Bill updates church land rules

Summary#

Bill PR10, The United Church of Canada Act, 2019, amends Ontario’s existing The United Church of Canada Act (1925); it does not create a new organization or public program. Its stated goal is to update Ontario law to reflect changes to the church’s governance structure. The Act took effect on Royal Assent.

  • It updates definitions to refer to the church’s Regional Council and Denominational Council, and to include successor church bodies established through the process in the church’s Basis of Union.
  • It lets the church’s trustees, or a majority of them, sell, mortgage, hypothecate (pledge as security), exchange or lease certain church lands—but only with written consent from the Regional Council for the area.
  • Trustees must apply transaction proceeds to the congregation’s purposes as its Official Board directs, after paying or providing for the trustees’ debts. If the congregation has ceased to exist as an organized body, the remaining proceeds go to the United Church for its benefit, with their use determined by the Regional Council under Denominational Council rules.
  • At least five members of an affected congregation may appeal a Regional Council decision about a property transaction to the Denominational Council.

What it means for you#

  • United Church trustees: They may pursue the listed property transactions, but need written Regional Council consent. Their application must state how the money will be used.
  • Regional Councils: They decide whether to consent to those transactions. The bill does not set a deadline or detailed test for their decisions.
  • Members of an affected congregation: At least five members may appeal a Regional Council decision to the Denominational Council.
  • Buyers, lenders and tenants: If the required council consent is obtained, they do not have to check whether the transaction was necessary or proper, or how trustees use the money. A council secretary’s or clerk’s certificate is conclusive evidence that consent was given.
  • Other Ontarians: The Act does not directly change public taxes, benefits or general property rules.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The Act does not state a public spending amount, create a tax or fee, or set a fine.
  • It governs how proceeds from certain church property transactions are handled. No publicly available information on the value of affected property or transactions.

What is unclear#

  • The 1925 parent Act was not supplied, so the earlier wording and the full change from current law could not be verified.
  • The consent rules, timelines and decision standards of Regional Councils are not set out here. The Act requires a written application stating the intended use of proceeds.
  • The appeal process is not detailed beyond allowing at least five affected congregation members to appeal to the Denominational Council.
  • The Basis of Union and the Denominational Council’s rules are not supplied, so the details of the governance process and proceeds rules cannot be checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make Ontario’s statute fit the United Church’s restructured governance.
  • Requiring Regional Council consent gives a regional church body a role before trustees make major property transactions.
  • Requiring the application to state how proceeds will be used, and allowing an appeal by congregation members, provides some checks on those decisions.
  • Letting buyers, lenders and tenants rely on a council’s consent certificate may make transactions more certain.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set standards or a deadline for Regional Council consent, so the decision process may be hard to predict.
  • An appeal requires at least five members, and the bill does not describe how the appeal is handled.
  • The bill gives Regional Councils a role in deciding how proceeds are used if a congregation has ceased to exist, but the applicable Denominational Council rules are not included here.