Summary#
Bill 24, the Health Care is Not for Sale Act (Addressing Unfair Fees Charged to Patients), 2022, would amend Ontario’s Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991 and Independent Health Facilities Act. Its stated goal is to address unfair fees charged to patients; it would not set a fee amount or define “unfair fee” in the bill itself.
- Patients would be to be treated with fairness, as well as sensitivity and respect, in their dealings with health professionals.
- A discipline panel could find a regulated health professional guilty of professional misconduct if that member—or another person—charged a patient an unfair fee for the member’s service. The panel could order the member to reimburse the patient and direct the Registrar to suspend the member’s registration for three months.
- Each College’s patient relations program would have to include measures to prevent and deal with unfair fees.
- A College Council could make a regulation defining “unfair fee,” but it would need the Minister’s prior approval and approval by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
- The Director could suspend or revoke an independent health facility’s licence, or remove services from its licence, based on reasonable grounds to believe it is charging or will charge unfair fees.
- The bill would take effect on Royal Assent. The parent Acts were not supplied, so I could not verify how these changes compare with current law.
What it means for you#
- Patients: If a discipline panel finds an unfair fee was charged, it could order the member to repay the amount the patient paid and direct a three-month suspension. The bill does not set the fee level or make a finding automatic.
- Regulated health professionals: A fee charged by someone else for a service you provided could lead to a misconduct finding against you. The bill does not set out a complaint or hearing process.
- Independent health facilities: The Director could act against a facility’s licence or remove services from its licence if the stated grounds are met. The bill does not require the Director to take either step.
- Colleges: Their patient relations programs would have to address preventing and dealing with unfair fees. The bill does not create a new College or a new patient service.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- A panel could order a member to reimburse a patient for the amount paid for the unfair fee.
- The bill requires Colleges’ patient relations programs to include unfair-fee measures, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- No public funding, fee schedule, or cost estimate for the new licensing powers is provided.
What is unclear#
- “Unfair fee” is not defined in the bill. A future regulation could define it, subject to the stated approvals.
- The bill does not set out how patients would complain, how cases would be decided, or what evidence or timelines would apply.
- It is unclear how the new rules would interact with existing fee rules or programs; the parent Acts were not supplied to check this.
- The bill does not explain how the Director would assess whether a facility will charge unfair fees, or what process a facility could use to challenge a decision.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give patients a way to seek repayment and to make unfair fees a specific ground for professional discipline.
- Requiring Colleges to address unfair fees in patient relations programs could make prevention and response part of their stated responsibilities.
- Giving the Director powers over facility licences could address concerns about fees at independent health facilities, including fees the Director believes will be charged.
Case against#
- The key term, “unfair fee,” is left to a later regulation, so the bill itself does not tell patients or providers which fees would count.
- The bill adds significant possible consequences, including a three-month suspension and action against a facility’s licence, without setting out the decision process.
- A member could face a misconduct finding even if another person charged the fee. The bill does not explain how responsibility would be assessed.