Summary#
Bill 212, the Connecting Care Amendment Act (Patient Bill of Rights), 2020, would amend Ontario’s Connecting Care Act, 2019. Its stated goal is to make a set of rights for people receiving health services part of that Act.
- Health service providers would have to fully respect and promote rights to courteous and respectful treatment; freedom from mental, physical and financial abuse by the provider; dignity, privacy and autonomy; and care that recognizes a person’s individuality and preferences.
- The rights would include information about services, providers and applicable rules; participation in specified assessments and care planning; consent to or refusal of any health service; and a substitute decision-maker for a person who cannot make their own decisions about care.
- People could raise concerns without fear of interference, coercion, discrimination or reprisal. They would have rights to information about complaints and appeals, and to keep receiving services without reprisal after making one.
- People would have rights to confidential records, to know who received their personal health information, and to a complete, accessible personal health record without delay or unreasonable cost.
- A person could designate an essential caregiver who provides specified kinds of support or care. The provider would have to respect that caregiver’s contribution and allow access in any health care setting at any time.
- The rights would generally prevail over conflicting provisions in other Acts or regulations, unless those laws specifically say they apply despite these rights. A person could ask the Superior Court of Justice for a declaration of a breach; the court could make any order it considers appropriate to enforce the rights.
What it means for you#
- People receiving health services: The bill would set out rights concerning treatment, information, consent, records, complaints and participation in care. For some planning rights, participation applies only after a person is found eligible for a service.
- Essential caregivers: A person receiving care could designate someone who continuously or occasionally provides personal, financial, social, psychological, emotional or physical support, or other personal care or health services. The bill would give that caregiver access at any time in any health care setting.
- Health service providers: They would have a duty to ensure the listed rights are fully respected and promoted. The bill does not set out a complaint-handling process or a process for deciding when a person qualifies for a service.
- Government and Crown agencies: The bill says the rights section would bind the Crown and every Crown agency.
- Everyone affected: The bill would not itself set out a new health service, benefit, tax or fee. It would create rights and a court route to enforce them.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.
- The bill would impose duties on health service providers, but gives no estimate of the cost of meeting them.
- It does not specify new funding, staffing, fees or fines.
What is unclear#
- The Connecting Care Act, 2019 is not included, so the existing definitions, rights and provider duties—and what would be new compared with current law—could not be verified.
- The supplied text does not explain which organizations count as health service providers or what services are covered.
- It does not define “unreasonable cost” for access to a personal health record, or set rules for access to essential caregivers.
- It does not explain how the new rights would work alongside existing complaint, appeal or substitute decision-making processes.
- It gives no details about court application procedures, deadlines or limits on the court’s orders.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give people receiving care clear rights, including a voice in care planning and the ability to consent to or refuse services.
- Naming rights to privacy, records and complaint protections could give patients a clearer basis to raise concerns.
- Recognizing an essential caregiver in law could support the role of people who provide personal, emotional or other care.
- A court could declare a breach and make an order to enforce the rights, rather than the rights being only a statement of purpose.
Case against#
- The rights would generally prevail over other laws unless those laws specifically provide otherwise. The bill does not explain how providers should resolve conflicts in practice.
- Access to an essential caregiver is stated to apply at any time in any health care setting, but the bill does not set out exceptions or explain how access would work in different circumstances.
- The bill gives broad rights but does not specify how complaints are handled, how compliance is monitored or what happens before a court application.
- Providers would have new duties, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detail about how they would be funded.