Election rules overhaul for youth register

Summary#

Bill 45, the Election Statute Law Amendment Act, 2016, became law. It amends Ontario’s Election Act, Election Finances Act, Education Act and Representation Act, 2015. Its stated goal is to change provincial election rules, including election dates, voter information, nominations and electoral boundaries.

  • General elections are scheduled for the first Thursday in June in the fourth calendar year after the last general election, subject to the Lieutenant Governor’s powers. The bill also changes advance-poll rules.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer may require vote-counting equipment and modify the voting process to allow its use. The equipment must meet testing, privacy and network restrictions.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer must create an opt-in provisional register for eligible 16- and 17-year-olds. The bill also changes what voter information is shared and with whom.
  • New nomination rules set out required paperwork and steps for candidates. The bill also gives candidates and their representatives access to common areas in many multi-residence buildings, subject to conditions and exceptions.
  • A Far North Electoral Boundaries Commission must recommend whether to create one or two additional electoral districts in specified northern areas and recommend boundaries and names for those districts. A minister must introduce legislation to implement its final recommendations by October 30, 2017.
  • Municipalities, school boards and provincially funded institutions that provide polling premises must make them acceptable to the returning officer and provide them free of charge.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: If you are 16 or 17, a Canadian citizen and an Ontario resident, you may ask to join the provisional register and must provide proof of identity. You cannot vote before you are eligible; the information is transferred to the permanent register when the Chief Electoral Officer knows you will be 18 by polling day.
  • Voters and political parties: Voters may ask the Chief Electoral Officer to redact information that the officer reasonably believes could endanger their life, health or security. Parties must disclose a privacy policy that complies with published guidelines to receive the permanent register. Parties and candidates may opt out of receiving specified voter information.
  • Voters and parties: Information provided from voter lists is generally limited to names, unique identifiers and addresses, subject to exceptions in the Act. Parties also receive a list showing whether each elector voted. Poll clerks must prepare updated lists during polling day, excluding electors who registered that day.
  • Candidates and residents of multi-residence buildings: Owners and condominium corporations generally must allow candidates or authorized representatives into common areas to distribute materials and seek contact with residents, within stated hours and subject to identification and other rules. Exceptions include certain residences and cases where residents’ well-being may be harmed. Returning officers may impose escalating penalties for violations.
  • Candidates: A nomination must include at least 25 electors’ names and addresses, among other details. A candidate may be nominated in only one district. The rules also allow a candidate to request an ordinarily used name on the ballot.
  • General public: The bill changes election administration; it does not give 16- and 17-year-olds the right to vote or guarantee that new northern districts will be created. The Commission makes recommendations; a minister must introduce implementing legislation, but the bill does not itself enact those boundary changes.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total cost.

  • The Commission’s costs, including permitted staff and member expenses, are charged to the Consolidated Revenue Fund. No estimate or staffing level is given.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer may provide equipment, advice, staff or other resources to other electoral authorities. Revenue from this work goes to the Consolidated Revenue Fund.
  • Administrative penalties are paid into the Consolidated Revenue Fund. Municipalities, school boards and provincially funded institutions must provide acceptable polling premises free of charge; their costs are not estimated.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so I could not verify all pre-bill rules or how the bill’s changes interact with the full existing law.
  • The bill does not set a budget or staff level for the Commission, or explain the likely cost of supplying free polling premises.
  • It does not specify how the Chief Electoral Officer will choose when to require vote-counting equipment or how any modified voting process will work in practice.
  • It does not state how the Commission will involve Indigenous communities beyond requiring two members who identify as Indigenous and considering representation of Indigenous people.
  • The bill sets rules for voter information but does not explain how the privacy guidelines will be applied in individual cases.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to update election administration and set clearer rules for nominations, advance polls and voter information.
  • A provisional register could let 16- and 17-year-olds register before they become eligible to vote, while requiring their own request and proof of identity.
  • Equipment testing and limits on network connections and disclosure of an elector’s choice are safeguards written into the bill.
  • Access rules for many multi-residence buildings could give candidates a way to reach residents who may otherwise be difficult to contact.
  • A Commission with a specific northern mandate and required public hearings could examine whether the current district boundaries should change.

Case against#

  • Sharing voter information, including whether people voted, raises privacy concerns even though the bill limits much of the information and provides for some redactions.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer can require vote-counting equipment and modify the voting process, while the bill does not fully spell out how that power will be used.
  • The bill requires a Commission and charges its costs to public funds without giving a cost estimate.
  • The access rules and penalties could burden building owners or condominium corporations; the bill relies on exceptions and an appeal process to address some cases.
  • The Commission can recommend new districts, but the bill does not guarantee that its recommendations will become law.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2016120801

    Passed91 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 45

    FOR · 91

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    91For

    • Liberal51
    • PC24
    • NDP16

    0Against

  2. Division No. 2016111601

    Passed82 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 45

    FOR · 46AGAINST · 36

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    46For

    • Liberal46

    36Against

    • PC22
    • NDP14
  3. Division No. 2016111602

    Passed84 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 45

    FOR · 84

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    84For

    • Liberal47
    • PC23
    • NDP14

    0Against