Summary#
Bill 88, the Planning Amendment Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Planning Act. The bill’s stated purpose is to amend that Act; the supplied material does not give a separate policy goal. If enacted, it would change rules for land division and consent applications, and would take effect on Royal Assent.
- The Minister could remove a municipal council’s powers under the affected land-division and consent rules for named applications or for all future consent and validation-certificate applications. The Minister must give a written explanation.
- Owners, chargees (people or lenders with a legal claim over land) and purchasers, or their authorized agents, could apply for consent. Applicants could amend applications before a decision, and councils or the Minister could allow one extension of up to a year to meet consent conditions.
- Councils or the Minister could give provisional consent with conditions. They would have to give extra notice of an amended application unless they consider the change minor.
- The bill would revise rules for dealing with parts of registered subdivisions, including rules about abutting land, mortgages, foreclosures and powers of appointment. It would also let some remaining land be dealt with before other parts, if a related certificate has not lapsed.
- A consent could be cancelled by a certificate requested by a landowner. Once registered, the certificate would make specified land-division rules apply to later dealings with that parcel.
- A contravention of the land-division rules more than 20 years old would no longer prevent a conveyance or creation of an interest in the land, subject to an exception for rights from certain court proceedings.
What it means for you#
- Landowners, purchasers and chargees: You could apply for consent, but the bill does not guarantee that consent will be granted. A landowner could apply to cancel a consent; the cancellation would affect later dealings after the certificate is registered.
- Consent applicants: You could amend an application before a decision. You could also apply, before the original one-year deadline expires, for one extension of up to a year to meet conditions. The council’s or Minister’s decision on that extension could not be appealed or reviewed.
- People dealing with land: A breach of the Act’s land-division rules that occurred more than 20 years before the land is dealt with would not block a conveyance or creation of an interest, unless the exception for court rights applies.
- Municipal councils: The Minister could take away the council’s powers for specified applications or for all future applications covered by the order.
- The bill does not create a new agency, front-line service, tax or fee. The supplied text does not set out fees.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill changes tasks and powers for councils and the Minister, but gives no staffing or funding estimate.
- No revenue, savings, fees or fines are specified.
What is unclear#
- The parent Planning Act was not supplied, so the bill’s changes cannot be checked against the full current law here.
- The bill does not define when an amendment is “sufficiently minor” to avoid extra notice.
- It does not set out the application process, timelines or appeal rights for consent decisions generally.
- The bill does not explain how councils or the Minister would use the power to remove municipal powers, beyond requiring a written explanation.
- The bill revises several technical land-division rules; the exact effect of those changes alongside the existing Act is not verifiable from the supplied material.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that allowing purchasers and chargees to apply could let more parties with a direct interest in land seek consent.
- Allowing amendments and a one-time extension could give applicants a way to address changed circumstances or complete conditions without starting over. The bill leaves the terms of amendments to the council or Minister.
- The 20-year rule could prevent old contraventions from blocking later dealings with land indefinitely, while preserving rights established through the specified court proceedings.
- The Minister’s power to remove municipal authority could allow applications to be handled outside the council in the cases covered by an order.
Case against#
- The bill gives the Minister broad power to remove municipal authority, including for all future applications in a category, without setting out criteria for when that should happen.
- Councils or the Minister could decide whether an amendment is minor enough to avoid extra notice; the bill does not spell out a test.
- The bill allows a decision on an extension to be made without appeal or review, limiting a way to challenge that decision.
- The 20-year rule could allow a conveyance or new interest despite an old breach; the practical effect on affected parties is not explained in the supplied material.