Summary#
Bill 87, Black Mental Health Day Act, 2022, would proclaim an annual day and amend Ontario’s Anti-Racism Act, 2017 and Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care Act. Its stated goal is to raise awareness of Black mental health and improve how health services respond to racial inequities.
- The first Monday in March each year would be proclaimed Black Mental Health Day.
- The Ministry of Health, Ministry of Long-Term Care, Ontario Health and any person funded by the Ontario government to provide health care services would have to take all reasonable steps to ensure information about patients’ race is collected.
- The bill would deem the data standards and regulations to require collection of personal information necessary for that purpose, unless they already provide for it.
- The Minister of Health would have a duty to ensure health services are provided in a culturally appropriate manner.
What it means for you#
- Black Ontarians: The bill sets a public awareness day and adds duties related to race information and culturally appropriate services. It does not guarantee a particular service, treatment or health outcome.
- Health care providers receiving Ontario government funding: They would have to take all reasonable steps to ensure patients’ race information is collected. The bill does not say patients must provide that information.
- The two ministries and Ontario Health: They would have the same collection duty. The Minister of Health would also have the duty to ensure culturally appropriate health services.
- General public: The bill does not create a new individual benefit, establish a new health service or set a penalty for failing to collect the information.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s costs.
- The bill requires collection-related steps but gives no cost estimate or specific funding.
- It may require staff time or changes to data systems; that is an inference, and the bill does not say what would be needed.
What is unclear#
- The full text of the two Acts is not supplied, so the bill’s changes cannot be checked against current law. The bill’s explanatory note says there is currently no coordinated approach or requirement to collect race-based health data.
- “All reasonable steps” and “culturally appropriate” are not defined in the supplied text.
- The bill does not set out how information would be collected, who could access it, how long it would be kept, or how it would be used.
- It does not set out oversight, reporting, timelines or a way to address non-compliance.
- No publicly available information explains how patients or Black communities would be involved in setting or assessing the approach.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to help identify racial differences in health outcomes by requiring collection of information about patients’ race.
- Having the same duty apply to the named ministries, Ontario Health and funded health care providers could support a more coordinated approach.
- A ministerial duty to ensure culturally appropriate services could direct attention to whether services respond to the diversity of Black communities.
- An annual awareness day could draw attention to the mental health effects of anti-Black racism. The bill does not guarantee that it will do so.
Case against#
- The bill requires race information to be collected but does not set out safeguards or rules for access and use. Those details may be addressed elsewhere, but the supplied material does not show how.
- “All reasonable steps” leaves providers uncertain about what they must do to meet the duty.
- The bill creates a duty to ensure culturally appropriate services without defining the term or setting out how the duty would be carried out or assessed.
- The bill does not specify funding for the new duties, so the cost to government and funded providers is unknown.