Summary#
Bill 208, the Sacred Spaces, Safe Places Act, 2024, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to protect the safety, security, health and privacy of people accessing religious institutions. It would create automatic access zones and make certain conduct in them offences.
- A zone would cover the property where each religious institution is located and the area within 150 metres of the property’s boundaries. The bill defines religious institutions to include places such as churches, mosques, synagogues, temples and cemeteries.
- In a zone, the bill would prohibit advising or persuading someone not to enter, persistently asking them not to enter, and certain acts done to dissuade them, such as intimidation or repeatedly following them. It would also prohibit threatening conduct.
- The bill would separately prohibit repeatedly contacting someone by telephone, fax or electronic means to dissuade them from entering, after they have asked for the communications to stop.
- Police could arrest without a warrant if they had reasonable and probable grounds to believe a person had committed or was committing an offence. A person could not be convicted unless they knew, or had been given notice of, the zone’s location.
- A person who suffers a loss from a contravention could sue for damages. The Superior Court of Justice could issue an injunction to stop a contravention, on application by a person, including the Attorney General.
What it means for you#
- Religious institutions: A zone would be established automatically for each institution; the bill does not require the institution to apply.
- People visiting or near an institution: The restrictions would cover the institution’s property and a surrounding area up to 150 metres from its boundaries. The bill does not set out an exception for peaceful advocacy or protest.
- People communicating with visitors: Repeated calls, faxes or electronic messages aimed at dissuading someone from entering would be prohibited after that person asks for them to stop.
- People accused of an offence: The bill sets out fines and possible jail time. For a first offence, the maximum fine would be $5,000 and the maximum jail term six months, or both. For a second or later offence, the fine would be $1,000 to $10,000 and the maximum jail term one year, or both. Conviction would require knowledge or prior notice of the zone’s location.
- Police and courts: Police would have the stated arrest power. People who suffer loss could seek damages, and a person—including the Attorney General—could apply for an injunction.
- General public: The bill does not create a new service or benefit. It does not say how its rules would interact with other laws.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s public costs.
- The bill sets fines, but the supplied material does not say how fine revenue would be used.
- Police, courts and any civil claims could involve costs, but no estimate or funding is provided.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “threatening conduct” or explain how terms such as “persistently” and “repeatedly” would be applied.
- It does not set out how notice of a zone would be given, or how the boundary would be marked.
- It does not explain how the rules would apply to public places within 150 metres, or how they would interact with other laws.
- The remote-communications prohibition does not itself specify a location; how it relates to the access-zone rules is not explained.
- No publicly available information is provided about current laws that may already address this conduct, so overlap with existing rules cannot be verified.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to protect people’s ability to enter religious institutions without being intimidated, followed, physically obstructed or persistently pressured.
- A possible argument for fixed zones is that people and police would have a defined area in which the listed conduct is prohibited.
- The bill offers several ways to respond: criminal penalties, a civil claim for loss, and a court order to stop a contravention.
Case against#
- A 150-metre zone around every institution could cover a large area, including places beyond the institution’s property.
- The bill prohibits some persuasion and observation when done to dissuade access, but leaves key terms undefined and states no specific exception for peaceful expression or protest.
- The arrest power, criminal penalties and civil claims could have serious consequences, while the bill gives little detail about notice, boundaries or how the rules would be applied.
- It is unclear how these new rules would fit with existing laws or what resources enforcement would require.