Summary#
Bill 238, the Emergency Management Modernization Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Emergency Management and Civil Protection Act and Ministry of Community and Social Services Act. Its stated goal is to strengthen emergency management and help protect people and property in Ontario; that goal is not a guaranteed result.
- The Minister responsible for the emergency law would have to lead and coordinate emergency management, develop a provincial strategy, report on progress each year and review the strategy at least every five years.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council would have to issue a provincial planning framework. Municipalities, provincial ministries and prescribed government entities would have to make their emergency plans conform to it.
- A provincial emergency management organization within the Minister’s ministry would operate under the Commissioner of Emergency Management. The Commissioner must coordinate the use or deployment of personnel, services, equipment, materials and facilities available to them, called “Ontario Corps”; this is not set up as a separate agency.
- The Minister could require plans or programs to be changed if they do not meet the Act’s requirements. Prescribed entities that operate or provide critical infrastructure could be required by regulation to develop emergency plans or programs.
- Municipal leaders would face new conditions and reporting duties when declaring an emergency. The bill would also let the Minister give binding directives to prescribed, publicly funded community and social service providers on prescribed extraordinary matters.
What it means for you#
- Municipalities: Each would have to develop and implement an emergency management program and plan, adopt them by by-law, and make the plan conform to the provincial framework. Regulations could allow joint plans or programs and require plans to address specified emergencies.
- Municipalities and residents: A head of council could declare an emergency only after consulting the municipal plan and being satisfied that action under it is necessary without serious delay. During the declaration, the head could take actions authorized by the plan, to the extent needed to protect property and residents’ health, safety and welfare—and not contrary to law. The municipality must report regularly to the public; the head must report to council every 30 days and notify the Minister. The head must also send the Minister a report after the emergency ends. The Premier could end the declaration.
- Provincial ministries and designated government entities: They would have to develop programs and plans, assess hazards and risks, and identify infrastructure at risk. Their plans would have to follow the provincial framework.
- Critical infrastructure entities: Only entities prescribed by regulation would be covered. The regulations would decide whether each must have a program, a plan or both.
- Prescribed community and social service providers receiving Ministry funding: They would have to follow any applicable directive. If the Minister believes there are reasonable grounds to think an entity has not complied, the Minister could order it to take steps or submit and carry out a compliance plan. Failure to follow an order could lead to reduced or ended Ministry funding. Knowingly disobeying an order is an offence: a person could be fined up to $5,000, and other entities up to $25,000. A director or officer who knowingly agrees to the offence could also be liable.
- Individuals: The bill does not create a new individual benefit or tax. Its stated purpose of protecting people is not a guarantee of protection or a new individual right.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires the Commissioner to coordinate resources available to them, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- It does not specify the cost of the new planning, reporting, training or exercise duties.
- A provider’s funding may be reduced or ended for failing to comply with a compliance order, but the amount is not set in the bill.
What is unclear#
- The full current versions of the two amended Acts were not supplied, so the precise change from current law could not be checked against them.
- Regulations will determine which critical infrastructure entities and community and social service providers are covered, and many of their detailed duties.
- The bill does not define “critical infrastructure” or specify what counts as an “extraordinary matter” for social service directives.
- It does not set out how Ontario Corps resources will be selected or supplied, or how Indigenous communities will be involved in emergency coordination.
- The bill does not specify a process for providers to challenge directives or orders. The costs of compliance, staffing and enforcement are also not estimated.
- Some provisions would start only on dates set by proclamation; the bill text does not give those dates.
Case for#
- A provincial strategy and shared planning framework could make responsibilities clearer and help coordinate emergency plans across municipalities and provincial bodies.
- Requiring plans to address specified emergencies could make planning more consistent across the province.
- Coordinating available people, equipment and services through the Commissioner could help organize support during emergencies.
- Directives and compliance orders could give the Minister a way to address urgent or extraordinary issues in publicly funded services.
Case against#
- The Minister’s power to require changes to plans and issue directives could add central control, while the bill leaves many details to future regulations.
- Municipalities and covered organizations would have new planning, reporting and compliance duties, but the bill does not estimate their costs.
- The bill does not explain how Ontario Corps resources will be obtained or how priorities would be set if resources are limited.
- A provider that does not comply with an order could lose funding and face fines for knowing non-compliance, while the bill does not set out a challenge process.