Summary#
Bill 94, the Keeping 2SLGBTQI+ Communities Safe Act, 2023, would create two new Acts; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to improve safety and help prevent hate crimes and hate-motivated incidents against 2SLGBTQI+ people in Ontario.
- The Attorney General may designate a place where 2SLGBTQI+ people gather as a safety zone for a set period. The Attorney General must make a public list of zones.
- Within 100 metres of the boundary of a property where a zone is located, the bill would prohibit “acts of intimidation,” including listed conduct such as causing a disturbance, distributing hate propaganda, certain threats or offensive remarks, and demonstrations aimed at furthering homophobia or transphobia.
- A person convicted of breaking that prohibition could be fined up to $25,000. Any person, including the Attorney General, could ask the Superior Court of Justice for an injunction to stop a contravention.
- The bill would require the Associate Minister to establish a safety advisory committee within 60 days. The committee would be made up of 1 to 6 members of the Legislative Assembly, with required representation from the government party and Official Opposition, and one other member. Its vice-chair must be from a 2SLGBTQI+ community.
- The committee must make recommendations and report at least yearly. The Associate Minister must table and publish each report and respond with recommendations and proposed actions. The bill says its provisions would come into force on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- People near a designated place: The 100-metre prohibition would apply during the period set in the Attorney General’s order. The order must give the place’s name and address and the dates and times of designation.
- People protesting or speaking: The bill says it does not prevent peaceful protests or demonstrations. But it does not explain how that safeguard applies alongside the broad and undefined term “act of intimidation.”
- People seeking to stop prohibited conduct: Anyone could apply to the Superior Court for an injunction. The court may grant one; the bill does not require it to do so.
- 2SLGBTQI+ people and the public: The advisory committee would examine issues including housing and homelessness, health care, education, and hate-crime reporting and investigation. This creates advice and reporting duties, not a direct service or guaranteed policy changes.
- Government: The Associate Minister must establish and chair the committee, respond to its reports, and publish them. The committee must consult, invite and review public submissions, conduct surveys, and review relevant plans and documents “as appropriate.”
Money#
No publicly available information about the bill’s estimated cost.
- The Associate Minister may determine financial support for proposed actions responding to committee reports, but only if the Legislature has appropriated funds for that purpose.
- The bill does not set an amount for that support or state how much the committee’s work would cost.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “act of intimidation,” “offensive remarks,” or demonstrations that further the objectives of homophobia or transphobia.
- It does not set out how the Attorney General would choose places, what evidence or criteria would be used, or how a designation could be challenged.
- It does not explain how the 100-metre restriction would be applied in specific situations, or how it would interact with the protection for peaceful protests.
- The committee consists of elected legislators, not a required set of community representatives. The bill does not specify how people outside the legislature would take part beyond the committee’s public-submission and consultation duties.
- The bill does not require the government to adopt the committee’s recommendations or provide funding for proposed actions.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address safety concerns by allowing a defined area around a designated gathering place to receive extra legal protection for a set time.
- A possible argument for the restriction is that it names several forms of conduct the bill treats as intimidation and allows a court to be asked to stop a contravention.
- The committee’s required yearly reports could bring recommendations on safety, health, housing, education, and hate-crime processes before the Legislature.
- Requiring the Associate Minister to respond publicly could make the government explain what actions it proposes to take.
Case against#
- The prohibition uses terms the bill does not define, which could leave uncertainty about what speech or conduct is prohibited near a zone.
- A fine of up to $25,000 is possible on conviction, but the bill does not set out how alleged violations would be investigated or prosecuted.
- The Attorney General has discretion to designate zones, while the bill sets no criteria or challenge process. That leaves important limits and safeguards unspecified.
- The committee must make recommendations, but the bill does not require the government to act on them or fund the actions it proposes.