Summary#
Bill 113, the Mount Pleasant Public Cemeteries Act, 2023, would repeal 11 listed Acts and continue the existing corporation known as the Mount Pleasant Group of Cemeteries under a new name. Its stated charitable objects include operating cemeteries and crematoriums, providing visitation centres, and preserving cemetery lands and their historical features.
- The corporation would be an agent of Ontario’s Crown, and all property it owns or acquires would be property of the Crown.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint the corporation’s board, with up to 10 members. The first board would have up to three members and could not include anyone who is or was a member or director of four named not-for-profit corporations.
- The corporation could exercise the powers of a natural person to carry out its objects, but could not create or acquire a subsidiary. It would need approval from the responsible minister and the Minister of Finance to buy real property or borrow money.
- The Auditor General would audit its accounts and financial transactions. The corporation would have to publish an annual report, and the minister would have to table it in the Legislature.
- Regulations could require the divestment, disposal, sale or lease of property or assets of the corporation or an entity it owns or operates.
What it means for you#
- People who use the cemeteries or crematoriums: The bill does not directly change burial or cremation services, prices, or eligibility. It sets out the corporation’s charitable objects but does not create a new service or application process.
- The corporation and its board: The corporation would continue under a new name, with a board appointed by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. It would have to provide reports and financial information to the government, and publish an annual report.
- The Ontario government: The corporation would be treated as a Crown agent, and its property as Crown property. Ministers would have approval powers over real-property purchases and borrowing.
- The public: The annual report would be publicly available. The bill does not set out what information it must contain beyond what the minister may require and any directives that apply.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.
- The bill allows board members to receive pay and reimbursement for reasonable expenses, with amounts set by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
- The corporation may appoint employees and retain assistance it considers necessary; the bill gives no staffing estimate or cost.
- The bill requires an Auditor General audit but does not state its cost or how it would be funded.
- The corporation would have to provide net-profit reports and forecasts to the government. The bill does not set out how profits would be used.
What is unclear#
- The older Acts being repealed or continued were not supplied, so the bill’s changes from the corporation’s current legal powers, ownership arrangements, and governance could not be verified.
- The bill does not explain how the corporation’s members are chosen or what rights members have.
- The bill allows regulations to require property or assets to be divested, disposed of, sold or leased, but gives no criteria for when or how this would happen.
- The bill requires a memorandum of understanding between the corporation and the minister but does not set out its terms.
- It is unclear how the corporation’s status as a Crown agent and the rule that its property is Crown property would affect existing property arrangements.
Case for#
- The bill could make the corporation’s governance and finances more publicly accountable through government-appointed directors, Auditor General audits, public annual reports, and reports to ministers.
- It gives the corporation clear charitable objects, including cemetery operation, environmentally responsible crematorium facilities, and preservation of historic cemetery lands and gravesites.
- Ministerial approval for real-property purchases and borrowing could provide government oversight of major financial decisions.
Case against#
- The Crown-agent status and Crown-property rule could significantly change the corporation’s legal and property arrangements, but the bill does not explain the practical effects.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint the board, while ministers would have approval and reporting powers. The bill does not set out limits or safeguards for these powers beyond those stated.
- The regulation-making power to require asset divestment or sale is broad; the bill does not specify the circumstances or process for using it.
- Excluding anyone who is or was part of the named organizations from the first board may limit continuity, and the bill does not explain the reason for that restriction.