Cemeteries Bill Creates Crown Agency

Summary#

Bill 74 is the Mount Pleasant Public Cemeteries Act, 2021. It would enact a new Act, continue the existing Mount Pleasant Group of Cemeteries corporation under a new name, and repeal 11 older Acts concerning the Toronto General Burying Grounds. Its stated objects are to operate cemetery-related facilities and preserve the historical and natural features of cemetery lands.

  • The continued corporation would be called Mount Pleasant Public Cemeteries. It would be a charitable corporation, an Ontario public body, and an agent of the Crown; property it owns or acquires would be property of the Crown in right of Ontario.
  • Its objects include operating burial, cemetery and columbarium facilities; providing environmentally responsible crematorium facilities and visitation centres for the funeral home sector; and preserving cemetery history, landscape design, the natural arboretum and cemeteries as National Historic Sites.
  • The corporation would have the legal powers of a natural person to carry out those objects, but could not create or acquire a subsidiary. It could not buy real property or borrow money without approval from the Minister and the Minister of Finance.
  • A board of up to 10 members would be appointed by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. The first board would have up to three members, could not include people who are or were connected to five named cemetery-related not-for-profit corporations, and must be established within 30 days of the Act coming into force.
  • The Auditor General would audit the corporation. It would have to publish an annual report and provide financial and other reports to ministers. Regulations could require the corporation or an entity it owns or operates to divest, dispose of, sell or lease property or assets.

What it means for you#

  • People using the cemeteries: The bill sets out the corporation’s objects, but does not create a new public service, an individual right to a particular service, or rules for access.
  • Funeral home sector: Visitation centres for its use are among the corporation’s objects. The bill does not set out how those centres would operate or who could use them.
  • The corporation and its board: The corporation would have new governance, audit and reporting requirements. Its board would be appointed by the provincial government, and the corporation would need ministerial approval to buy real property or borrow money.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The corporation would be treated as an Ontario public body and Crown agent, and its annual report would be made public and tabled in the Legislature. The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, cemetery prices or burial rights.
  • The supplied material does not include the older Acts or other current-law materials, so the bill’s changes to existing legal arrangements cannot be fully checked against current law.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The corporation may appoint employees and retain assistance, but the bill gives no staffing level or cost.
  • Board members would receive remuneration and expense reimbursement set by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
  • The Auditor General must audit the corporation. No audit cost is stated.
  • The corporation must provide ministers with financial reports, including net profit forecasts. The bill does not state how any profits would be used.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain who the corporation’s members are or how membership is determined, even though the corporation is composed of members and directors must be members.
  • “Environmentally responsible” is not defined. The bill does not set service standards or say how the corporation must meet its stated objects.
  • The bill gives no process or criteria for regulations requiring property or assets to be sold, leased or otherwise disposed of.
  • The bill requires a memorandum of understanding with the Minister but does not set out its terms.
  • The supplied materials do not show how this Act would interact with other laws that apply to cemeteries, or fully establish what changes from current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to put the corporation’s structure and charitable objects into one new Act while continuing its cemetery-related work.
  • A government-appointed board, Auditor General audits and public annual reports could provide clearer public oversight.
  • Requiring ministerial approval for borrowing and property purchases could add oversight of major financial decisions.
  • The stated objects include both cemetery services and preservation of historical and natural features.

Case against#

  • The bill makes all property the corporation owns or acquires property of the Crown in right of Ontario, but the supplied material does not explain the practical or financial effects of that change.
  • Regulations could require property or assets to be sold, leased or otherwise disposed of. The bill does not set criteria or a process for that power.
  • The bill does not specify how members are chosen or how they relate to the government-appointed board.
  • The bill creates reporting and staffing responsibilities but gives no cost estimate or staffing plan.