Bill would require reports of adult abuse

Summary#

Bill 40, the Support for Adults in Need of Assistance Act, 2021, would create a new Ontario law. Its stated goal is to require reports of suspected abuse or neglect of people aged 16 and older, and to provide a process for assessing those reports and recommending support.

  • Regulated health professionals would have to report a reasonable suspicion directly and immediately to a board of health. They would have to report again if they develop additional suspicions.
  • Boards of health would have to ensure reported information is assessed and verified within 48, 72 or 120 hours, depending on the urgency suggested by the report.
  • Every board of health would have to establish a review team, including at least one legally qualified medical practitioner. For verified reports referred to a team, the team would review the case and recommend a support and assistance plan to the board.
  • The bill would allow certain board employees to enter premises under powers in the Health Protection and Promotion Act, applied with changes. Obstructing them could bring a fine of up to $5,000.
  • Boards would have to publish report numbers, verification numbers, general reasons for reports and outcomes every six months, without personal information.

What it means for you#

  • Regulated health professionals: You would have a legal duty to report suspected abuse or neglect of someone aged 16 or older if the suspicion is reasonable and the information came through your professional or official duties. Failing to report could be an offence, punishable by a fine of up to $5,000. The bill protects good-faith reports from legal action, unless made maliciously or without reasonable grounds.
  • People aged 16 or older who may be abused or neglected: A report would trigger an assessment and verification process. A verified report would be referred to a review team. The bill requires a recommended plan, but does not guarantee that services will be provided or that a person will accept a recommendation.
  • People aged 16 or 17: The bill says it does not affect the separate duty to report under the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017.
  • Boards of health: They would have to assess and verify reports on set deadlines, establish review teams, keep the medical officer of health informed, and publish information every six months.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not set out a new tax or fee. It would require boards of health to carry out new work, but does not specify how it would be staffed or funded.

Money#

The bill requires boards of health to carry out new reporting, assessment, review and publication work, but no cost estimate is provided.

  • A person who fails to make a required report, or obstructs an employee exercising the incorporated entry powers, could face a fine of up to $5,000.
  • No information is provided about staffing levels, implementation costs, or how the work would be funded.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “abused,” “neglected,” “immediate need of assistance” or “vulnerable situation.” These terms affect when reports are required and which assessment deadline applies.
  • It does not set out how assessments are done, how a person can respond or challenge a finding, or how a recommended plan would be put into effect.
  • It does not explain how a potentially affected person’s consent or views would be handled. If the team believes the person may be incapable, the plan must include specified consultations, but the bill does not require a court application or guardianship.
  • The bill refers to entry powers in the Health Protection and Promotion Act, but that Act was not supplied, so the exact entry rules and limits could not be checked.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s legislative status or whether it has received Royal Assent. If enacted, it would start one year after Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it creates a clear duty to report suspected abuse or neglect, rather than leaving reporting to individual choice.
  • Set deadlines could help ensure reports are assessed promptly, with shorter deadlines for cases suggesting greater urgency.
  • A review team that includes a medical practitioner could bring more than one perspective to verified cases and recommend a support plan.
  • Six-month public reporting could show how many reports are made and what outcomes follow, while barring disclosure of personal information.

Case against#

  • The bill gives health professionals a broad reporting duty, including where information is confidential or privileged, while leaving key terms such as “abused” and “neglected” undefined. Solicitor-client privilege is expressly preserved for the reporting duty.
  • The bill permits disclosure of confidential or privileged information to a review team, without stating in this section a solicitor-client privilege exception.
  • It requires assessments and review teams but does not specify the resources needed, who pays, or how recommendations become actual assistance.
  • The entry powers are incorporated from another Act, and their precise limits cannot be assessed from the supplied material.