Bill allows care placement without consent

Summary#

Bill 7, More Beds, Better Care Act, 2022, amends Ontario’s Fixing Long-Term Care Act, 2021 and makes a related amendment to the Health Care Consent Act, 1996. It creates a process for certain hospital patients to be assessed and considered for long-term-care placement without their consent; the stated goal is to address placement for patients designated as needing an alternate level of care. The bill was enacted, but its main provisions require a proclamation to come into force, and no start date is provided here.

  • The new process applies to a person occupying a public-hospital bed whom an attending clinician designates as needing an alternate level of care because, in the clinician’s opinion, they do not need the level of hospital resources or services.
  • A placement co-ordinator may determine eligibility, select one or more homes subject to geographic restrictions set by regulation, share required information, authorize admission, and transfer placement responsibility to another co-ordinator. A clinician may request these actions, but the co-ordinator may act without a request.
  • A physician, registered nurse, or another person named in the Act may assess the patient for eligibility. A long-term-care home’s licensee must review the information and approve admission unless a specified reason for refusal applies; the licensee must admit the approved patient when the patient presents and the required conditions, including an available bed, are met.
  • These steps may be taken without consent only after reasonable efforts to obtain consent. The law does not authorize restraint or physically transferring a patient to a home without consent.
  • The process may involve collecting, using, and disclosing personal health information when necessary. Regulations may set rules and conditions for these actions and modify or exempt parts of the usual process.

What it means for you#

  • Hospital patients designated as needing an alternate level of care: Eligibility assessment, home selection, and authorization of admission may proceed without your consent after reasonable efforts to obtain it. You or your substitute decision-maker may consent at any stage; the usual statutory process then applies to the parts you consent to, subject to regulations.
  • Patients found ineligible: You may apply to the Appeal Board for a review. The new provision does not authorize anyone to restrain you or physically move you to a long-term-care home without consent.
  • Placement co-ordinators, assessors, hospitals, and long-term-care homes: The bill authorizes or requires the actions described above. It also permits necessary personal health information handling by authorized people and hospitals.
  • Long-term-care residents: The new provision says it must not be interpreted as inconsistent with the Residents’ Bill of Rights.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new independent agency, tax, fee, or direct public benefit in the text provided.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s expected cost.

  • The bill assigns work to placement co-ordinators, assessors, hospitals, and long-term-care home licensees, but gives no staffing numbers or cost estimate.
  • The text provided does not specify new taxes, fees, fines, or an appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The main provisions take effect on a date set by proclamation; the supplied material does not say whether or when they have been proclaimed.
  • Regulations are to set important details, including procedures, criteria, restrictions, geographic limits, and what information must be shared. Those details are not included here.
  • The amendment describes who may be designated as an alternate-level-of-care patient but does not define that term beyond the clinician’s stated opinion.
  • The supplied material does not include the full amended Acts, so the existing process and all conditions for refusing admission could not be checked against current law.
  • The new provision expressly provides an appeal for an ineligibility decision. The supplied text does not describe a review process for other decisions, such as home selection.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address cases where a clinician says a hospital patient no longer needs the level of hospital care being provided but still needs a care placement.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that placement steps can proceed even if the patient or substitute decision-maker has not consented, rather than waiting for consent at each step.
  • The bill retains limits: reasonable efforts to obtain consent are required, patients can appeal an ineligibility decision, and physical transfer without consent is not authorized.

Case against#

  • One concern is that eligibility, home selection, and admission authorization may proceed without the patient’s or substitute decision-maker’s consent.
  • The process may involve personal health information without consent when necessary. The bill leaves many rules for regulations, which are not included in the supplied material.
  • The law requires a home to admit an approved patient when the patient presents and the stated conditions are met. A possible trade-off is that the bill gives less weight to consent during placement planning, while not authorizing forced physical transfer.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2022083101

    Passed111 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 7

    FOR · 76AGAINST · 35

    76For

    • PC76

    35Against

    • NDP25
    • Liberal8
    • Green1
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2022083002

    Passed106 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 7

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 32

    74For

    • PC74

    32Against

    • NDP24
    • Liberal7
    • Green1