Legislative Assembly of Ontario · House

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

The official record of the sitting, from Hansard, by section and topic. Passages link to the Assembly’s video of Members’ Statements and Question Period where it is posted.

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Read from the beginning of the sitting

Sitting endedLast passage 6:58 p.m. ET

Orders of the Day

Plan to Protect Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2026 (No. 2) / Loi de 2026 sur le plan pour protéger l’Ontario (mesures budgétaires) (no 2)Bill 143

4:33 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

It’s an honour to rise today and to affirm support for an economic plan to keep our country and province strong. The backdrop of this discussion is—with the new Congress elected yesterday, it reminds us of the opportunity before Ontario to seize the moment, and often, as I hear members opposite speak about meeting the moment, it is always focused on the expenditure of the state. While there’s a need to invest, especially in times of economic distress—that’s why we have invested $30 billion to provide that stability and that security to our employment markets, to our industries besieged by these unjustified tariffs. Be under no illusion: What contrasts this government from the members opposite is we choose also to pursue paths of economic growth that don’t require, necessarily, a taxpayer investment. The ultimate case study of that principle, which is laughed at by the members opposite, is to move faster on permits to actually get foreign investment deployed on the ground for the benefit of jobs, growth and sovereignty. And in the mines’ ministry, it’s the ultimate case study—although there are so many case studies across the government—where we can and should move faster to drive economic growth. I don’t want to pretend for a moment in this time, when the country and people are facing great challenge, we should not or ought not invest in them. That is at the cornerstone of the Premier’s mission: Support the people, whatever it takes. But I think part of the wisdom of this government is we didn’t wait for the crisis to unfold; we got ahead of the curve. We had the foresight to recognize: Whereas the federal government decided to reduce the excess tax on gasoline more recently, we took decisive action years ago and then made it permanent. That’s 10 cents in the pocket of everyday families in rural Ontario, in northern Ontario, in the GTHA, in eastern Ontario, in the St. Lawrence region specifically, as the House leader would remind me. The bottom line is we understand that in order to buttress this economy, we’ve got to, as Prime Minister Mulroney said, “look around the corner of history.” We did that by pursuing a series of tax cuts and permit reforms that have helped to keep this economy strong. And don’t listen to me, Speaker; look at StatsCan data points when you see tens of thousands of people working as a consequence of that plan, even though we face an unprecedented attack on our industry and on our workers. How can both be true if not for—it’s not luck and it wasn’t a prayer; it was sound public policy to stand up for our sectors and to give them a bridge until we get past this insanity. I found it interesting: Today, as I listen and reflect on the debate, thoughtful discussions from members opposite—I appreciate hearing from them all. But somehow, today, the mid-term election results yesterday have sort of been decoupled. It’s as if we are an island unto ourselves; we are not part of a global economy interfacing with global headwinds much stronger and sometimes much more perverse than what we can control here at home. I think most sensible Canadians recognize the global links of trade and commerce, and that we need to think through a big lens. So that’s why I’m very proud: Part of this budget is the reaffirmation of a plan to build large-scale projects, to do the big things, the intergenerational lens to policy that was not here when the former Liberals were governing. This is a government, the party at the time, that was going to retire the Pickering Nuclear Generating Station—2,000 essential megawatts, 5,000 jobs—didn’t give a hoot; was prepared to close it. I mean, it’s this type of short-sightedness that really undermines public confidence. So we’re thinking long term, we’re building nuclear. Often, people say to us, “How does that help me today?” Well, the nuclear build-out at Pickering, the largest clean-energy construction project to date in our country, as we speak—at least of the active infrastructure projects; the feds have announced many and commenced few. This government started the largest clean energy project in Ontario, in Canada today, by saying yes to the refurbishment of the Pickering Nuclear Generating Station, creating 30,000 jobs for the people of Ontario. That is the rhetoric. How do you build a resilient economy? Well, you double down on your strengths—tariff-proof, recession-proof, made-in-Canada nuclear technology, the IP. The Speaker today hails from a region—like the House leader, like so many others—which literally conceived the Candu technology. It was birthed in Ontario, the IP remains in Ontario, the supply chain is 95% built with Ontario products and stamped with “Made in Canada.” It’s a 100-year asset, relative to 20 to 25 years for the renewable alternative, and so it begs the question: Why wouldn’t we do more of that? There’s nothing this President or this Congress can do to undermine that momentum to build this country strong, to get people working, to fire up the supply chain of Canada and secure sovereign power, which we need, because our economy is growing, our population is rising and electrification is on the rise. And thus, we’re going to meet that demand forecast of up to 90% more power by doubling down on the made-in-Canada strengths. I do want to speak a bit about the leadership of the government when it comes to affordability, because talking about the principle of getting ahead of the curve, we decided, last year, to launch the largest energy savings program in the history of Canada. Mr. Speaker, this energy savings program is a sharp contrast to the former Liberals. I’ll explain in three ways. The first: The former Liberals, by their design, constrained energy efficiency savings to communities in the province that had power constraints, so 30% of Ontario were eligible for energy efficiency savings. Our government brought forth a bill just two years ago to remove that prohibition so that every family in the smallest towns and the biggest cities of this province—everyone—could play a role in reducing the megawatts they use. Thus, their bills go down; we save power. It’s a win-win for the ratepayer and for the province and for the families of Ontario. So the first principle is, we transformed how we do this by allowing everyone to be able to participate. The second is we launched the largest energy savings program in Canadian history. Unlike the Liberals, who use short-term planning cycles for energy efficiency, we gave a 12-year road map, a 12-year guarantee, $10.9 billion of investment. It is larger when you add up all the provincial energy efficiency programs combined. That is ambition. That $11 billion, according to the IESO—the Independent Electricity System Operator—will return a 2-to-1 savings for the system—$20 billion unlocked of power we didn’t have to produce. It’s as if we took 1.5 Pickerings off the grid of the power we’re going to save. We cut the gas tax, and then we made it permanent—10 cents: 5 cents on diesel, 5 cents on gasoline. Why did we do it? How could members opposite have opposed it, then or now? Pre-Trump, post-Trump, it actually doesn’t matter. It comes back to the philosophy of the government: We think money should be back in people’s pockets. We’ve never raised a tax. There are just not many governments in modern history that can say that with a straight face. We’ve cut taxes and fees, development charges, anything that aggravates or increases costs on people. That’s, I think, a cornerstone of the government and the Premier’s legacy, that we’re trying to make life more affordable on issues of housing. As I approach my 40th birthday, Mr. Speaker—I’m now officially an old person— Interjections.

Official source

4:40 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

I’m not there yet, to be clear, so please don’t celebrate that. I’m going to hold on to that thirty-something for the last few weeks here. But when I was young, when I was elected at the tender old age of 31, I was elected in part because I felt, generationally, the government of the past—there was no one speaking for me, for us and now for your kids and grandchildren. Housing was the ultimate case study of the perversion of that government literally being so out of touch—increasing fees, development charges that sounded good and made them feel good, and yet the end effect was your kid couldn’t own a home in the communities they were raised—a serious intergenerational undermining. And what did we do? We cut the HST on every new home. We cut DCs, development charges, saving an average home in and around $200,000. That inspires confidence for young people that want to get a job, because somehow in this country there are people without jobs and, paradoxically, jobs without people. Our mission is to bridge that gap, through nuclear expansion, through mineral expansion, by moving fast on permits, by repatriating the critical mineral processing away from China, away from even America, away from Europe, back to this province, back to this country. We’ve taken a series of reforms that make a difference, and the proof is in the benchmarks. We were the second-slowest on earth; we’re now number one in Canada for attracting mining investment. We were the second-slowest in the OECD to open a mine; we’re now number two, behind Nevada, in one year. And so my point, Speaker, is our economic plan: prudent, cautious but focused on making life more affordable, thinking holistically of how to make this economy strong. I’m proud of the cabinet, the caucus and the Premier for doing the tough things and working together for the benefit of Canada, working with the federal government in the interest of our country, and I hope that sense of unity could prevail in this House today.

Official source

4:42 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Jamie West

I won’t miss an opportunity for the Minister of Energy and Mines to advocate for money and investment in my community, constantly talking about Dr. Mykytczuk and the MIRARCO project. But I think, more importantly, there is a lot of advertising money spent on the Ring of Fire—$12.2 million, I think, is what FOI brought forward. That project, best-case scenario, it’s going to be six years before they start work on a nickel mine. Vale in Sudbury, they have two ore deposits they can get to surface within the next two years. Is that something you’d be in support of as well?

Official source

4:43 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

Thank you to the member from Sudbury for the question. It isn’t an either/or proposition. As we often say to each other, Sudbury is an existing Ring of Fire, blessed with some of the best, most consequential geology on earth. We are absolutely supportive of mine expansions in Sudbury and across northern Ontario. That’s immediate-term action to create jobs. But I also believe, medium term, we ought to be thinking about how to create the networks of roads and transmission to actually allow for responsible resource development, in partnership with the First Nation. We’re doing a dual track: immediate action; medium term. The one commonality is that the government has talked a big game with the Ring of Fire, and we actually have a credible path to build the infrastructure to improve quality of life on the ground but also to unlock resources that are currently dominated by the most authoritarian regime on earth. I want to believe all of us—as imperfect as any country may perceive them to be—this is the gold standard of human rights and environmental labour standards. We should be proud of Canada today.

Official source

4:45 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme Lucille Collard

Thank you to the minister for his presentation. You defend your portfolio very well. But you said something very important during your presentation: You said, “Support the people, whatever it takes.” I do agree with that, and I think it’s great to support workers that are negatively impacted by the tariffs—the US tariffs, obviously—and I do appreciate your vision on energy. Of course we need a sound, long-term energy strategy. I am glad you’re devoting energy to that, but I would like to see your government devoting energy to the vulnerable people, because the vulnerable people have an impact on our economy. They are costly to our system, to emergency services, to hospital space. Why not devote energy to taking care of those people and saving money at the same time?

Official source

4:46 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

I have profound respect for the member opposite, so I do appreciate the question. The issue of how to support more vulnerable people in the economy is important for all governments, regardless of the economic circumstances, but it’s especially important today. I think about some of the most progressive tax reforms this government initiated out of the Ministry of Finance. The LIFT tax credit—the low-income tax credit—is the single-largest tax cut for low-income people in Ontario history. We didn’t wait for a recession, a depression or an economic trade war; we did it within, I believe, the first 12 months of our government. We enacted that to help cut taxes for everyday people. We increased funding to help create training and upskilling of people that wanted to get employment where the labour market was going. And, of course, we created energy efficiency programs. We enhanced the low-income and disability supports in electricity, intentionally targeting the very people you cited. I think about tuition that was cut 10% and then frozen for the entire duration of government, up until last year. There’s no government that did that. And—

Official source

4:48 p.m.Official Hansard

The Acting Speaker (Mr. John Jordan)

Thank you, Minister. The member for Sarnia–Lambton.

Official source

4:48 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Robert Bailey

Coming from Sarnia–Lambton, the headquarters of the petrochemical sector, the fuel sector, in the province of Ontario, I wonder if the minister could speak to that, to some of the plans he and his ministry have for expansion of industry.

Official source

4:48 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

I want to thank the member from Sarnia–Lambton for his question and leadership. I think, for many Canadians, it may be news to you that the first oil well in North America, actually, was in Oil Springs, Ontario, which is in the homeland of the proud member. This is a year before Pennsylvania and America discovered oil. The first in North America was right here in Ontario. It wasn’t Alberta; it wasn’t Saskatchewan; it was this province. So the leadership of extraction, exploration and responsible development is part of our lineage and our heritage for which we are proud. So it’s not surprising that we have the largest petrochemical and refinery hub of Canada in Sarnia–Lambton. The one thing we don’t have that every other G7 country does have is a strategic petroleum reserve, and we saw with the Strait of Hormuz that we need to have domestic supply. Our commitment is to build that reserve in addition to a sovereign pipeline that starts and ends in Canada, made by Canadian steel, Canadian workers and Canadian technology.

Official source

4:50 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Meegwetch to the minister for the presentation on the investments that are happening and speaking on the fall economic statement. I know that there are lots of things happening in Kiiwetinoong and lots of things happening around the world. When you have nine-year-old girls committing suicide in our communities—there are things happening. There are people protecting their lands—and, I know, with no proper free, prior, informed consent. Speaker, to those who want to destroy our lands, we will defeat you. To those who protect the inherent rights in the lands, we will support you. The strength of our people is in the power of our ancestors, is in the power of our identity. We’ve been doing this for thousands of years. We have the power in our ceremony. How are you going to address this issue—

Official source

4:51 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

It’s so important fundamentally that we do these projects in partnership. I think one of the areas where the government has achieved success is that we’ve actually been willing, meaningful partners. It’s not just in the engagement, for which we, of course, discharge that duty, but we’ve actually taken this much further, where the equity partnerships are unprecedented to improve the lives of those very young people. The small modular reactor project in Canada and Ontario was the first time any First Nation of this country signed on as a willing owner of the SMR, creating transformations for the next 65 years, for three, four, five, seven generations. We look at every transmission line. Every storage project we’ve authorized has been done in true partnership and with 50-50 equity because it’s not just about the business case. It’s about the effects on the ground to improve the quality of life; to provide the revenue and the resources to support more mental health supports, education, social infrastructure. I believe all can win. Businesses, families, First Nations can have sovereignty if we do this together.

Official source

4:52 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. David Smith

Northern Ontario is home to some of the most significant critical mineral opportunities in the world, including the Ring of Fire. As demand for critical minerals continues to grow, Ontario has an opportunity to become a global leader in the development and processing of these essential resources. Our government has committed $1 billion towards infrastructure to unlock the Ring of Fire, and the federal government has recently committed to matching that investment to advance critical mineral road infrastructure. Can the member explain how these investments will help northern Ontario’s economic potential, creating good-paying jobs and strengthening Ontario’s critical mineral supply chain?

Official source

4:53 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

I want to thank the parliamentary assistant for his good work on this file. What I would simply conclude with is, the Critical Minerals Processing Fund was designed in part to end the ripping and shipping of Canada’s resources and Ontario’s minerals abroad. It offended us pre-Trump, and it is now entirely indefensible in the post-Trump world that we continue to export the raw materials for all the value-added investment to go anywhere but here. So we created a $500-million fund, a small upfront investment of the state, to catalyze significant private investment, and we’re seeing jobs come back to the province. The first project that has been designated is Generation Mining. We’re talking about hundreds of good-paying jobs building a mine, a mill and the downstream conversion, meaning we’ve maintained the entire supply chain in the province for the benefit of Canada—so important as we repatriate investment and help develop allied, democratic supply chains.

Official source

4:54 p.m.Official Hansard

The Acting Speaker (Mr. John Jordan)

Further debate? The member for Spadina-North York.

Official source

4:54 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

North York is a nice community as well, but it’s not the one I serve.

Official source

4:54 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

Northern Ontario—North York, yes. Okay. It’s an honour to rise and speak to the fall economic statement. In my response to the fall economic statement, I just want to contrast and compare some of the things that Premier Ford has said to the actions and the outcomes, because you know one thing about this Premier: When he says something, you can take it to the bank. For example, when he was elected in 2018, he decried “15 years of the previous government’s mismanagement” and promised to “get Ontario’s finances back on track,” because he was “very fiscally responsible” and the Conservatives are “prudent fiscal managers with the taxpayers’ money.” Those are the words from the Premier. So, eight years in government, and the new fall economic statement comes out, and the deficit is—what do you think it is, folks?

Official source

4:55 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

It’s $17 billion. That’s $3 billion higher than it was expected to be six months ago. The debt is $483 billion.

Official source

4:55 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

Next year we’re going to hit half a trillion dollars, yes. The interest on debt from when this government was elected, when they inherited the government from the Liberals—it was $12 billion a year we were paying in interest on debt. What do you think it is today?

Official source

4:56 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

It’s $17 billion. Thank you to the member from Hamilton. You’ve got the numbers too, right? So this is eight years of being prudent fiscal managers with the taxpayers’ money. We now have $17 billion going to interest, and we’re going to hit half a trillion dollars in debt. Let’s see. Before he was elected, the Premier said quite famously he was going to “stop the gravy train,” and he said, “The party with the taxpayers’ money is over.” So let’s do an update. How is that going? Well, let’s see. I’ve done a list of some of the scandals and the wasted money here. Last summer, the Ontario NDP exposed expense scandals by some of the government members there. There was one who spent $15,000 on hotels in Toronto, when he lived in Toronto, and another $100,000 on lobster, oysters, steak dinners with—yes, from his riding association, but that was also taxpayer-subsidized. There was another one who spent $27,000 on hotels—not to outdo the first—$27,000 on Toronto hotels, and he lived in Brampton.

Official source

4:57 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

Now, okay, Brampton is far; I know. The member from Sudbury says Brampton is far, but maybe you could drive home at the end of the day. I don’t know. Especially if you live in Toronto, I don’t think you need the Toronto hotel. We’ve always been wondering, “Why did he need a Toronto hotel?” He’s come up with different excuses, but none of them quite hold water. Let’s see. There was also $117 million in partisan advertising just in the last year. These days, in question period, we’re debating the billion-dollar OSAP fraud with the private career colleges. Last year, there was the $2.5-billion Skills Development Fund—$800 million went to very low-ranking applications, most of them from Conservative Party donors. There was $9 billion that this government has spent on private nursing agencies. The list just keeps going here, guys—$5.1-billion taxpayer subsidy to developers. Now, this was Bill 23, a few years ago. They gave a $5.1-billion taxpayer subsidy to developers to build housing faster. They even had the $8.3-billion greenbelt scandal, because they were going to build those homes faster on the greenbelt by developers that had recently bought land in the greenbelt. This government passed legislation to remove the greenbelt protections, and they stood to make $8.3 billion. So how is that going? Do you know where Ontario ranks in housing starts per capita in the country?

Official source

4:58 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

Not quite. No, no. We’re not dead last. We’re only second-last. Interjections.

Official source

4:59 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

Yes, yes. We’re second-last in housing starts. That $5.1-billion taxpayer subsidy to developers—that has really helped us out, apparently. We have gotten good value for that. Let’s see. There’s also the $2.2-billion subsidy for the Ontario Place spa, because all of us know how much the Premier loves a good spa. Then there are the cost overruns, where the government says, “Hey, we’re going to build this thing, and it should cost this”—and then it seems to creep up a little bit. For example, the Mississauga hospital is 16% higher than what was projected. Okay, 16%—it’s $4 billion. The Ottawa Hospital: The initial cost was going to be $2.8 billion. What do you think it is now? The Ottawa Hospital started at $2.8 billion. What do you think the projection is now? Anybody?

Official source

5:00 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

No, keep going. Five billion? No, not $5 billion; not $6 billion; not $7 billion; not $8 billion, not $9 billion. It’s going to be $10 billion for the Ottawa Hospital—$2.8 billion, to $10 billion. Interjections.

Official source

5:00 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

Yes. This is the prudent fiscal management of this government, economic discipline of this government. The Ontario Line started off at $11 billion. Does anybody happen to know what the estimate is now? It was $11 billion for the Ontario Line, going from what used to be the Ontario Science Centre—shame on you for ever closing it—down to Ontario Place. What do you think the cost is now? So $11 billion to—

Official source

5:00 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

It’s $34 billion. It started at $11 billion. It’s now going to be $34 billion. This is another cost overrun. That’s a $23-billion cost overrun. If you’re building something and you’re thinking, “Oh, I’ll get out my pencil. I’ve got to figure out materials. I’ve got to figure out the land costs. I’ve got to figure out all the labour costs and stuff,” and you come up with $11 billion and then it goes to $34 billion, I think you made a mistake; I think there was something wrong somewhere along the line, and maybe you need to have somebody else managing your finances. And I think the people of Ontario really need to have somebody else managing our finances because this government is not doing too well, really. Then there’s the Eglinton Crosstown. Remember the Eglinton Crosstown? Their initial budget was around $4 billion. Does anybody know how much it went over and what the final cost of the Eglinton Crosstown was?

Official source

5:02 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

I’ll just say it was only six years late. But how much was the cost overrun? Anybody? Give me a guess. It started at $4 billion. What do you think it ended up at?

Official source

5:02 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

No, no. You’re overshooting because of the Ontario Line. No. It was only $12 billion. It was only three times the initial estimate. So it wasn’t the full—no, much, much lower. I’ll tell you, all of these cost overruns don’t stop the government from announcing new plans. They’ve got all kinds of plans. You know the beautiful Toronto waterfront, Canada’s number one tourist destination—last year 28 million visitors came and enjoyed it. Well, what people really want down there, apparently, is to have jets flying by every two minutes. That’s what they want there. And we can do it. Premier Ford says he can put jets there, flying by every two minutes, for the low, low cost of only $5 billion. Remember, that’s the initial cost—

Official source

5:03 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

Does it come with earplugs? I don’t know. We’re going to need something. Apparently, you’re going to need a mask for the fumes, and you’ll need earplugs for the jets flying over. But you’ll still be able to enjoy the waterfront, I am sure, with the Premier’s plan. And that $5 billion—that’s the initial estimate, and we’ve seen what happens to their estimates. And then, of course, there’s the tunnel under the 401. Can I just say to the government in all seriousness, please—I drive on the 401, so don’t start tearing it up and trying to dig a tunnel underneath. Traffic is a nightmare already. Please don’t do that. The estimated cost is starting at $100 billion. And it’s not going to improve traffic. It’s just going to create a traffic nightmare. Let’s see. There are just so many cost overruns. The Premier said that the party with the taxpayer dollars was coming to an end, but what he really meant to say was that the party with the taxpayer dollars was just beginning—and it’s all in the fall economic statement.

Official source

5:04 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Sandy Shaw

I just want to be clear that $500 billion—that’s half a trillion dollars—is the accumulated debt of this province. It’s about $35,000 of debt for every man, woman and child. Even though the kids don’t know yet, they’ve been saddled with a lifetime of debt from this government. That $500 billion, I said this morning, because it’s hard to get your head around—if those were seconds, that would be 15,850 years. So it’s a big, big number. It’s easy, when you hear these numbers, not to understand how significant this is and the kind of debt we’re in. Despite what this government says about trying to make sure we’re sovereign and our industries are sovereign, when you owe this kind of debt to who knows where, we don’t have sovereignty. We owe money, and we are beholden to whoever owns that debt. Do you believe, really, that we are a sovereign province when we have so much—

Official source

5:05 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

It reminds me of what the Premier said: “the good old days of Liberal fiscal mismanagement.” It was only 15 years of Liberal fiscal mismanagement. They also increased the debt massively. Their scandals, I think, were relatively minor compared to what this government has done. There was the $3-billion gas plant scandal; the $700-billion Ornge air scandal; the billion-dollar eHealth scandal; the cash-for-access scandal, where you would pay $5,000 to $10,000. There were 150 of those dinners in just a two-year period under the former Liberal government—cash for access, $5,000 to $10,000. Now, this government only charges $1,500 if you want to get some free tax dollars in exchange for a donation to the Conservative Party. So yes, $500 billion: That’s a hell of a big debt. We’re paying for it now, and future generations are going to be paying for it. Really, we need a little bit of fiscal management and we need some honest government in this province. That’s why I’m with the NDP.

Official source

5:07 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Andrew Dowie

I want to thank the member from Spadina–Fort York for his remarks. I know in his community, and certainly many across Ontario, we are finding it increasingly difficult to undertake trade. Our companies are looking for customers. Some of those relationships have been severed due to economic nationalism, tariffs and the general economic environment that we’re in. I think one of the struggles that businesses face today is liquidity, keeping their people employed and ensuring that they have a place to go to, a place to work at, when things pick back up. Some of the measures in the FES—the competitiveness tax credit is among them—are there to support those businesses and keep those employees working and bringing home paycheques at the end of the month. I’m hoping you may be able to elaborate—through you, Mr. Speaker—on what measures you see that are worthwhile for industry to keep their people working.

Official source

5:08 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Chris Glover

I would say one of the things this government needs to do is they need to look at their own procurement. One of the problems with the jobs is, our jobs are being farmed out to the United States, and this government is one of the worst offenders. We’re losing 700 WSIB jobs in Ontario because this government is passing those jobs, contracted out, to an American corporation, Iron Mountain. They contracted those jobs out. They closed down small businesses that were running ServiceOntario outlets and gave those contracts to Staples, an American corporation. The government has a Buy Ontario website. The Premier actually said that if municipalities aren’t buying and procuring their goods from Ontario businesses, he would punish them. But the Buy Ontario website is contracted out to an American company. This Conservative government contracted the website that’s Buy Ontario to an American corporation instead of an Ontario corporation. So the government really needs to look at its own procurement and support—

Official source

5:09 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme France Gélinas

In the fall economic statement, they restated their intention of spending $50 billion for the construction and upgrading of hospitals. That would bring us 3,000 new beds over the next 10 years. There’s $50 billion for the next 10 years. But now we know that the construction of the hospital in Ottawa took $10 billion. How many of those 50 hospitals do you think we’ll be able to do in the next 10 years?

Official source

5:10 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

It’s good to be here debating another fall economic statement. Something I’m just trying to wrap my head around again is that repeated notion and message from this government about fiscal responsibility. Every year, I hear about balancing the budget. We’ll get there eventually. It seems to be a huge problem when the Liberals are in power, but the moment they get into power, it’s just nothing but spending. We’re not getting what we deserve or need when it comes to this historic spending every single year. After eight long years of this Ford government, Ontarians are paying more, they’re waiting longer and they’re still getting less. This fall economic statement, it wasn’t an opportunity to blame Donald Trump; it was an opportunity to fix the government’s own mistakes. Instead, it ignores the issues that Ontarians and families are facing every single day. I want to start off by talking about health care. I’ve been eager to talk about health care. We’ve been very focused on OSAP and that absolute disaster that’s going on—hundreds of millions of dollars just flowing to a handful of private career colleges that are possibly going to be under investigation by the OPP. Part of the reason why I ran in the first place was because I was a student who was studying to become a nurse. I was a part of that first gutting of OSAP back in 2019. It made life very difficult. But then I entered health care as a registered nurse back at the start of COVID, which was a very fun time to jump in as a baby nurse. As a registered nurse, I know that budgets aren’t just numbers. They determine whether patients receive timely care. They determine whether nurses and health care workers are properly supported, that they have enough resources and people around them to work in a safe environment and to provide that quality care we want to provide to our patients. Having had the opportunity to work and pick up shifts over the five-month—probably historically—long break from this Legislature, I have never seen hospitals this bad. We are bursting at the seams right now. And what are hospitals doing across Ontario? They’re firing registered nurses, they’re firing health care workers. They’ve been directed to pinch pennies, that there’s no more money coming. We actually see a $500-million cut in health care than was actually promised in the last spring. Hospitals are having to do the impossible. They’ve been dealing with the brunt of our health care crisis for a long time now. A lot of folks, a lot of people, a lot of families don’t have anywhere else to go when they urgently need care. There’s a ton of people who don’t have a family doctor, a nurse practitioner. But when they urgently need care, even if they have that family doctor—walk-in clinics are readily available, usually full by 10 a.m. or noon, shutting their doors to anyone else who wants to go there, leaving the only place for them to go the emergency room, where they know they will be waiting an eternity, surrounded by a lot of other sick people, surrounded by people with varying degrees of urgency and emergency to get treated. When our hospitals are bursting at the seams; when I walk into a patient’s room that is supposed to be a room of two, but now there’s a third bed in there; when I walk into a quad room, which we are supposed to get rid of, and now there are now five patients in there—those are patients in rooms. I’m not even talking about the patients that are in the hallways or the closets. But that has become the norm in Ontario. We’re spending $10 billion on the new Civic Campus, with no net new beds, mind you. Queensway Carleton goes on ignored by this health minister and this government. They’re shovel-ready. They have a $600-million plan to expand the emergency room and double the size. But somehow, we’ve let the new Civic Campus, which we need, balloon from $2 billion to $10 billion. It’s absurd. I don’t understand how this happened. Where’s that fiscal responsibility I keep hearing about? It’s not happening. Right now, we are just treating people at a point of crisis or emergency. There is next to no investment when it comes to things like community health, prevention, public health access, making sure that people have the opportunity and ability to stay healthy. It’s much cheaper to treat someone who’s pre-diabetic than someone who’s in full-blown CKD. It’s much cheaper to treat someone who’s in stage 1 cancer than stage 4, let alone it being just ultimately better for that individual and their health. I was very disappointed to see there’s basically no vision for our health care system in this FES. To be honest with you, Speaker, I don’t buy the numbers that this government has released about how many patients they have attached. The government won’t release their methodology for how they came to that number. I know for a fact that we have people that have been attached, but they are not actually able to see those teams or family physicians. So what’s going on here? Emergency rooms are over capacity. The one I work at often is at 130% capacity. Imagine going to work every single day and you have to deal with 30% more than you’re capable of. The shifts that pop up on my phone every single day where they need help hospital-wide—it’s every day. The solution here is to fire nurses, to fire health care workers. This isn’t because the hospitals want to do this; it’s because they have to because that’s what this government has allowed and created for them. Residents in my riding of Nepean are not asking for miracles. They’re just asking for basic health care. I want to talk about education in my last few minutes here. We have ongoing negotiations right now between the teacher and education unions and the government. I’m not going to hold my breath on that one. But the teacher unions are advocating for very serious things. It’s really shocking, what I hear about what’s going on in classrooms—the violence, the chaos. Kids aren’t learning. Kids can’t read anymore. What’s going on? Ontario’s public education system used to be something that we could be so proud of, but this government hasn’t kept up with just how fast society has changed, and this education system has become something that no one can thrive in. Teachers, education workers, staff don’t have the resources and support they need. How is that teacher who has 30-plus students in his class supposed to provide a quality education to their students when they’re dealing with someone who is potentially violent at the back of the room? They’re having to deal with mental health crises. They don’t have supplies. They certainly don’t have time to log into that Staples portal and purchase $40 crayons. Their priorities are just all over the place. If we’re going to be going into this much of a deficit and spend this much, I expect—and I know taxpayers and Ontarians expect—for us to actually get something out of it. Ask yourselves: After eight years, nearly nine years, is your health care any better? Are your hospital wait times less? Is your kid getting a better education? Are there homes available to buy? Can you afford those homes? Has the cost of living gone down? What actual, measurable cost-of-living measures has this government taken? We hear a lot about, yes, the gas tax cut, but what else have they done? They still brag about the licence plate sticker removal, which was years and years and years ago. That’s not helping them anymore. The cost of living has gone through the roof with inflation, and people are struggling. They just want to feel heard. They want to feel that their government is actually listening to them. So when you present a budget like this with a deficit like this, we certainly would expect more. I hope that the results from last night inspire this government to show the power of listening to real people on the ground, those voters who want to be heard and want their government to be actually fighting for them. With that, Speaker, it’s tough to have to stand here and see these bills every day. It really goes to show to me just a government that’s frankly out of touch, and it’s time for some change.

Official source

5:20 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Stephen Lecce

I do want to thank the member from Nepean—like the Minister of Long-Term Care, front-line nurses. We’re grateful for your service. This will be the first question and maybe the only question I’ll ask the member from Nepean, but appreciating your concern with our fiscal plan, I am curious if you have the same level of concern with Prime Minister Carney’s government, who doubled the deficit under his tenure, and the federal Liberal government, who doubled the debt in the last eight years.

Official source

5:20 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

That’s the thing with this government, Speaker, is they love to point at the feds. They love to point to anyone else but themselves. They have had eight years—they have had eight years—and it’s always someone else’s fault. You ran on balancing the budget. You ran on being fiscally responsible. So you can go ahead and point to the feds. You love to take credit when they do good stuff, and then when you screw up, you point the finger at them.

Official source

5:21 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Jamie West

Thank you to my colleague for his debate. He mentioned several times the Conservatives took eight years, almost nine years to start fixing the problems that were happening under the Liberal majority government prior to that. I remember when I was running in 2018, that in Sudbury, we were leading the province in hallway medicine. That has grown under the Conservative government. We had issues with homelessness with the Liberal government, but under the Conservative government, it’s visible. There are a lot more needs for homeless people and for affordable rent. I’m just wondering if my colleague can reflect on this and what he would like to see moving forward.

Official source

5:22 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

Again, we need to remember where we are today. I was elected in 2025. We have a new generation of Liberal MPPs here, an amazing caucus that I am super proud of. So, yes, we can look back, but here’s the thing: We actually look back and learn. We want to do better. I’m working on repairing and rebuilding relationships from the past. No government is going to be perfect. We have a new generation of amazing MPPs here. What I want to see from this budget is I want to see us actually addressing what the provincial government is responsible for: better health care, better education, housing, mental health, long-term care. We’re not seeing anything actually progress the way that we need to. I will talk your ear off all day about health care. There’s a lot more that needs to be done, but again, it comes from actually investing in the community, in access and prevention, not just slapping band-aid solutions on hospitals, which isn’t even happening anymore.

Official source

5:23 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Natalie Pierre

Thank you to the member opposite for his remarks earlier. I heard the member talk about the importance of access to a family doctor, so I just wanted to share some of the investments that have been made in my community in Burlington. Under the province’s primary care action plan, we have received funding to create a new community health centre in my community and to also expand the number of patients attached to the Burlington Family Health Team. They have effectively eliminated the wait-list in my community. I just did a quick search online through haltonregion.ca, and we have 27 patients in Burlington, in my riding, that are accepting new patients there. I thought I would just share that information because you said you weren’t sure how we were tracking how patients were attached to a family doctor. That’s through Health Care Connect, and in my riding, that’s through the Burlington Ontario Health Team. I was wondering if you can tell this House why you wouldn’t support those kinds of—

Official source

5:24 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

Why won’t your government release the methodology for how you got to those statistics? The Minister of Health was asked and she won’t release it. So you came up with a number out of nowhere, and we have some data that shows that these statistics just are not true. It’s slightly bending the truth, which this government is absolutely famous for. I support the notion of attaching patients, but they need a real person to be attached to. They need to be attached to a family health team— Interjection.

Official source

5:25 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

Release the methodology, member. Release the methodology. When people don’t have a nurse practitioner or a family doctor to go to, but they’re just attached because they’ve been removed from a wait-list, it doesn’t actually mean anything. So again, you want to be transparent and accountable? Tell us how you actually got to those numbers. Talk to your constituents—

Official source

5:25 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Lise Vaugeois

Thank you to the member from Nepean for your comments. I wondered, you touched a bit on post-secondary education, and we heard from the Minister of Energy about all of these high-tech jobs that are coming up, but I don’t know. I had the chance to meet with the Ontario Confederation of University Faculty Associations today. They were saying how impossible it is for students to actually take engineering anymore or take any of those degrees because they can’t afford it. Do you see a contradiction in these plans—the spending plans and the lack of funding for post-secondary education?

Official source

5:26 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

Thank you to that member. It’s a really important point, action versus words. We see a lot of that, a lot of really big words by the Premier and this government, but when it comes to the execution, it’s just not there, or not necessarily what it should be. When we are ripping the rug out from under thousands of students that are in the private sector right now, who are trying to get into a particular career, better their lives—I don’t understand how that’s helping people get into the workforce. When it comes to those engineers—you have all these really brilliant people that are maybe thinking of leaving Ontario to go study elsewhere. We’re not going to be able to keep that talent here. I also want to mention, I had the privilege of visiting the university—I’m blanking on which university it was, but they have a great engineering program there. When I asked all the students, “What do you want to do after you graduate?” You know what they told me? “I want to go to Silicon Valley. There’s nothing here for me in Ontario.” We need to be investing here in Ontario to create—

Official source

5:27 p.m.Official Hansard

The Acting Speaker (Mr. John Jordan)

Thank you. The member for Beaches–East York.

Official source

5:27 p.m.Official Hansard

Ms. Mary-Margaret McMahon

Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. It’s nice to see you in the chair. To the fine member from Nepean: Do you feel that this government is wasting a lot of taxpayers’ dollars on ridiculous things versus spending taxpayers’ dollars on services Ontarians desperately need?

Official source

5:28 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

Thank you to my fabulous colleague for that question. The answer is yes. It’s the total lack of priorities here, right? When we have over $100 billion to go towards incessant Protect Ontario ads—every radio interview that I’ve done recently to talk about the billion-dollar OSAP scandal is always after a Protect Ontario ad, every single time— Interjections.

Official source

5:28 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

You’re proud of that, eh? Wow. They’re clapping because they love spending all that money. It’s just wild. Actually, the one that I just heard was about how they’re creating jobs for young people, and then I went on to talk about OSAP and how they have thrown tens of thousands of students across Ontario out of OSAP, out of their programs, so they can’t enter the workforce here. This is all about patting themselves on the back. We’re not focused on health care, we’re not focused on education, post-secondary, cost of living—all the things that the provincial government is responsible for.

Official source

5:29 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. David Smith

Thank you to the member from Nepean for his remarks. Sir, you speak about young people in the next generation. Ontario attracts new investment in advanced manufacturing, artificial intelligence and critical minerals. We need to make sure our workforce has the skills to hit these jobs. That is why our government is investing $1.7 billion to support 70,000 post-secondary seats annually in high-demand trades. Will the opposition support these investments to prepare Ontario workers for the jobs of tomorrow, and can they explain to students and young people across the province why they would not stand against expanding—

Official source

5:30 p.m.Official Hansard

MPP Tyler Watt

Thank you to that member for that question. Of course I support people getting into the trades. I’d like to see where this money is actually going, but when we look at access to post-secondary in this province, it’s just going down. The mess with OSAP right now—it’s nuts. Students’ grants have been slashed. Their loans have been cut. People have been thrown off of OSAP entirely. So I apologize if I don’t exactly trust the minister of MCURES to actually facilitate a goal like that.

Official source

5:30 p.m.Official Hansard

Hon. Steve Clark

It’s great to see my neighbour in the chair this afternoon. I’m looking forward to you taking your normal rotation in your flowing robes in the future. We’re debating the province’s fall economic statement, Bill 143. It’s a very important bill for us. I was extremely pleased, Speaker—through you to the members—that our Premier stood up at the end of question period today and talked about what happened last night. It was a solid rebuke, last evening in the House and in the Senate, of President Trump’s policies. I thought, given that historic election by the American people, our Premier so rightly acknowledged the fact that, come the end of January, when those Governors, senators and congressmen and women get sworn in, our ministers will be dispatched across those states and in Washington to continue to talk about our plan for the people. The fall economic statement is an extension of the government’s plan to protect workers, to help businesses and communities deal with President Trump’s tariffs. It was interesting; I saw the leader of the third party respond to what the Premier said in the House, and he indicated that you need to have a plan. I think we all acknowledge, on this side of the House, that we need to continue to fight for workers, to fortify key industries and sectors and to secure those good-paying jobs in Ontario, both now and in the future. This plan, this bill, needs to continue to move forward, knowing that in January, our ministers are going to continue the fight to ensure that our message and our plan are put forward. So moving this bill forward in the Legislature is very, very important. Speaker, I’d like to ask you to test the debate that’s taken place for the fall economic statement, and I move that the question now be put.

Official source

5:30 p.m.Official Hansard

The Acting Speaker (Mr. John Jordan)

The government House leader has moved that the question be now put. There has been over nine hours of debate, with 27 members speaking to the bill. I am satisfied that there has been sufficient debate to allow this question to be put to the House. Is it the pleasure of the House that the motion carry? All those in favour of the motion that the question be now put, please say “aye.” All those opposed to the motion that the question be now put, please say “nay.” In my opinion, the ayes have it. A recorded vote being required, it will be deferred to the next instance of deferred votes.

Official source

Protecting Ontario’s Streets and Communities Act, 2026 / Loi de 2026 visant à protéger les rues et les collectivités de l’OntarioBill 119

5:31 p.m.Official Hansard

Resuming the debate adjourned on October 27, 2026, on the motion for third reading of the following bill:

Official source

5:31 p.m.Official Hansard

Bill 119, An Act to enact two new Acts and to amend various other Acts / Projet de loi 119, Loi édictant deux nouvelles lois et modifiant diverses autres lois.

Official source

5:31 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme Lucille Collard

I’m happy to resume the debate on Bill 119. This is a Liberal lead-off, and my colleague from Kanata–Carleton had initiated it, so I’m going to continue. It’s a real pleasure to stand up again and speak on behalf of the people of Ottawa–Vanier. I want to start by stating that passing a law is not the same as delivering justice. It sounds obvious, but the fact is, a bill can pass this House and receive royal assent, but that alone does not help a victim, make a community safer or improve access to justice if the legislation is not supplemented by effective implementation measures. Often, those are developed in regulations. The other important element is that adequate financial and human resources are allocated for the implementation of the bill because, without those things, even legislation with good ideas and good intention is only words on paper. Bill 119 is an omnibus bill with 16 schedules, and I will not address every one of them today—I wouldn’t have time anyway. Some of those measures, I have to admit, are relatively straightforward and easy to support, but some of them need to be looked at more closely, not necessarily because we disagree with their stated objective, but because the real test is whether or not the measures being proposed will actually achieve them. That is the lens through which I want to examine this bill today. Will it work? Is it properly resourced? And will the people who are supposed to benefit from these changes actually see a difference in their lives? Bill 119 is titled the Protecting Ontario’s Streets and Communities Act, but does it really do that? I’m the Liberal critic for the Attorney General, but I’m also the representative for the people in Ottawa–Vanier, a mother of four wonderful children and a former school trustee. Because of these roles, I have been actively working on ways to protect vulnerable people in our community and in our schools, and so I will acknowledge that there are some good provisions in this bill. There are measures that help survivors of human trafficking escape coerced debts, measures to improve the enforcement of restraining orders and measures to provide additional legal remedies for victims. They are all good to support. But, Speaker, we also have a responsibility to look beyond the title of a bill and ask whether the provisions contained in the bill will actually achieve what the government promises. Because a government can introduce legislation, announce tougher measures and claim it is making our streets safer, but just saying it doesn’t make it so. Real public safety depends on effective laws, properly functioning institutions, prevention, enforcement that respects constitutional rights and meaningful support for victims. This is where I have serious concerns about the bill, because too often, this government appears more interested in demonstrating that it is taking action than in ensuring that its actions will actually deliver lasting results. That distinction matters enormously to the people who depend on our justice system. I want to spend some time discussing the human trafficking provision in this bill because the issue is something I’ve devoted significant time and energy over a long period of time and, despite the personal legislative achievement, it remains unfinished business. It is something I’ve worked on since I was first elected six years ago. I can’t imagine that it’s been that long, but I have to say that it’s been a remarkable learning experience, both personally and in my role as a member of Parliament, to get this legislation through. In fact, I consider this one of the most meaningful legislative initiatives I have undertaken, mostly because of the people who inspired it. I started with conversations with survivors of human trafficking; women who had endured unimaginable exploitation and who, even after escaping their traffickers, continued to suffer the consequences. I learned about coerced debts, which are financial obligations imposed on victims by their traffickers, often through fraud, threats or manipulation. These debts could follow survivors for years, damaging their credit, limiting their ability to secure housing, find employment or rebuild their lives. Imagine finding the courage to escape an abusive and exploitative situation, only to discover that your trafficker still has a hold on your future through debts you never freely agreed to incur. I also learned something that deeply disturbed me: Human trafficking was happening much closer to home than I had imagined. It was happening in our communities and even in our schools—the very schools my own children attended. Once I understood the extent of the problem, I just simply could not look the other way. I felt a responsibility to act, so I began researching the issue, consulting with survivors and organizations working on the front lines and collaborating with legislative counsel to develop a solution. That work led to the introduction of my bill, Bill 99, in March 2022. Unfortunately, when the Legislature was dissolved ahead of the June 2022 election, the bill died on the order paper, but I wasn’t prepared to let it end there. I knew the issue was too important, and I also believed that protecting survivors from coerced debts was something every political party should be able to support. So I decided to approach things differently. Rather than reintroducing the bill on my own, I reached out to colleagues from across the political spectrum. I listened to their concerns, worked through potential obstacles and sought their support. That is how Bill 41 became a co-sponsored bill. It was the result of considerable research, consultation, negotiation and above all a shared determination to do something meaningful for survivors. And despite the many hurdles of the legislative process, we succeeded: Bill 41 became law. Speaker, that was a proud moment for me. It demonstrated what the Legislature can accomplish when members put aside partisan differences and work together toward a common goal. But there is another side to this story. Passing a law is not the same as changing someone’s life. And despite having received royal assent back in 2023, Bill 41 was never fully implemented. The mechanisms needed to provide survivors with the relief promised by the legislation were never put in place. I have raised this issue repeatedly with the government, including with the Attorney General, because every month of delay represents another month in which survivors continue to face financial barriers that this Legislature agreed should be addressed. I have to admit that this has been deeply frustrating. I take pride in what we accomplished legislatively, but I also feel a profound responsibility towards the survivors who shared their experiences with me and placed their hopes in this legislation. At times, I’ve even wondered whether we have let them down, because they did not come forward simply to help us pass a bill. They came forward because they needed change, they needed relief and they needed a genuine opportunity to rebuild their lives, and they are still waiting. That is why I welcome the government’s decision to incorporate these protections into Bill 119, even if it means that Bill 41 will be repealed. I recognize that this represents another opportunity to finally deliver on the commitment we made to survivors, but I want to be very clear: I will measure the success of these provisions not by their passage through the Legislature, but by their implementation and the tangible relief they provide to survivors. We cannot afford another legislative achievement that remains only on paper. There is also a broader dimension to this work, Speaker. Through my role as Ontario’s representative on the women’s network of the Assemblée parlementaire de la Francophonie, I have had the opportunity to share our legislative approach with parliamentarians from other jurisdictions—I would say across the world. And there is considerable international interest in the measures Ontario has developed to protect survivors of human trafficking from coerced debts. Other parliamentarians are looking at us. They are looking at our experience, and they are considering similar protections in their own jurisdictions. They are following our progress. That has given me an additional reason to push for implementation. Imagine if we could see that kind of protection applied internationally, we could make a real difference for survivors. Ontario has an opportunity to demonstrate leadership, not only here at home but internationally. But leadership requires more than good intentions or legislation that looks impressive on paper; it requires follow-through. And so, Speaker, as we consider these provisions in Bill 119, I want to emphasize that this is not simply a technical legislative exercise. It is about fulfilling a promise: a promise to survivors that escaping exploitation should also mean having a fair chance to escape the financial consequences imposed by their traffickers; a promise that our justice system will recognize the realities of human trafficking and provide meaningful remedies; and a promise that when this Legislature comes together to address an injustice, we will see that work through to the end. I am proud of what we’ve accomplished with Bill 41, but I will be prouder still on the day the first survivor actually benefits from these protections. That is the outcome I have been working toward for six years, and that is the outcome I expect this government to deliver. One issue deserves particular attention: Under Bill 119, a survivor cannot simply initiate the process independently, a designated organization must be involved. The minister will decide which organizations qualify, and those organizations must have experience working with trafficking survivors, receive Ontario government funding and satisfy government accountability requirements. That all makes sense. There is good reason to involve organizations that understand trauma and human trafficking because survivors should not have to navigate another complicated legal process alone. But we also need to ask whether this requirement could inadvertently become a gatekeeper. What happens to a survivor in a rural or northern community where there is no designated organization nearby or to a francophone survivor who cannot access services in French—those are highly sensitive services—or to an Indigenous survivor who wants culturally appropriate support? And we know, unfortunately, that Indigenous people are very much targeted by those traffickers. What happens if the organizations doing this work simply do not have the staff or funding to take on these additional responsibilities? Access to a statutory right should not depend on your postal code or on whether the nearest community organization has enough capacity to take your case. Funding must follow the responsibility. And that brings me to funding. Bill 119 gives designated organizations substantial responsibilities. They will review cases, assess whether debts appear to have resulted from trafficking, notify creditors and help survivors navigate the dispute resolution process. That is specialized, sensitive and potentially time-consuming work. The government cannot simply assign those responsibilities to front-line organizations without providing the resources to do them properly. If organizations face months-long waiting lists because they have not been adequately funded, then we will technically have created a remedy while practically denying survivors access to it. I would, therefore, urge the government to provide dedicated, predictable funding for organizations that are expected to administer this process. Regulations cannot become another delay. There is another lesson from Bill 41. Passing legislation is only the beginning.

Official source

5:43 p.m.Official Hansard

Mme Lucille Collard

Many important details of this new framework are left to regulations, including aspects of referrals, the review undertaken by designated organizations, agreements concerning coerced debts and the operation of the adjudication process. Schedule 9 itself comes into force on a date proclaimed by the government, and that makes implementation timelines critically important. Survivors have already waited years. I would therefore like the government to provide a clear implementation timetable. When will the regulations be completed? When will organizations be designated? When will adjudicators be appointed? Most importantly, on what date will survivors actually be able to use this process? I particularly welcome the government’s commitment to a trauma-informed dispute resolution process. The government’s own description of Bill 119 says the new framework is intended to provide such a process for coerced debt with designated survivor support organizations assisting victims. But “trauma-informed” cannot simply be a label. A survivor should not have to repeatedly recount their exploitations to different officials, they should not have to prove a criminal offence occurred, and they should not be forced into unnecessary confrontation with a creditor. The evidentiary standard must recognize the reality that trafficking frequently occurs without documentation. That is why the provision explicitly stating that a police report or investigation is not necessary is so important. The regulation must preserve that principle. Speaker, I am proud that an idea that began as my private members’ bill will now become part of a broader framework to protect survivors of human trafficking. I don’t mind seeing Bill 41 repealed, almost, if what replaces it is stronger and actually works. That was always the objective: not ownership over a piece of legislation, but helping survivors rebuild their lives. But after three years of waiting for implementation, I will be watching very closely. A right that exists only on paper is not much of a right. The organizations responsible for delivering this program must be properly funded, the process must be accessible everywhere in Ontario and in French, the regulation must be completed without further delay, and survivors must know where to turn for help. Passing Bill 119 should therefore not be the end of this work; it must finally be the beginning of delivering the protection we promised survivors two years ago. Let me now briefly turn to the measures to improve victims’ rights. Schedule 4 proposes to improve the recognition and enforcement of restraining orders issued in other Canadian jurisdictions. I agree with this. I mean, who wouldn’t? People fleeing violence should not lose their protection simply because they cross a provincial boundary. For someone escaping an abusive relationship, delays and legal complication can create very real safety risks. I also welcome the intention to provide additional civil remedies for victims of harassment in schedule 16, but we must recognize that having a legal remedy on paper is different from being able to exercise it. Civil litigation can be expensive, time-consuming and emotionally exhausting. What does a new legal remedy mean to someone who cannot afford a lawyer? What does it mean to someone who fears retaliation or lacks the resources to pursue a claim? And what does it mean if obtaining a judgment does not result in meaningful compensation? The government must ensure that victims have access to legal information, legal assistance and appropriate support services. Otherwise, we risk creating rights that are more accessible to people with financial resources than to those who are more vulnerable. Justice should not depend on a person’s ability to pay. I’m going to turn now to another subject in this bill that raised some concerns, which is schedule 3. It relates to the government’s proposed expansion of ministerial authority over police service boards. We’ve seen a pattern with this government. We see that, when they’re faced with complex problems, its response is often to concentrate more decision-making authority here at Queen’s Park. We’ve seen this in education, and now we are seeing it in police governance. At committee, the Solicitor General defended provisions that would allow him to direct police service boards to incorporate provincial priorities into their strategic plans. He argued that some boards had failed to align their priorities with those of the government but did not identify specific boards when he was asked. Speaker, the role of police service boards, composed of civilians, is to ensure that adequate and effective policing is provided in the area for which it has policing responsibility. Communities across Ontario do not all face the same public safety challenges. All of our communities are different. The priorities in downtown Ottawa may be different from those in a small northern community or a rapidly growing suburban municipality. Of course, there is a legitimate role for provincial standards and coordination, but there must also be room for local decision-making. The Ontario Human Rights Commission has raised concerns about the human rights implication of these changes, particularly in the context of systemic racial discrimination in policing. Speaker, let me give you a concrete example from my own riding of Ottawa–Vanier. In the ByWard Market and Lowertown, public safety is a serious concern. Residents and businesses want action against drug trafficking, violence and criminal activity, and they are right to expect it. But we also know that many of the situations police encounter involve people struggling with homelessness, addictions or mental health challenges—I feel like I speak a lot about this in this House, but it is a reality, and a reality that needs to be addressed. Our local police services boards must be able to consider these realities when establishing policing priorities, including community policing, partnerships with social services and measures to prevent discriminatory enforcement. Our police service in Ottawa is doing a great job. Now imagine a provincial government stepping in and overwriting those locally developed priorities or replacing board members because their approach does not align with the government’s preferred strategy. Who would be accountable to the residents of Lowertown? Who would ensure that the concerns of racialized communities, Indigenous residents and vulnerable populations are heard? This is precisely why civilian oversight matters. Speaker, I know I won’t have time to get through all my notes, so maybe I’m going to turn to another subject, about public safety, which is a fundamental responsibility of government. But I want to say that protecting communities also means protecting the rights and freedoms that define our justice system. During committee consideration of Bill 119, concerns were raised about the proposed public disclosure of information concerning high-risk offenders. I understand why communities want timely information about individuals who may present a serious risk, but Ontario’s Information and Privacy Commissioner raised legitimate concerns about the information that could be published, how long it would remain available and the possibility of inadvertently exposing victims and their family. The Criminal Lawyers’ Association also raised concerns about disproportionate consequences for Black and Indigenous communities. These are not arguments against public safety; these are arguments for getting the legislation right. We must ensure that information is accurate, that disclosure is necessary and proportionate, and that appropriate review and correction mechanisms exist. Speaker, what concerns me most about Bill 119 is not that every provision is misguided—some are constructive and long overdue. My concern is the government’s approach to justice reform. It introduces broad legislation, announces new powers and presents these measures as evidence of progress. My experience with Bill 41 has demonstrated why these questions matter. It is simply not enough to pass a law and assume that the problem has been solved. We have a responsibility to examine whether the law works in practice. We also have a—

Official source

5:50 p.m.Official Hansard

The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)

I’m sorry to interrupt the member, but the time is now 6 o’clock. It’s time for private members’ public business.

Official source

Private Members’ Public Business

Ethnic Media and Community Media Appreciation Week Act, 2026 / Loi de 2026 sur la Semaine de reconnaissance des médias ethniques et communautairesBill 120

6:00 p.m.Official Hansard

Mr. Anand moved second reading of the following bill:

Official source

6:00 p.m.Official Hansard

Bill 120, An Act to proclaim Ethnic Media and Community Media Appreciation Week / Projet de loi 120, Loi proclamant la Semaine de reconnaissance des médias ethniques et communautaires.

Official source