A bill would boost accountability in assault cases

Summary#

Bill 189, Lydia’s Law (Accountability and Transparency in the Handling of Sexual Assault Cases), 2024, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to improve accountability and transparency in handling sexual assault cases. The bill would require annual reporting on two Auditor General recommendations, a review of the Victim Quick Response Program, and notice about an existing legal advice program.

  • The Attorney General must report each year on how far the Ministry of the Attorney General has implemented two recommendations from the Auditor General’s 2019 report. The report must be tabled by March 1 and published within 10 days.
  • The Standing Committee on Justice Policy must set up a working group to review each report. The committee must report its review to the Assembly within 20 sitting days after the report is tabled.
  • The Attorney General must review the efficiency of the Victim Quick Response Program as a replacement for the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board in supporting survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault and human trafficking, and report the results within one year after the Act starts.
  • A police service that receives a sexual assault complaint from someone aged 16 or older must make that person aware of the Independent Legal Advice Program, delivered through Ontario Victim Services.

What it means for you#

  • People reporting sexual assault to police who are 16 or older: The police service must tell you about the Independent Legal Advice Program. The bill does not require the service to arrange legal advice for you or say how it must give you this information.
  • Survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault and human trafficking: The Attorney General must review the efficiency of the Victim Quick Response Program for supporting these survivors. The bill does not itself change the program, its eligibility rules or the support it provides.
  • The Attorney General and Ministry: They would have to prepare and publish annual progress reports and complete the program review.
  • The Assembly’s Standing Committee on Justice Policy: It would have to establish a working group and report on its review of each annual progress report.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires work by the Attorney General, the Ministry and the committee, but gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • It does not appropriate money or set a fee, fine or payment.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the Auditor General’s two recommendations, so their subject and the progress expected cannot be checked here.
  • The bill does not set criteria or a method for judging the Victim Quick Response Program’s efficiency.
  • It does not explain how police services must make people aware of the legal advice program, or define what counts as making someone aware.
  • The bill does not say how the working group must conduct its review.
  • Current law and existing practices are not provided, so it is not possible to verify what duties or program arrangements already exist.
  • The bill would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not give its current status.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that yearly public reports would let the Assembly and the public track the Ministry’s progress on two Auditor General recommendations.
  • A committee review would add a second step of scrutiny rather than leaving the progress reports without a required review.
  • Requiring police to tell complainants aged 16 or older about legal advice could make them aware of a service they might otherwise not know about.
  • A required review could give the Assembly information about how efficiently the Victim Quick Response Program supports the named groups.

Case against#

  • The bill requires reports and a review, but does not require the Ministry to implement the recommendations or make changes based on the findings.
  • It does not set standards for the program review, so the results may not answer what changes, if any, are needed.
  • The notice duty does not specify how or when police must give the information, or what happens if they do not.
  • The bill requires recurring government and committee work but provides no cost estimate or staffing details.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2024051401

    Passed88 members voted

    Trevor Jones moved, That, pursuant to Standing Order 77(a), the Order for Second Reading of Bill 189

    FOR · 59AGAINST · 29

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    59For

    • PC57
    • Independent2

    29Against

    • NDP21
    • Liberal5
    • Green2
    • Independent1