Summary#
Bill 37, the Notwithstanding Clause Limitation Act, 2022, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to limit when an Ontario bill can use the Canadian Charter’s notwithstanding clause. The bill would take effect on Royal Assent.
- A bill could include a notwithstanding clause only if it addresses a temporary, urgent and critical situation that seriously endangers Ontarians’ lives, health or safety, and amends an Act with a provision a court has found violates the Charter.
- In that case, the clause could apply only to the court-identified provision and the Charter provisions the court found it violated.
- A bill containing a notwithstanding clause could not be adopted unless at least two-thirds of elected MPPs approve it.
- For a bill introduced by a Crown minister that contains the clause, the Attorney General must table a report within 30 days. It must explain how the use can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society and why alternatives were considered inadequate.
What it means for you#
- Ontarians: If enacted, the bill would change the conditions under which a bill can use the notwithstanding clause. It does not itself change Charter rights or create a new public service, benefit, fee or fine.
- The government and Attorney General: A minister introducing a bill with the clause must ensure the Attorney General tables the required report within 30 days.
- Elected MPPs: At least two-thirds of elected members would have to approve any bill containing the clause.
- Legislative Assembly: The bill would set limits on what bills can include. It does not specify a process or penalty for deciding whether a bill meets those limits.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Attorney General would have to arrange for reports to be tabled. The bill gives no estimate of the work or cost.
- The bill does not specify new funding or staffing.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “urgent and critical situation” or set out who decides whether the conditions for using the clause are met.
- It does not explain what happens if a bill includes the clause but does not meet the conditions, or how those conditions would be enforced.
- The supplied material does not include current Ontario law or Assembly procedures, so existing rules and processes cannot be compared.
- The bill does not specify whether or how the Assembly would assess the Attorney General’s report.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that use of the clause would be limited to a narrow situation involving serious danger and a provision already found by a court to violate the Charter.
- Requiring a two-thirds vote could mean a bill needs support from more than a simple majority of elected MPPs.
- Requiring the Attorney General to explain the justification and alternatives could give MPPs information to consider before voting.
Case against#
- The bill does not define the urgent-danger test or explain how it would be applied, leaving important questions unanswered.
- The two-thirds requirement could make it harder to pass a bill using the clause, even when the bill meets the stated conditions.
- The report duty applies to bills introduced by ministers, but the bill does not require such a report for a bill introduced by someone else.