Bill would collect race data in health care

Summary#

Bill 32, the Black Mental Health Day Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Anti-Racism Act, 2017 and Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care Act. Its stated goal is to raise awareness of Black mental health and address inequities in health services; the bill does not guarantee a particular outcome.

  • It would proclaim the first Monday in March each year as Black Mental Health Day.
  • The Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Long-Term Care, Ontario Health and anyone funded by Ontario to provide health care services would have to take all reasonable steps to ensure information about patients’ race is collected.
  • Unless already covered by existing data standards and regulations, those standards would be treated as listing the personal information needed for that collection, and the regulations as requiring its collection.
  • The Minister’s listed duties would include ensuring health services are provided in a culturally appropriate manner.
  • The bill would repeal a provision of the Anti-Racism Act, 2017, but the supplied material does not show what that provision currently does.

What it means for you#

  • Black Ontarians and other patients: Health organizations covered by the bill would have a duty to take reasonable steps to collect information about patients’ race. The bill does not require patients themselves to provide it or set out how they would be asked.
  • Health ministries, Ontario Health and funded health-care providers: They would have to take those reasonable steps. The bill does not specify a collection process or require that every patient’s race be recorded.
  • The Minister: The Minister would have a listed duty to ensure culturally appropriate health services. The bill does not set a service standard, create a new service, or give patients a specific right to a particular type of care.
  • The public: The annual day would be proclaimed by law. The bill does not require events, education campaigns or other activities on that day.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill creates duties for government bodies and funded health-care providers, but gives no estimate of staffing, data-collection or other costs.
  • It does not specify new funding, fees, fines or savings.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so the current rules and the effect of repealing subsection 6(7) of the Anti-Racism Act, 2017 could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain what counts as “all reasonable steps” or how compliance would be checked.
  • It does not set out how race information would be collected, protected, stored, shared or used.
  • It does not explain how the duty to ensure culturally appropriate health services would be carried out or measured.
  • The bill says it would come into force on Royal Assent; the supplied material does not establish whether or when that has occurred.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the stated lack of a coordinated requirement to collect race-related health information. Such information could help inform health policy and service planning.
  • A duty to take reasonable steps applies across named health bodies and Ontario-funded health-care providers, rather than relying only on voluntary collection.
  • The Minister’s added duty and the annual day could give attention to culturally appropriate care and Black mental health needs.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set clear collection, privacy or oversight rules. That leaves important details about how sensitive personal information would be handled unresolved.
  • “All reasonable steps” is not defined in the bill, so providers may not know what is required or how compliance will be judged.
  • The Minister’s duty to ensure culturally appropriate services is not paired with a service standard, timeline or stated funding.
  • Without details on how information would be used, collection alone may not lead to changes in care.