Summary#
Bill 111, the No More Pits or Quarries in the Greenbelt Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Greenbelt Act, 2005. Its stated goal is to prohibit applications for new pits or quarries in the Greenbelt Area and expansions of existing ones.
- It would deem the Greenbelt Plan to prohibit anyone from applying for an aggregate permit to operate a new pit or quarry in the Greenbelt Area.
- It would also deem the Plan to prohibit anyone from expanding an existing pit or quarry there.
- It would define “pit” and “quarry” by reference to the Aggregate Resources Act.
- It would change wording in another part of the Greenbelt Act from “Protected Countryside” to “Greenbelt Area.”
- If passed, the bill would take effect on Royal Assent. The text does not say it would cancel existing permits or require existing pits or quarries to close.
What it means for you#
- People or businesses seeking permits: They would be prohibited from applying for an aggregate permit to operate a new pit or quarry in the Greenbelt Area.
- Operators of existing pits or quarries: They would be prohibited from expanding them in the Greenbelt Area. The bill does not say existing operations must stop.
- People generally: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, or individual rights outside these restrictions on pit and quarry applications and expansions.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill contains no stated spending amount, fee, fine, or funding provision.
- No estimate is provided for any costs to government, applicants, or existing operators.
What is unclear#
- The Greenbelt Act, 2005 and Aggregate Resources Act were not supplied, so the bill’s changes cannot be checked against the full current law or the Acts’ definitions.
- The text does not explain how the change to “Greenbelt Area” in the other part of the Act affects its rules.
- It does not set out application handling, enforcement, exceptions, appeals, or oversight for the new prohibitions.
- The bill does not say how it would apply to applications already underway.
- No publicly available information.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent new pits and quarries, and expansions of existing ones, within the Greenbelt Area.
- A clear prohibition could avoid case-by-case applications for those activities in the area.
- Defining “pit” and “quarry” by reference to the Aggregate Resources Act links those terms to another statute rather than leaving them to be interpreted without a legal reference.
Case against#
- The bill would bar applications for new operations and expansions without setting out exceptions or a way to consider individual proposals.
- The text does not explain how the prohibitions would be enforced or how applications already underway would be handled.
- Because the parent Acts were not supplied, the effect of the change from “Protected Countryside” to “Greenbelt Area” cannot be verified here.