Summary#
Bill 306, the York Region Wastewater Act, 2021, would create a new Ontario Act. It does not amend the text of the Environmental Assessment Act; instead, it would temporarily block a decision and actions under that Act for the defined Upper York Sewage Solutions Undertaking. The stated goal is to suspend the Minister’s decision and prohibit actions related to the undertaking.
- The Minister must not decide York Region’s application for the undertaking under the specified parts of the Environmental Assessment Act.
- While that restriction is in force, no person may take any action in respect of the undertaking, which includes a water reclamation centre, a phosphorus offsetting program and changes to the York Durham Sewage System.
- Those two restrictions end when their repeal is brought into force on a date set by proclamation. The bill does not require a decision or project action after that date.
- The bill limits claims against the Crown, current or former ministers, and Crown employees, agents or advisers related to the Act. It also says certain proceedings already underway are dismissed without costs.
- Most of the Act would start on Royal Assent. The repeal of the decision and action restrictions would start later, on a date set by proclamation.
What it means for you#
- York Region and others involved in the undertaking: While the action ban is in force, no person may take action in respect of the defined undertaking. The bill does not set out an application or approval process for exceptions.
- The Minister: The Minister must not decide York Region’s application under the specified parts of the Environmental Assessment Act while the decision restriction remains in force.
- People or organizations with claims against the Crown or the listed officials and advisers: The bill bars a wide range of proceedings related to the Act, including claims for compensation. Proceedings already started that fall within the ban are deemed dismissed without costs. The bill has an exception concerning judicial review and proceedings specifically provided for under another Act, but how that exception interacts with the separate proceeding ban is unclear.
- Residents and wastewater users: The bill does not directly change wastewater service, set a new fee, or permanently cancel the undertaking. It does not say what will happen to the project after the temporary restrictions end.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not set an appropriation, fee, tax or fine, or provide an estimate for public or private costs.
- It limits some legal claims, but the material does not estimate any financial effect from that limit.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current Environmental Assessment Act, so the bill’s effect on the existing approval process cannot be fully checked against current law.
- The bill does not set the date when the decision and action restrictions will be repealed. It does not say whether the application would then proceed or what decision process would follow.
- The bill does not explain how its exception for judicial review and proceedings under another Act works alongside its separate ban on proceedings.
- It does not explain how the restrictions affect related work or decisions outside the defined undertaking.
- No information is supplied about the bill’s current status.
Case for#
- A pause could prevent the undertaking from moving forward while the decision restriction is in force.
- The restriction applies to the defined project and its listed components, rather than changing wastewater rules generally.
- The later repeal date allows the restrictions to end without the bill itself requiring a particular decision or project outcome.
Case against#
- The bill does not set a fixed end date or explain what should happen when the restrictions end, leaving the project’s next steps uncertain.
- The broad action ban could stop work related to the undertaking without setting out exceptions or a process to resolve practical issues.
- The limits on legal proceedings could prevent people or organizations from pursuing claims related to the Act, including claims based on events before it took effect.