Climate-Health Plan Bill Aims Public Sector Action

Summary#

Bill 121, the No Time to Waste Act (Plan for Climate Action and Jobs), 2022, would create three new Acts; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to prepare health services for climate-related health risks, set a climate strategy for the public sector, and have a legislative committee propose a broader response.

  • The Health Minister would have to publish a climate-and-health plan within two years, review it at least every four years, and consult specified groups when developing or revising it.
  • The plan would have to cover health risks, vulnerable communities, research programs, priority health infrastructure, monitoring, and plans for funding and guidance to public health units and health care facilities.
  • The Minister would have to establish a Climate Crisis and Health Secretariat, directed by the Health and Environment Ministers, and a 10-to-20-member science advisory board.
  • The government would have to establish a public-sector climate strategy within one year. The strategy would set out plans toward emissions and building-energy goals, and include retrofitting and vehicle programs and purchasing guidelines.
  • A legislative select committee would have to propose a response to climate-related threats within six months, including threats facing Indigenous, racialized and low-income Ontarians. It would not be required to implement its proposal.

What it means for you#

  • Health services and the public: The bill requires a plan to identify health risks and vulnerable populations, and to set out ways to communicate health strategies. It does not itself require people, health workers or facilities to follow particular health measures.
  • Public health units and health care facilities: The plan must include a plan for providing them funding and guidance to assess vulnerabilities and develop adaptation plans. This is not an automatic funding entitlement or a specified amount.
  • Municipalities and First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities: The Secretariat would have to provide technical assistance and support to them in assessing preparedness and response strategies. The bill does not set out how they would request or receive that help.
  • Public-sector organizations and suppliers: The strategy would set goals to cap public-sector emissions within 12 months after it takes effect and reduce them by at least 5 per cent each year until net zero. It would also set energy goals for new public-sector facilities and require purchasing guidelines that can disqualify proposals based on higher emissions. These are goals and plans for the strategy; the bill does not set out penalties for failing to meet them.
  • Taxpayers and the wider public: The bill creates no tax, fee, fine, personal emissions limit or direct climate-related benefit. It does not promise jobs or require a particular number of jobs to be created.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires a Secretariat, an advisory board, government research programs, annual public-sector energy reports and audits, but gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • The health plan must include plans for funding and guidance, but the bill sets no amount or funding source.
  • The public-sector strategy includes retrofitting and vehicle programs, but the bill does not state their cost.

What is unclear#

  • The public-sector definition refers to the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996. That Act was not supplied, so the bill’s coverage of organizations cannot be checked against current law.
  • The bill leaves the actual emissions cap, how emissions will be measured, and important details of the building-energy comparisons to the strategy or later regulations.
  • It does not specify how health-plan funding will be allocated, who will qualify, or how decisions can be challenged.
  • It does not set out the Secretariat’s size, budget, or procedures, or say how affected communities will be involved beyond consultation on the health plan.
  • No bill status or passage information is supplied, so it is unclear whether these proposed measures are in force.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make health planning account for climate-related risks, including extreme heat, illness, air quality, food insecurity and disruptions to care.
  • Requiring monitoring, scientific advice and regular plan reviews could help government update its response as risks and evidence change.
  • A public-sector strategy could use government buildings, vehicles and purchasing decisions to pursue emissions and energy goals, while public reports and audits would provide some accountability.
  • A committee proposal could bring climate-related threats to society, the environment and the economy into one broader review.

Case against#

  • The bill sets ambitious goals but leaves key measures and methods to the strategy and regulations. The emissions goal, for example, has no specified starting cap or measurement method in the bill.
  • The bill requires plans and programs but does not specify funding, staff, delivery timelines for many actions, or penalties if goals are missed.
  • It is unclear how the proposed health programs and assistance would work in practice, or how the required consultation would affect decisions.
  • The public-sector purchasing rules could disqualify proposals based on emissions, but the bill leaves the comparison method and details to regulations.