Youth Pandemic Recovery Plan Proposed

Summary#

Bill 113 would enact a new law, the Centering Youth in Pandemic Recovery Act, 2022. It would require the Premier to publish a youth recovery action plan and create a COVID-19 Recovery Youth Secretariat to help carry it out and review legislation and regulations for their potential effects on young people. The bill’s stated goal is to put children, youth and young adults at the centre of pandemic recovery and support their well-being.

  • The Premier must consult youth leaders—predominantly from equity-seeking groups—and experts in education, child development and mental health when developing the plan.
  • The plan must include ongoing data collection, goals for addressing pandemic effects and structural inequalities, and a plan to coordinate related programs and services across ministries.
  • The Premier must review the plan every two years, consult the named groups and may amend it.
  • The Secretariat must review every bill introduced in the Legislature and every new regulation for potential effects on children, youth and young adults. It must assist with the plan and report to a standing committee.
  • A standing committee of the Legislative Assembly, with party representation proportional to the Legislature, must review the plan and Secretariat research and report to the Assembly every two years.

What it means for you#

  • Young people and families: The bill creates no direct benefit, service, application process or individual right. Youth leaders would be consulted on the plan, but the bill does not give every young person a way to take part.
  • Groups named in the plan: Data collection must address effects on Black, Indigenous and other racialized youth; low-income youth; LGBTQ2S+ youth; youth with disabilities; newcomer and refugee youth; and youth in care. The bill does not set out how that data is collected.
  • Premier and government: The Premier must produce and review the plan. The plan must set out a way to coordinate relevant ministry programs and services, but the bill does not itself require ministries to change or deliver particular programs.
  • Legislature and public: The Secretariat must review bills and new regulations for potential effects on young people. The bill does not require the Secretariat to recommend changes or require the government to act on its reviews.

Money#

The bill creates a Secretariat and assigns it work, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • It states no budget, funding source or staffing level for the Secretariat.
  • It creates no tax, fee, fine or direct payment to young people.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “children,” “youth” or “young adults,” or set a deadline for publishing the first plan.
  • It does not say what counts as a clear goal, or how progress toward goals would be measured.
  • It does not set rules for collecting, storing or sharing the required data.
  • It does not say what must happen after the Secretariat reviews a bill or regulation, or whether those reviews will be made public.
  • “Bi-annually” is used for Secretariat reports to the committee; the bill does not make clear whether that means twice a year or every two years.
  • The supplied material does not describe current requirements for youth recovery planning, so the extent of change from current practice cannot be verified.

Case for#

  • The bill recognizes that the pandemic may have affected young people’s education, health and opportunities, and specifically calls for attention to groups it identifies as disproportionately affected.
  • A plan spanning ministries could help address problems that cross areas such as health, education and social services.
  • Reviewing bills and regulations for their potential effects on young people could bring those effects into policy discussions earlier.
  • Regular reviews by the Premier and a legislative committee could create recurring opportunities to examine the plan and related research.

Case against#

  • The bill requires a plan and goals but does not require particular services, spending, targets or outcomes. The plan could therefore leave the practical response uncertain.
  • The Secretariat’s reviews do not have to lead to changes in bills or regulations, and the bill does not require the government to explain what it does with the findings.
  • The bill gives no details on how youth leaders will be selected or how young people outside those consultations can contribute.
  • The bill does not set out funding, staffing, data protections or clear measures for judging whether the plan is working.