Rare disease plan to implement 2017 report

Summary#

Bill 129, the Rare Disease Strategy Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Health Protection and Promotion Act. It would require the Government of Ontario to implement recommendations in a 2017 Rare Diseases Working Group report; its stated goal is to address Ontario’s lack of a rare disease strategy.

  • The Government would have to implement the report’s recommendations as soon as practicable.
  • Starting six months after the amendment takes effect, the Government would have to post an update every six months until all recommendations are implemented. The updates must list completed recommendations and steps being taken on the rest.
  • The bill does not itself set out the recommendations or create a specific service, benefit, or eligibility rule.

What it means for you#

  • People with rare diseases and their families: The bill could lead to changes through the report’s recommendations, but the supplied material does not say what those changes are. It does not itself guarantee a particular treatment, service, or benefit.
  • Ontario government: It would have a legal duty to implement the recommendations and publish the required updates.
  • Public: The updates would provide information on implementation, but the bill does not set out a public review or feedback process.

Money#

The bill requires government action, but no cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.

  • The report’s recommendations are not included, so their cost is unknown.
  • The bill gives no budget, staffing requirement, or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • What are the report’s recommendations? The report itself was not supplied.
  • What counts as implementing a recommendation, and who decides when all recommendations have been implemented?
  • What does “as soon as is practicable” require in timing?
  • The supplied material does not include the current Health Protection and Promotion Act, so the bill’s effect compared with current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set out oversight or consequences if the Government does not implement a recommendation or post an update.

Case for#

  • The bill would turn the commitment to act on the 2017 report into a legal duty, rather than leave implementation entirely to the Government’s discretion.
  • Requiring regular public updates could make progress, delays, and remaining work more visible.
  • Using an existing report could give the Government a set of recommendations to implement rather than requiring the bill to spell out a new strategy.

Case against#

  • The bill requires implementation of recommendations that are not listed in its text. Without the report, the public cannot assess what the Government would have to do or what it might cost.
  • The bill does not set deadlines for individual recommendations, standards for judging completion, or a process for oversight.
  • A duty to implement every recommendation may be difficult to judge if recommendations are broad or require choices the bill does not address.