Summary#
Bill 26, the Strengthening Post-secondary Institutions and Students Act, 2022, amends Ontario’s Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities Act, Private Career Colleges Act, 2005 and Ryerson University Act, 1977. It is now law, enacted as Chapter 22 of Ontario’s 2022 statutes. Its stated goal is to strengthen post-secondary institutions and students.
- Publicly assisted universities and colleges of applied arts and technology, and private career colleges, must have employee sexual misconduct policies with rules and examples of possible discipline.
- An institution may discipline or dismiss an employee for sexual misconduct toward a student. If it dismisses the employee, the dismissal counts as just cause, and the employee cannot receive notice or termination pay as a result. An adjudicator cannot substitute a different penalty.
- An institution must not re-employ an employee who committed sexual misconduct toward a student and was dismissed for it or resigned.
- New agreements generally cannot stop an institution or related person from disclosing that an allegation or complaint was made. An exception applies if the student requests confidentiality and legal-advice, freedom-from-pressure and time-limit safeguards are met.
- The bill continues Ryerson University under the name Toronto Metropolitan University and raises the number of Senate members in one statutory category from 51 to 62.
What it means for you#
- Students: Their institutions must have employee sexual misconduct policies. The bill does not itself set an investigation process, decision timeline or appeal process.
- Employees: If an institution finds that an employee committed sexual misconduct toward a student, it may discipline or dismiss them. Dismissal has the consequences described above; resignation after the misconduct also bars later re-employment at that institution.
- Universities, colleges and private career colleges: They must follow the new rules. For a private career college, having the required policy is a condition of registration.
- Toronto Metropolitan University: The law changes the university’s legal name and the number of Senate members in one statutory category. It does not create a new university.
- General public: The bill does not create a new public service, tax, fee or student benefit.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Institutions must have policies, but the bill gives no estimate for the cost of creating or maintaining them.
- The bill does not state a new appropriation, staffing budget, fee or fine.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out how institutions investigate allegations, decide whether misconduct occurred, or handle appeals.
- “Sexual misconduct” can include conduct that violates an institution’s own policy. The bill does not set a common policy standard for all institutions.
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts. I could not verify how the amendments to section 15(6) of the Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities Act change the existing legal powers or how the changes compare with current law.
- The supplied material does not explain how the university’s Senate operates or how the change affects its overall size.
Case for#
- The bill requires institutions to set out rules and possible discipline, which could make expectations clearer for students and employees.
- Allowing dismissal for just cause and barring re-employment after dismissal or resignation could help institutions respond to misconduct and prevent a former employee from returning to the same institution.
- Limits on confidentiality terms could make it harder for agreements to prevent disclosure that a complaint or allegation was made, while preserving an exception when the student requests confidentiality under stated safeguards.
Case against#
- The bill does not require institutions to use a specific investigation or appeal process, even though a finding can lead to dismissal without termination pay.
- Because institutions’ own policies can define conduct as sexual misconduct, rules may differ between institutions.
- The bill prevents adjudicators from replacing a disciplinary measure with a different penalty. One concern is that this limits the ability to change a penalty through arbitration or another adjudication process.