Summary#
Bill 109, the Hands Off the Greenbelt Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Greenbelt Act, 2005. Its stated goal is to prevent land from being removed from the Greenbelt Area or from protections under the Greenbelt Plan.
- The Minister and the Lieutenant Governor in Council (Ontario’s cabinet acting formally) could not take any action under the Act that removes land from the Greenbelt Area, removes land from the Plan’s application, or removes its Protected Countryside designation.
- Anything done in breach of that restriction would be deemed never to have been done.
- Ontario Regulation 567/22, which amended the regulation designating the Greenbelt Area, would be deemed never to have been made or filed.
- The restrictions would apply retroactively from December 13, 2022. The bill also repeals three provisions of the Act; their existing effects cannot be verified from the materials provided.
What it means for you#
- Ontario government: The Minister and cabinet would be barred from making changes under the Act that have one of the three listed effects. The bill does not bar every possible change to the Greenbelt Plan.
- People and land affected by Ontario Regulation 567/22: The regulation would be treated as never made, so its amendment would have no legal effect under the bill. The materials do not identify the specific land or explain what steps would follow.
- Other landowners and the public: The bill does not create an application process, benefit, fine, or front-line service. It also does not set out a process for deciding individual land claims.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill mentions no appropriation, fee, fine, staffing requirement, or cost estimate.
What is unclear#
- The Greenbelt Act, 2005 was not supplied, so the effect of repealing its three provisions—and how the bill would interact with the rest of the Act—could not be checked.
- The bill does not identify the specific land affected by Ontario Regulation 567/22 or explain how the retroactive date would be applied in practice.
- It does not set out a process, timeline, appeal, or oversight method for resolving disputes about whether an action breaches the restriction.
- The bill’s passage status is not provided.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent the provincial government from shrinking the Greenbelt through actions under the Act.
- Treating a prohibited action as never done would give the restriction a clear legal effect, rather than only setting a rule for future decisions.
- Applying the change from December 13, 2022, and voiding Ontario Regulation 567/22 would address that regulation directly.
Case against#
- The restriction gives the Minister and cabinet no stated exception to remove land, even if a future government considers a change necessary.
- The bill does not explain the practical steps or dispute process for applying its retroactive effect.
- Repealing three provisions without the parent Act in the supplied material makes it difficult to assess what other existing powers or rules would change.