Budget Measures Act Expands Interim Spending

Summary#

The Progress on the Plan to Build Act (Budget Measures), 2022 is an enacted Ontario law that amends several existing Acts and enacts two interim appropriation Acts. Its stated goal is to implement budget measures and make other changes to provincial laws.

  • It creates a framework for clean energy credits, with the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) running a registry. Some parts of this framework require a proclamation to take effect.
  • It extends existing reductions to fuel and gasoline tax through December 31, 2023.
  • It authorizes capped interim spending for the 2022–23 and 2023–24 fiscal years, pending approval of the regular spending bills.
  • It doubles a payment under the Ontario Guaranteed Annual Income Act for eligible people during 2023 and changes how MPP salaries are set.
  • It changes pension-plan document requirements, gives the Ontario Securities Commission authority to make rules about alternative document delivery, and changes eligibility limits for certain film and television production tax-credit expenses.

What it means for you#

  • Electricity generators, consumers and the IESO: If the clean-energy-credit provisions take effect, the IESO must establish and maintain or designate a registry. The IESO, Ontario Power Generation and other entities named in regulations must make specified environmental attributes available for transfer. Transferors and intended buyers must register. A credit can be transferred only if it is recorded in the registry and meets conditions set by the law and regulations; the recipient must record its retirement. The IESO must report on generation and credit transfers each year and publish its report.
  • People and businesses paying fuel or gasoline tax: The Act extends the existing tax reductions to December 31, 2023. It does not change fuel-tax eligibility rules in the supplied text.
  • Eligible recipients under the Ontario Guaranteed Annual Income Act: The specified payment amount was doubled for January 1 to December 31, 2023. The Act does not change eligibility in the supplied text.
  • Pension-plan administrators and members: Once the relevant provisions take effect, plan documents must include a funding policy and a governance policy (rules for how the plan is funded and overseen). The Act also clarifies when a collective agreement counts as a document supporting a plan.
  • Film and television production companies: Certain costs of leasing real property from a lessor not ordinarily in that leasing business can count toward the production-services tax credit, subject to conditions and a cap. The change applies to expenses incurred after November 14, 2022.
  • Investors and MPPs: Securities Commission rules may allow or require certain documents to be made available in another way; the rules may set when they count as received. Repealing the MPP salary-freeze provision removes that specific freeze-ending condition, but the Act does not set a new salary amount.
  • The public service and taxpayers: The two appropriation Acts authorize spending within stated limits; they do not specify the programs receiving each amount or require the full amounts to be spent.

Money#

The Act authorizes interim spending up to stated caps, but the available material does not give a total cost estimate for all its measures.

  • For 2023–24, it authorizes up to $174.4 billion for public-service expenses, $5.03 billion for public-service investments and $298.2 million for Legislative Office expenses, pending the regular supply vote.
  • For 2022–23, it authorizes up to $10.95 billion for public-service expenses and $13.8 million for Legislative Office expenses, in addition to earlier interim amounts. These are authorization limits, not proof that the amounts were spent.
  • The IESO’s registry rules may require fees, but no fee amount is set in the Act. Regulations will direct how the IESO and Ontario Power Generation apply proceeds from credit transfers.
  • The materials give no estimate of the revenue effect of the tax changes or the cost of the doubled payment.

What is unclear#

  • The clean-energy-credit and pension provisions require proclamations to take effect. The supplied material does not say when they took effect.
  • Regulations and registry rules will set key details for clean energy credits, including eligible energy sources, transfer requirements, fees and how proceeds are used.
  • The supplied material does not give the fuel- and gasoline-tax reduction amounts or their fiscal cost. The parent Acts were not supplied, so those details and the full current-law baseline could not be verified.
  • The appropriation Acts do not show how the authorized amounts are divided among programs.
  • The Act gives no schedule for when pension plans must file their policies; that timing is left to regulations.

Case for#

  • A registry, one-time submission of attribute information and a required retirement record could help track credits and reduce the risk of the same environmental attribute being claimed more than once.
  • The annual public report could make credit transfers and electricity generation by energy source more visible.
  • Extending the tax reductions and doubling the specified payment for 2023 provide direct, time-limited financial relief to the groups covered.
  • Requiring pension funding and governance policies could make core plan documents clearer for administrators and members.

Case against#

  • Many important clean-energy-credit rules are left to regulations or IESO rules. The Act allows rules to set fees and permits some decisions to be delegated, while the detailed process is not set out here.
  • The Act requires certain entities to make environmental attributes available, but it does not explain how proceeds will ultimately be distributed or what public benefit they must support.
  • The interim appropriations authorize very large amounts without identifying the programs or showing how much will actually be spent.
  • The tax reductions and doubled payment have costs or revenue effects, but the supplied material does not quantify them.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2022120601

    Passed105 members voted

    Motion for closure on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 36

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 31

    74For

    • PC74

    31Against

    • NDP23
    • Liberal7
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2022120602

    Passed105 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 36

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 31

    74For

    • PC74

    31Against

    • NDP23
    • Liberal7
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2022111701

    Passed104 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 36

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 30

    74For

    • PC74

    30Against

    • NDP21
    • Liberal8
    • Green1
  4. Division No. 2022111702

    Passed104 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 36

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 30

    74For

    • PC74

    30Against

    • NDP21
    • Liberal8
    • Green1