Caregivers gain access rights in care settings

Summary#

Bill 203 would create a new law, the More Than a Visitor Act (Caregiving in Congregate Care Settings), 2020. Its stated goal is to protect the rights of people receiving care and their designated caregivers, including during emergencies; it does not amend an existing Act. The supplied material does not state whether the bill passed or is in force.

  • The Minister would have to ensure designated caregivers excluded because of the COVID-19 pandemic are safely integrated back into congregate care settings, and that infection-control protocols provide a way to integrate them during a crisis or emergency.
  • The Minister would have to ensure that people receiving care have certain rights, including access to their designated caregiver, a choice about the caregiver’s role in decisions, and private communication with the caregiver. Both people and caregivers would have the right to dignity and respect.
  • A designated caregiver must provide significant, unpaid, non-professional support and share an emotional bond with the person. The person or their substitute decision-maker can designate one or more caregivers, and can revoke a designation at any time.
  • Coverage includes long-term-care and retirement homes, hospitals, hospices, independent health facilities, supportive housing, residential services for people with developmental disabilities and children, custody settings, some violence-against-women and anti-trafficking services, and emergency homeless shelters. Home and community care settings would be included on a day set by the Minister.
  • The Minister would have to provide operators with support, resources and training, and ensure they have resources to implement the Act’s rights and caregiving strategy. The strategy must include a staffing strategy for each type of setting so caregivers supplement, rather than replace, paid care.
  • The Minister would have to consult specified groups, including people receiving care, caregivers, providers, staff and researchers; publish the strategy; and review it at least every five years. An interim strategy would be due within one month of Royal Assent and remain in effect for the first year.

What it means for you#

  • People receiving care and designated caregivers: The bill would establish rights to caregiver access according to the person’s needs and preferences, to have a caregiver treated as more than a visitor, and to choose how much the caregiver participates in decisions. It would also protect confidential communication and require dignity and respect. The rights would remain in effect during crises or emergencies.
  • Caregivers: More than one person may be designated, including a family member, friend, neighbour or support person. Designation depends on the person’s choice or their substitute decision-maker’s choice, and can be revoked at any time.
  • Operators and paid workers: The Minister would have to provide operators with support, resources and training. The bill says it does not change workers’ roles or responsibilities or affect their collective bargaining rights. It also says caregiver support does not replace paid care.
  • People using covered settings: The bill does not set out an application or approval process for caregiver access, or specify how an individual could enforce these rights.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require the Minister to provide support, resources and training to operators and ensure they have resources to implement the rights and strategy.
  • It does not give a spending estimate, specify staff numbers, or set out an appropriation or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain what “safely integrated” means or set out detailed access rules, timelines, exceptions or an enforcement process.
  • It does not say how disputes about a caregiver’s designation, access or participation would be handled.
  • It requires the strategy to prevent the Government from unilaterally developing policies about caregivers’ roles, but does not explain how that limit would work in practice.
  • The date for adding home and community care settings would be set later by the Minister.
  • No publicly available information on whether this bill passed or is in force.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the risk that people could lose access to important unpaid support when a setting restricts visitors, including during a crisis.
  • Treating designated caregivers differently from visitors could help preserve the person’s chosen role for them in care and decision-making.
  • Requiring caregiver access to be built into infection-control protocols could make planning for future emergencies part of the Minister’s duties.
  • Requiring consultation and a published strategy could give people receiving care, caregivers and staff a formal role in shaping policy.

Case against#

  • The bill creates broad rights and duties but leaves key practical rules, such as access limits and how safety concerns are resolved, unspecified.
  • It requires resources and training but provides no cost estimate or funding source; the staffing strategy also has no stated staffing levels.
  • The bill does not specify how rights would be enforced or what remedy a person would have if access were denied.
  • It is unclear how the requirement to maintain caregiver access during emergencies would be balanced against infection-control or other safety measures.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2020092401

    Passed47 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 203

    FOR · 47

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    47For

    • PC27
    • NDP17
    • Liberal3

    0Against