election reforms, including a provincial election-day holiday, voting solely by mail, limits on published polls, and mandatory voting. The bill does not itself make those changes.
  • The bill would require ranked-ballot voting in specified provincial by-elections and in the ten electoral districts where winners had the lowest vote percentages in the previous general election.
  • The Finance Minister would have to send a spending-and-benefits statement to each individual who filed a taxpayer’s return. Three officials would have to certify that it meets the bill’s requirements and is accurate.

What it means for you#

  • Students and schools: The curriculum would have to include democracy education in every grade and prepare students to vote by age 16. The bill requires mock elections at an “appropriate age,” but does not specify that age.
  • Provincial voters aged 16 or 17: The bill would make them eligible to vote in provincial elections starting January 1, 2022. It would not automatically make them eligible in municipal elections.
  • Municipalities: A municipality could pass a bylaw allowing 16- and 17-year-olds to vote in municipal elections. It would also have to cooperate with the Chief Electoral Officer on the single address authority system.
  • Voters in the pilot elections: By-elections starting after the relevant section comes into force and before the next general election would use ranked ballots. The pilot would also apply in the ten specified electoral districts. The pilot provision would end five years after it comes into force.
  • People shown in election records as not voting: For the first two general elections after the relevant provision comes into force, the Chief Electoral Officer would have to make best efforts to send them a notice asking for feedback about mandatory voting and why they did not vote. The bill does not require them to respond.
  • People who file a taxpayer’s return: They would receive an outline of provincial spending over the previous four fiscal years, including debt maintenance, and an outline of tax benefits, rebates or other benefits they received in the tax year covered by the return.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.

  • The bill assigns work to the Education Minister, the Chief Electoral Officer, municipalities, the Finance Minister and the three officials who must certify the statements, but gives no staffing or cost figures.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer’s study must consider possible business costs and savings to the electoral system from an election-day holiday. The bill does not estimate either.
  • The bill does not set a new tax, fee or fine, or provide a spending appropriation in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the four Acts are not supplied, so the existing rules and the full effect of the amendments cannot be checked against current law.
  • The bill does not set out the single address system’s design, the regulations it would need, or how municipalities would carry out their cooperation duties.
  • It does not set deadlines or methods for the Chief Electoral Officer’s studies, or explain what would happen after the reports.
  • It does not explain how the ranked-ballot rules in the Municipal Elections Act, 1996 would work in provincial elections; that Act and its relevant rules are not supplied.
  • The bill does not explain how the tax statements would be prepared, delivered or corrected, or how the three officials would carry out their certifications.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give students more preparation for voting, using classroom education and mock elections.
  • A single address authority could give election administration one central office for this task, while requiring municipal cooperation.
  • Studying possible reforms before adopting them could help identify their feasibility, effects and costs.
  • A limited ranked-ballot pilot could provide experience with that voting method before any wider change.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how the single address system would work or how much work municipalities would have to do.
  • The mock-election materials would cover parties above a 10 per cent threshold, leaving out parties below that threshold.
  • The ranked-ballot pilot is limited in time and location, which may limit what it can show about the method.
  • The tax statement would require certification by the Deputy Minister of Finance, the Financial Accountability Officer and the Chief Justice of Ontario, but the bill does not explain their respective roles or how disagreements would be handled.