Revives dissolved corporation to sue

Summary#

Bill PR25, the Superior Corporate Services Limited Act, 2023, is a proposed standalone Act, not an amendment to another Act. It would revive Superior Corporate Services Limited, which the bill says was dissolved in 1989, and restore its legal position as of the date of dissolution. The stated goal is to let the applicant, who says they are the corporation’s executor and trustee, start a legal action on its behalf.

  • The corporation would again have its legal position as if it had not been dissolved, including its liabilities, contracts, debts and disabilities.
  • Property or rights acquired by someone else after the dissolution would not be taken away by the revival.
  • Property that passed to the Crown when the corporation was dissolved would remain with the Crown, unless returned under specified laws or as directed by the Ontario Superior Court of Justice.
  • The corporation would have to indemnify (cover certain losses of) the Crown and its officers, employees and agents for losses tied to claims or proceedings about dispositions of the corporation’s property during the dissolution. A court could approve, void, end or change the indemnity.
  • The Act would take effect on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether it has passed.

What it means for you#

  • The corporation and the applicant: If enacted, the corporation would be revived. This could allow it to start the legal action described in the bill’s preamble, but the bill does not guarantee that an action would be brought or succeed.
  • People who acquired the corporation’s property or rights after dissolution: The revival would be subject to those later acquisitions.
  • The Crown and its officers, employees and agents: They would be covered by the corporation’s indemnity for the specified losses, subject to a court’s power to review and change it.
  • The public: The bill does not create a public service, benefit, tax, fee or fine.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost.

  • The bill requires the corporation to indemnify the Crown and specified Crown personnel for the losses described, but gives no estimate of those losses or the corporation’s ability to pay.
  • The bill provides no estimate of administrative, legal or court costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not identify the proposed legal action, the parties involved or the amount at stake.
  • It does not explain how the indemnity would be claimed or how any losses would be calculated.
  • It does not say what property or rights were disposed of during the corporation’s dissolution.
  • The bill does not explain whether any Crown property could be returned in this case, or which route for return might apply.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let the corporation pursue a legal action that the applicant says cannot be started while it is dissolved.
  • Reviving the corporation restores its legal position while preserving property or rights acquired by others after dissolution.
  • A possible argument for the indemnity is that it assigns the specified losses to the revived corporation, while allowing a court to review the arrangement.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill restores the corporation’s debts and other liabilities without stating what they are or whether it can meet them.
  • The indemnity covers direct or indirect losses tied to a wide range of claims or proceedings about dispositions during the dissolution; the likely exposure is not stated.
  • The bill does not explain the proposed lawsuit or its possible effects on other people or organizations.