Summary#
Bill 71, Lung Health Act, 2017, creates a new Ontario law. It establishes the Lung Health Advisory Council and requires the Minister of Health and Long-Term Care to develop and implement an Ontario Lung Health Action Plan; the stated goal is to improve lung health.
- The Council may advise the Minister on promoting lung health, preventing and treating lung disease, access to care, research, public awareness and related matters.
- The Council must include up to 20 members, with representatives of people with lung disease, caregivers, health professionals, researchers and non-profit organizations. The Ontario Lung Association appoints one member; the Lieutenant Governor in Council appoints the others.
- The Minister must develop and implement the Action Plan, taking Council recommendations and specified health reports into consideration.
- The Minister must publish annual reports on progress. The Minister must also publish a progress report on developing the Action Plan within two years of the Act coming into force, and publish the Plan and intended implementation steps within three years.
- The Minister must pursue listed improvements in awareness, care and services only to the extent the Minister considers reasonable and appropriate.
What it means for you#
- People with lung disease and their caregivers: The Act directs the Minister to improve access to early diagnosis, treatment, rehabilitation, health maintenance, and community and home support services, subject to the Minister’s judgment about what is reasonable and appropriate. It does not guarantee any particular service or create an individual right to receive one.
- Health professionals and researchers: They are among the groups represented on the Council. The Minister must also facilitate training and professional development opportunities for health-care providers, within the same limit.
- Ontario residents: You can read the Minister’s annual progress reports and the Action Plan. The Act does not itself set out new treatment rules, benefits, or a process for applying for services.
- Government: The Council must submit an annual report with recommendations. The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make rules about Council meetings, members’ duties and the Council’s procedures.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost of the Act is in the supplied material.
- The Act requires the Minister to develop and implement a plan and prepare reports, but gives no cost estimate, budget or staffing amount.
- It creates no tax, fee, fine or direct payment to patients.
What is unclear#
- The Act does not set a budget, staffing level, or specific measures for the Action Plan.
- It does not define what the Minister considers “reasonable and appropriate” when deciding how far to pursue the listed improvements.
- It does not set detailed rules for how Council members are selected beyond the appointment provisions, or how the Council gathers evidence and reaches recommendations.
- It does not specify how people with lung disease, caregivers or other groups would be involved beyond having representatives on the Council.
- The Act came into force six months after Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not give the assent date.
Case for#
- A Council with patients, caregivers, health professionals, researchers and non-profit representatives could give the Minister advice from several parts of the lung-health system.
- Requiring an Action Plan and public progress reports could make the government’s plans and progress easier to track.
- The Act names prevention, early diagnosis, treatment, research and support services as areas for the Minister to address.
Case against#
- The Act does not guarantee improved access or new services: the Minister’s listed actions are limited by what the Minister considers reasonable and appropriate.
- The required plan has no stated funding level, specific targets or detailed implementation rules in the Act.
- The Council advises the Minister; the Act does not require the Minister to adopt its recommendations, only to take them into consideration when developing the Plan.