The House met at 0900.
Legislative Assembly of Ontario · House
Wednesday, November 4, 2026
The official record of the sitting, from Hansard, by section and topic. Passages link to the Assembly’s video of Members’ Statements and Question Period where it is posted.
Prayers.
Orders of the Day
Plan to Protect Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2026 (No. 2) / Loi de 2026 sur le plan pour protéger l’Ontario (mesures budgétaires) (no 2)Bill 143
Resuming the debate adjourned on November 3, 2026, on the motion for second reading of the following bill:
Bill 143, An Act to implement Budget measures and to enact and amend various statutes / Projet de loi 143, Loi visant à mettre en oeuvre les mesures budgétaires et à édicter et à modifier diverses lois.
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
Further debate? I recognize the member for Scarborough–Guildwood.
MPP Andrea Hazell
Good morning, everyone. It’s a beautiful day. Speaker, I rise today to continue my debate from yesterday on Bill 143, the Plan to Protect Ontario Act. Speaker, this year’s fall economic statement reveals that planned health care spending is $500 million lower than what was projected in the spring budget. This government decided to cut more than 1,900 registered nurses’ positions across Ontario. It means 1,900 fewer positions to support overwhelmed hospital staff and even greater pressure on an already strained health care system. Patients are now paying the price for these cuts, Speaker. Last year, 10,000—listen to this number: over 10,000. Let me be specific: 10,634 patients died waiting for surgery or diagnostic scans. These are real families that are being impacted. Hospitals are still seeing over 2,000 patients that are being treated in hallways and other unconventional spaces in Ontario in 2026. Speaker, this sounds like a Third World experience. For our young people, average wait times for intensive and youth mental health treatment have increased from 94 days to 105 days. That is more than three months for a child in crisis. This is really shameful on this government. The Canadian Mental Health Association and Addictions and Mental Health Ontario have already sounded the alarm over a substantial funding gap in the spring budget, but this government continues to do what it does best, which is to not listen to the people that voted us in into this chamber. This government’s fall economic statement shows planned health care spending is $500 million lower than the spring budget. Speaker, when mental health services are already underfunded and children are waiting more than three months for intensive treatment, how can this government justify planning to spend even less on health care? This government can find $117 million to spend on ads to advertise themselves, but not one new dollar for children’s mental health. And it gets worse. A survey of Ontario students in grades 7 to 12 has revealed some alarming statistics. I want to put this on the record: One in six students reported serious thoughts of suicide; 4% reported attempting suicide; 15% reported intentionally harming themselves. These are not just statistics; these are our children. These are young lives at risk, crying out for help. Our children should not have to reach a breaking point before they receive the help that they need. Their mental health cannot continue to be overlooked. This government must make children’s mental health a priority because our children deserve more than promises by this government—for eight years, the same promises that are not being kept. They deserve action. Let’s look at education, Speaker. In this year’s fall economic statement, it shows that planned education spending is $600 million lower than in the spring budget. So really and truly, nothing in this fall budget is new. Nothing at all is new for the families in Ontario that are going through this horrible affordability crisis. Speaker, our schools are already struggling with overcrowded classrooms, staff shortages and a growing backlog of repairs. The FAO estimates that Ontario’s schools already face a $6.5-billion infrastructure repair backlog, with almost 2,000 schools falling below a state of good repair. If this government continues to underfund our publicly funded education system, which it is doing right now, the backlog is projected to balloon to $22.1 billion over 10 years. Speaker, in my riding of Scarborough–Guildwood, I have constituents calling in to my office to speak with me because they’re complaining that the school sizes have gone from between 35 to 40. Speaker, how can one teacher possibly give 30 to 40 children the individual attention that they need to learn and succeed? I don’t know how. How can one teacher manage that amount of students, each with different learning abilities, needs and challenges? And how can this government talk about investing in our children’s future when our classrooms do not have the resources to support them? Under this government’s watch, the TDSB projected cuts to 289 teaching positions, including 145 elementary teaching positions in model schools. Shame on this government. Our children are being asked to learn in overcrowded classrooms, our teachers are being asked to do more with less and our schools are being left to deteriorate. Speaker, how can this government claim to be building a stronger Ontario when it is failing to invest in the very children who will build Ontario’s future? Ontario is facing an affordability crisis with a high unemployment rate at 7%, and youth unemployment rate at 15%. But I want to share with you a new report from the Daily Bread Food Bank with alarming stats, and I want this to be on the record. Children account for 25% of Daily Bread’s client base despite only representing 18% of Toronto’s population. Food bank clients are left with a median of only $8.33 per person per day after paying for housing. That’s barely enough for one round-trip TTC fare or a single load of laundry. Speaker, are we aware of how many families are struggling under these eight years of this government being in power? And each year, our young people, our families, our seniors—their opportunities are just decreasing year over year. It continues. One in four clients spends their entire income on rent, leaving nothing for food or essentials, and 82% of clients live in unaffordable housing—82%. Some 59% of clients missed a rent, credit card or loan payment in the past month. One in eight Toronto children lives in a household relying on food banks. Thank God for the food banks. There were 4.1 million food bank visits for the second consecutive year, a staggering 333%—I’m going to repeat this again: Since this government came into power in 2018, from 2019 there’s a record 333% increase in food bank visits. Some 67% of parents using food banks have sacrificed their own food so their children could eat. The case I’m trying to make here is that the Daily Bread Food Bank has done their survey and come out with their stats. We’ve got a fall economic statement from this government telling us what they’re doing, but the results are not showing. Results matter, Speaker—results matter. I also want to put this on the record: In Scarborough, 46% of food bank users would go to bed hungry if it wasn’t for the food banks. In my riding of Scarborough–Guildwood, 34% of children—more than one in three—live in poverty. In Toronto, there are—
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
I’m sorry to interrupt the member, but pursuant to standing order 50(c), I am now required to interrupt proceedings and announce that there have been six and a half hours of debate on the motion for second reading of this bill. This debate will therefore be deemed adjourned unless the government House leader directs debate to continue.
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
I turn back to the member from Scarborough–Guildwood.
MPP Andrea Hazell
Thank you very much, House leader. Speaker, I believe that no child should go to school hungry, no parent should have to choose between paying rent and feeding their children and buying medication, and no family should have to sleep in their car because they’ve just lost their jobs and they cannot afford to pay their rent. The government has mismanaged another file and froze OSAP from private career colleges. I have received hundreds of emails in my inbox from parents that have lost their jobs, and they want to go back to school to upskill or reskill and to get back into the job market so that they can now provide for their families, so they can buy food and they can pay rent. But the sad part of this is, on this side of the House, we kept hearing the government saying, “Four years, four years, four years.” I am assuming that you’ve had four years to deal with the situation and refused to do anything about it. Speaker, when a budget is presented in this House, when a budget is presented to the people in Ontario, it’s about choices. This government chose the luxury spa over the hospital bed. It chose the private jet over the classroom. It chose $117 million in self-advertisements while students are struggling to access their OSAP and families are lining up at the food bank. This fall economic statement shows a government spending a record $247.3 billion, running a deficit of about $17 billion, and now paying $47 million every day in interest alone. I’ve got to ask: If we are in a deficit of $17 billion, why aren’t we seeing the results? Why do the people in Ontario, the families, continue to suffer, the students continue to be punished, the seniors continue to be punished on a fixed income? Young people cannot even graduate from school—well, now education is gone from them. Now they are going into the workforce because they cannot afford to pay tuition, and so they can’t find jobs. What are we really doing to our young people in Ontario? Speaker, the people of Scarborough–Guildwood and the people of Ontario are not asking for luxury. They are asking for a family doctor, a classroom with enough support, an education they can afford, a job that pays the bills and a safe place to call home. They are asking for a government that can give them an equal opportunity to thrive in Ontario, a government that invests in its people, not in itself.
Ms. Aislinn Clancy
I just want to ask: Who do you think is benefiting most from this budget? We see a lot of big slush funds with no strings attached and very limited transparency on how these decisions are made about who gets what money and for what. What do you think will happen with these big multi-billion-dollar slush funds?
MPP Andrea Hazell
Thank you to my colleague for that question. And for me, when I review this fall economic statement, one thing that keeps popping out at me: The rich are going to get richer while the families and the young people in Ontario suffer. I want to go back to all the high-priority transit projects. All those projects are delayed and overrun on budget. We don’t know who’s benefiting from that. We do not know who’s benefiting from all these high-priority projects and the overrun dollars being spent. And do you know who is suffering? The taxpayers’ dollars are paying for the wealthy. Thank you for that question.
Mr. John Jordan
To the member opposite: Back in 2018, our health care budget was—well, I should say your health care budget was $62 billion. It’s now over $100 billion. One of the success stories within that is the primary care action plan and increasing access to primary care. So 511,000 people have been attached to primary care because of those investments, and those investments will continue as a result of this budget. So my question is, are you going to support the expansion of primary care in Ontario by supporting this budget?
MPP Andrea Hazell
To the member, that’s a great question, and I really welcome that question. Primary care—you’ve really brought in that a bit too late, okay? I welcome the investment and I welcome what you’re trying to do, but I can’t go to the hospitals in Ontario and in Scarborough and up north and talk to the people who are actually waiting for diagnostic results. They’re dying. That’s one chair less of someone being at the table with their families. And so while I welcome that, you’ve got so much work to do, and I think you’re being behind time. There are over three million people without a family doctor. Our population is growing, so please help me to understand: When are we going to fix the problem? Because you had eight years to fix the problem.
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
I recognize the member for Hamilton West–Ancaster–Dundas.
Ms. Sandy Shaw
This government’s current debt is stupefying. It’s $500 billion. It’s a number you can’t even get your head around, so I looked it up. If this was in seconds, 500 billion seconds is about 15,850 years. It’s longer than recorded civilization. It’s completely jaw-dropping. During that time, let’s be clear, these are taxpayer dollars that this government is spending. And the choices that they continue to make are to vote down our motion to support students, to vote down our motion to take the tax off groceries and to continue to underfund our hospitals, to underfund all the things that people think that their tax dollars should be going toward supporting. My question to the member is: These choices are deeply hurting people in Ontario and the debt and the deficit is staggering. Why do you think the government is making this choice today?
MPP Andrea Hazell
Thank you for that question. I appreciate that. It’s really difficult for me to stand here and try to start this question of where I think this government is going wrong, because this government continues to mismanage all the files, all the services to help give opportunities to all the families and the young people and the seniors in Ontario. Unemployment alone for the people is over 700,000; young people, it’s over 15%. As I said before, in this fall economic statement the rich are getting richer, the poor are getting poorer—
Mr. Stephen Blais
Thank you for your eloquent remarks this morning. As we know, the government is running the largest deficit in 20 years. Unemployment and youth unemployment is extraordinarily high and, as you articulated in your remarks, food bank usage is through the roof and families are suffering. I might note, Mr. Speaker, the last time that the deficit was this high, Conservatives in Ontario actually fought against saving the auto industry, calling it “corporate welfare.” And while they were not able or willing to support auto workers during the great recession of 2008-09, they’re demonstrating the same thing now, not able to support families through this affordability crisis. My question to my colleague is: What kinds of measures do you think the government should be undertaking to help the families of Scarborough get through this affordability crisis?
MPP Andrea Hazell
I want to take this question as two-prong. I want to talk about the businesses first. During the summer, I spoke to, I would say, over 60 manufacturing SME businesses—that’s the small and medium enterprises—in Scarborough and they are crying out for help. They’ve got over 10,000 employees. One business has about 1,500 employees, all employing Scarborough families. They do not know how long they can keep their lights on. They are talking about the high rent that they’re paying. They are talking about the taxes that they need to see decrease. They are talking about tariff supports; they’re not seeing that. The process that is laid out for them is not properly laid out for—
Mr. Andrew Dowie
I want to thank the member from Scarborough–Guildwood for her comments. I know one thing that has been of importance to us on this side has been the increasing disability supports since 2022. We know that people who rely on disability assistance need the support, that response to the rising cost of essentials. We increased the ODSP rates from more than 22% since September 2022. It certainly dwarfs the past number of years prior and tied future increases to inflation. So my question to the member is whether she’ll commit to maintaining those annual adjustments. I’m wondering if she may also be able to explain additional changes that the third party would make in how to fund them.
MPP Andrea Hazell
To the member across the floor: Thank you for your question. I’m looking at Scarborough and I’m looking at seniors. I’m looking at people with disabilities that are accessing these services. They are crying out that the financial support that they are getting from the government is not even helping them to buy groceries after they’ve paid their rent. That’s the financial pressure that I’m hearing from families in Scarborough that are using the services that the member across is speaking about. I spoke to two families in Scarborough; the moms had to quit their jobs to now take care of their family members, because they’re not getting the support from this government.
MPP Alexa Gilmour
I want to thank my colleague for her debate. Speaker, families across Ontario are being told that children need mental health support, and yet 28,000 of them remain on a wait-list, some waiting up to two and a half years for care. As a church minister, one of the darkest days I ever had was a funeral for someone who was waiting for care as a young person and died of depression. So to the colleague across the way: When we talk about the funding, the small bit of investment, and then we see the hundreds of millions going out into advertising how great this government is, and yet they are letting children die of depression, I wonder what my colleague would say about the way we should invest in youth mental health.
MPP Andrea Hazell
Thank you for that question. Let me make it clear: This government is investing in all the wrong priorities in Ontario and talking about building a tunnel under the 401. I didn’t even have that in my debate speech because there is so much more I could add in this debate speech—so many materials. You can stand here for two hours and talk about the horrible priorities that this government is—
Ms. Aislinn Clancy
It’s an honour to rise and represent the people of Kitchener Centre today. I do want to thank the government; we do see an investment in primary care, we see new schools and cuts to fees to build new homes. So there are some good bits in this budget, but it misses the mark in serving the vast majority of Ontarians. When I go door to door, I tell folks every day that I will hustle in this place to make sure that everybody in Ontario has access to a roof and food. I know that the member from Cambridge and I bond often about the needs in our community—the growing number of people who find themselves homeless and are in downtowns, living in tents—and this is not acceptable in the province of Ontario, where there is affluence. There is enough to go around and we have to make sure that everyone has access to these things. When I look at this budget, I see the markings of a silver-spoon Premier, someone who has an us-and-them approach to funding. That’s why the homelessness crisis continues on, with 85,000 people homeless, and that’s set to rise to 300,000. Stats show that the number one reason why people end up homeless is eviction. One thing this government has done more than anything else is made sure more people are evicted, made it easier for folks to get evicted and provided no alternatives on where they can live. Yet they’re willing to spend $4 billion on jails. This is their solution to mental health and addiction. This is their solution to homelessness, is to build more jail beds. But we know that when folks get out of jail—guess what? They’re more likely to be homeless than before. Instead, there’s $53 million for supportive housing, which—guess what?—is one sixth of the amount that we’re spending on a parking garage for a spa that is owned by a private foreign company in downtown Toronto. There’s always money for slush funds. There’s always money for vanity projects in Toronto. There is nothing—if anything, scraps—for folks who find themselves struggling with mental health and addiction and homelessness. And seniors as well: Those in the Waterloo region saw the number of seniors who are homeless double in one year in our area. And why is that? We see legislated poverty. Ontario Works has not gone up; it is frozen. If you measure for inflation, it has gone from almost $12,000 to almost $8,000 under this government’s watch. How can anybody survive a whole year on $8,000? There’s about $380 per month for housing allowance. Tell me which riding in Ontario anyone could even rent a room for $380 a month? And that’s why 20,000 people on Ontario Works and ODSP have no fixed address. There is nowhere to go, and that is our responsibility. I am tired of looking at folks in my office and talking to them and wiping their tears because they have developmental disabilities and they can’t afford to eat. That is a moral injury to me and to everybody in this province. It’s unacceptable. We need to give the Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services more money because the cost of living has gone up and the cost of poverty has gone up. It costs us more to stand by and watch while people starve in our streets, and it’s unacceptable. It is a moral injury to all of us. In our schools, we see crowded classrooms. We see a lack of and burnout of support staff, but there’s not enough money for sick days. I heard that the Peel board saves $1 million a month because they do not replace EAs and ECEs when they call in sick. And those kids who need an EA—guess what? They don’t get to go to school that day. It is time that we make sure that the funding for special ed matches the demand. We are seeing an increasing need in our schools because of the impact of the Internet. What has this government done to address the impact of the Internet in Ontario? Nothing. We see countries across the world setting legislation, putting protections in place, holding big tech accountable for the horrible impacts they’ve had on our society, and we laugh at Toronto school boards when they take these companies to court. It is not a laughing matter. This government ought to do better. There are serious needs in our school, in our kids, in their development, and it’s time that we start to pay the support staff that are dealing with this and have a plan to address the impact of screens from birth to death. We don’t even pay enough for CPP. Schools have to literally do bake sales to pay for CPP—pay your bills. It’s like saving money when you go out for dinner with a friend by passing the bill to the friend sitting next to you. We’re forced to make difficult choices in education, but there is a slush fund, there’s a 3P that makes every project, whether it’s hospital or transit or other things—nuclear—go over budget again and again and again. Nuclear is the most expensive energy in the world. These SMRs, they’re an American plan. They use American-enriched uranium. This is the plan we have? What about buy Ontario? Why are we not investing in renewables and batteries, which are the cheapest form of energy? It means buying a home instead of renting. IESO just bought fuel from America—just bought fuel. What happened to buy Ontario? We could generate our own energy if we invested in clean, renewable technology. Let’s expand batteries. Let’s use our steel locally and make sure that we can create our own energy right now, not in 10 years, because we are going to keep burning Ontario, not protecting it. You want to blame the poor for the problems in our communities. You want to blame kids and teachers and education staff workers, but I hold you accountable for this travesty because there’s always a slush fund and there’s never enough for everybody else. That’s why we see crowded classrooms and crowded—
Mr. Andrew Dowie
I want to thank the member from Kitchener Centre. I really want to applaud the local focus. I know one thing that the region of Waterloo, and Kitchener particularly, is great at is research and innovation. Businesses need to invest in research—and we see that; I’m a BlackBerry fan forever—equipment and new technologies to remain competitive. The proposed changes in the fall economic statement are to Ontario’s research and development tax, through credits, to provide more than $50 million in additional support over three years to approximately 700 businesses. I’m hoping the member for Kitchener Centre can indicate whether she supports these specific changes to encourage innovation and to help companies develop new products right here in Ontario, and particularly in Waterloo region.
Ms. Aislinn Clancy
Thank you to the honourable member from Windsor–Tecumseh. Yes, we are good at doing the economic development, trying to fund companies. We are good at investing in innovation and incubator space. Do you know what we’re not good at? Buying our own products. Every health care innovation product we create, almost 95% of their sales in my community are abroad. And now they’re going to leave because of tariffs, because our health care system, our hospitals, do not buy our own technology. Talk to your Minister of Health and tell her to fix the OHIP system, fix the funding for hospitals so they can actually innovate. These innovations save our care systems money so they’re not just pissing money away; they’re actually making it cheaper and more effective to provide health care. But you don’t buy from our own companies, and that is a disgrace. Instead, Staples gets money—
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
I will go to further questions, but before I do, I will caution the member on her parliamentary language. I recognize the member for Toronto–Danforth.
Mr. Peter Tabuns
Speaker, I appreciate the comments that were made by the member from Kitchener Centre. Clearly, she’s had an opportunity to review the bill and the fall economic statement itself. As she is well aware, climate change is a huge threat to the future of this province. Could you detect anything in this bill that will actually take on the climate crisis?
Ms. Aislinn Clancy
I think this is the reason I’m here: because I see a train barrelling quickly into a wall with a driver putting on the gas. We can’t even say the words “climate change.” Do you know what they say if you’re talking to folks who are trying to predict what the economy of the future will be? The economy of the future will be fresh water. If anything, we’re just polluting the water. We’re polluting the air. We talk about investing in fire, but it comes at the very last minute. That’s not good planning. I know that there’s been an investment recently in flood mitigation, but when I talk to the folks in Bracebridge, they talk about how that Building Faster Fund, that extra 15%, saved them from the disastrous effects of flooding this year. But that money is gone, so St. Catharines doesn’t get the Building Faster Fund. We don’t build back better. because we’re not—
MPP Stephanie Smyth
Thanks to my colleague from Kitchener Centre. You want to be positive, but every time you sit here, you hear another negative story from my colleague from Scarborough–Guildwood, about poverty and children going hungry in Scarborough. We’re hearing in my own riding about seniors in NORCs being deathly afraid of being evicted because of the affordability issues. We’re hearing this morning—just this morning—how we have the Association of Early Childhood Educators here in Queen’s Park advocating for better care in the media studio, talking about provincial funding guidelines that are flatlining the pay for ECE workers, the lowest-paid and perhaps some of the most important workers in this province. I want to ask the member: You just referred to a silver-spoon Premier. I couldn’t agree with you more. What’s it going to take for this government to see that things aren’t working? There is a huge example just south of the border that people are catching on.
Ms. Aislinn Clancy
I see a lack of accountability, and I think it’s going to take all the people of this province to rise up and demand better. We saw the former Minister of Tourism get a pay bump after egregious behaviour, yet our ECEs aren’t good enough for $1 an hour. Folks who are taking care of the next generation don’t have enough to pay for a roof and food, and that is a mandated situation, because they don’t get a living wage across Ontario. It shows a lack of respect for the cost of living, and we’ve only seen the cost of living go up under this government’s watch. We see subsidies—Galen Weston gets his energy subsidized; Drake gets his energy subsidized—yet we can’t afford $1 an hour for ECEs. That is a travesty, and we need to be more fiscally prudent and stop giving dole-outs to the mega-rich.
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
It is an honour to rise here today in this chamber to speak to Bill 143, the Plan to Protect Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2026. Firstly, I would like to thank the people of Newmarket–Aurora who elected me to be their representative and have their voice here at Queen’s Park. My goal is to ensure that I reflect their voice in my comments today. What a different world we are living in. It was just under two years ago when we initially launched our plan to protect Ontario workers, given the challenges we were encountering with our friends to the south—and I would like to reiterate: our friends to the south. I do not believe we, or anyone, could have predicted the roller coaster upon which we were embarking: turbulent times for businesses, for workers, for the entire economy. Why? Due to the initial threats of tariffs made by the US, followed by actual tariffs, which seemed to constantly fluctuate depending on the flavour of the day. But Ontario committed to protecting our workers while investing in strengthening our industrial base and growing the economy. And, Speaker, the plan is working. Yes, it is working by investing to fortify specific tariff-impacted industries while improving Ontario’s competitiveness so that we can attract good-paying jobs. This is in strategic sectors, including advanced manufacturing, critical minerals mining and refining, artificial intelligence, defence and more. Nous avons su répondre aux défis actuels tout en faisant preuve d’une gestion budgétaire responsable. Nous traçons une trajectoire vers l’équilibre à l’horizon 2029 à 2030 tout en conservant la discipline nécessaire pour disposer de la marge de manoeuvre financière requise pour réagir. And respond we have indeed. From the $30 billion in tariff relief we made available to our continued pursuit of new opportunities through our international sales missions, we are using every tool at our disposal to protect Ontario workers and bring home new job-creating investments. As recently as September 8, just less than two months ago, Canada’s counter-tariffs on $28 million worth of goods took effect. And yes, President Trump continued his complaints and his threats. Ontario has a well-rounded, diversified economy, and we are taking every action to diversify our trade, create the conditions for companies to succeed, and build on the $235 billion in investment that we have attracted since taking office. From our Ontario Made Manufacturing Investment Tax Credit to the Trade-Impacted Communities Program to the Ontario Together Trade Fund, these programs are providing the support needed to weather the Trump tariff storm. Let me give you some examples, Mr. Speaker, of what these programs have done. The Ontario Together Trade Fund has seen 90 companies invest nearly $1 billion, creating and protecting 10,000 jobs. In my riding of Newmarket–Aurora, I was thrilled to make that call to Tony Denham, President of Bramden Precision Ltd.—this was back in January—to advise him that his application to the OTTF grant was approved. Bramden offers complete turnkey manufacturing of complex CNC-machined components and associate assemblies to the aerospace and defence sectors. Only one year prior to that phone call, when I met with Tony, he advised me that the tariffs that President Trump was threatening would shut down his business within 12 months. This was not a good situation in my riding. Thanks to this grant of $263,250 and Bramden’s investment of a total of $1.3 million, Bramden was able to move forward with a project that allowed them to add a production cell to accommodate a new Ontario-based customer. They invested in advanced manufacturing technologies to enhance their competitiveness to develop a new market within Ontario while meeting customers’ domestic content demand. With this investment, Bramden was able to retain 14 good-paying, local jobs in my community, and they created eight new jobs. This is a true win for my community. Exco Engineering, another Newmarket-based leading tool and die manufacturer, and one of the only North American firms capable of designing and building large, high-pressure die casting tooling for the automotive components—another business who knew the threats of tariffs would have grave impacts on their business, consequently jobs. How humbling it was to call the CEO to advise them that their OTTF application was approved for $1.7 million, and this allowed for their project entitled bringing tooling home—establishing Ontario’s capacity to improve and replace offshore supply chains. This is precisely why our government invested in the OTTF program, so companies like Exco Engineering could adopt new capabilities that would allow them to reshore advanced tool and die production from China to address three urgent risks: firstly, rising threats of the US tariffs on automotive tooling; secondly, costly and unpredictable international shipping; and thirdly, the loss of control over proprietary designs. This project enabled Exco to pivot into tariff-free nuclear and advanced manufacturing markets in both Canada and the US. What an amazing morning. Employees were all gathered in the plant. The Exco CEO and I were able to celebrate Exco’s major $4,252,000 investment with our government’s support of $1.7 million through this Ontario Together Trade Fund. It is this type of project that strengthens Ontario’s supply chain resilience. It grows our advanced manufacturing capacity, and it ensures that we stay competitive in a rapidly changing global economy. And, importantly, this investment protects 140 existing jobs, and it created four new good-paying positions for the people of Newmarket–Aurora. With investments like these, we are reshoring critical supply chains, finding new export markets and helping companies hire new workers. We understand that different sectors need different supports. That is why our fall economic statement puts such a strong emphasis on fortifying Ontario’s industrial base. Il y a tout juste deux semaines maintenant, nous nous sommes tenus aux côtés du gouvernement fédéral pour annoncer notre plan d’action doté de 8,7 milliards de dollars. Just two weeks ago, we stood alongside the federal government to announce an $8.7-billion action plan. Dans le cadre de ce plan, nous avons engagé plus de 5 milliards de dollars pour soutenir notre secteur sidérurgique par l’entremise du Fonds d’action conjoint pour l’acier. In this plan, we pledged more than $5 billion in support for our steel sector through the Joint Steel Action Fund. This will help steelmakers diversify production and support growing industries like defence and energy while opening up new markets. We are also leveraging our buy-Ontario policy to prioritize the use of Ontario-made steel in public procurement, strengthening domestic demand. At the same time, we are working with steelmakers like Tenaris and Algoma to build the products that the Ontario and Canadian market needs. In Sault Ste. Marie, Tenaris, a steel pipe maker, invested $300 million in its operations, creating 200 new jobs and helping them reduce their reliance on the US market. Just down the road from there, we continue to work with Algoma on a plan to build I-beams for infrastructure and plate steel for the defence sector. These projects are critical not only to our industrial strategy but to our national security, helping us be less reliant on foreign actors to build what we need right here in Ontario. Another sector I would like to highlight is health care. This falls under our build Ontario for growth plan. Firstly, our plan to connect everyone in Ontario to primary care by 2029 through the primary care action plan is supported by a $3.4-billion investment over four years. This includes creating and expanding more than 300 primary care teams to connect approximately two million people to primary care. I do not have to look far to see the success, because it’s right in my riding of Newmarket–Aurora. With more than $2.8 million invested in two new primary care teams, we are attaching 6,500 residents to primary care providers. I was excited to hear directly from Dr. Makary. Dr. Makary is with the Southlake Academic Family Health Team. Just three weeks ago, we talked. Dr. Makary advised me that they have achieved their patient target. This is an important and meaningful achievement, and it shows the care, the commitment and the collaboration that this team brings to our community every single day. The impact of their work is felt not only in the numbers, but in the improved health and well-being of the patients and families that they serve. A big shout-out to the Southlake Academic Family Health Team. Thank you for what you do. Another critical investment is the $64 billion in health infrastructure over the next decade, including nearly $50 billion in capital grants to support more than 50 hospital projects. And in my riding of Newmarket–Aurora, we had the great opportunity to announce the new location of the acute care hospital, just a 15-minute drive north. This announcement included a $10-million planning grant for the next phase of this massive project, which also includes the renovation of the Davis Drive campus. My constituents, along with those in the entire catchment area, including in my neighbouring York–Simcoe riding, are the direct beneficiaries of this exciting project. Just yesterday morning, I had the opportunity to attend the UHN as they updated their progress on their surgical tower project at the UHN Toronto Western Hospital. It is a 15-storey surgical tower. It’s the largest project and the first of its kind in Canada, and I should mention that UHN is the number one hospital in Canada, and I should also mention that it’s number two in the world. I mention this project because it is a $1.1-billion total cost for a 380,000-square-foot new clinical space. Our government, under the leadership of Premier Ford and the Minister of Health, has committed $800 million for this project. The work this hospital performs every day is nothing but outstanding, from lung transplants to brain-computer interface implants—imagine that. They are revolutionizing surgeries for the next 100 years using robotics, AI innovations and real-time intelligence. Their team are the experts; they make the magic happen for people. Our government is supporting these amazing health care wizards to ensure that they have the infrastructure where they can perform this high-quality care for Ontarians close to home. Speaker, I’m not even halfway through my speech here. I’m going to have to move it on up a bit here. Un autre volet essentiel du plan pour protéger l’Ontario, bâtir l’Ontario pour la croissance, consiste à alléger le fardeau financier des familles et des particuliers, grâce à plus de 12,5 milliards de dollars de mesures de soutien en 2026-2027. Cela comprend des investissements dans le logement, l’éducation, les transports en commun et les infrastructures de transport, l’accessibilité financière à l’énergie, les services de garde d’enfants et les prestations familiales, ainsi que des mesures de soutien destinées aux populations vulnérables. Well, Speaker, I’m going to fast-forward to some other sections. Another action I’m extremely proud about is, under the leadership of Premier Ford and the Minister of Finance, our government has never raised a tax. Think about that—never raising a tax. You don’t hear that too often. By respecting the taxpayer dollars through responsible fiscal management and continuously looking at how to improve government efficiency, strengthen oversight and reduce administrative burden, this is how a government can set the stage for businesses to come to this province and invest—invest in their businesses and invest in a highly skilled workforce. Through this fall economic statement, we are planning more than $8 billion in additional tax relief over five years to help businesses write off qualifying capital investments sooner.
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
Combined with accelerated write-off measures announced earlier this year, that is more than $12 billion in Ontario capital investment tax relief over five years. This means more room for businesses to buy equipment, modernize their operations, expand production and hire workers—to grow their business. This is what the government is doing: ensuring we set the conditions for businesses to grow their business here in this great province of Ontario. Lowering costs is only part of the plan. We must also compete for the industries and jobs of tomorrow. Ontario is already a leading destination for artificial intelligence, advanced manufacturing and other emerging technologies. Speaker, since I’m running tight on time, I’m going to go straight towards my end to conclude. We want to strengthen protections for Ontario’s data and ensure our province can benefit from investment in critical digital infrastructure—digital sovereignty. This is critical, because if we don’t build them here in Ontario, they will be built on foreign soil. We have been clear: Our data should be stored on our soil. Digital sovereignty is more important than ever. There is a common thread throughout this fall economic statement. Whether we are supporting tariff-impacted manufacturers, strengthening the steel and automotive supply chains, reducing the cost of investment, building health care infrastructure or preparing for new technologies, we are following one clear plan: Protect Ontario’s workers and businesses today while creating the conditions for jobs and opportunities tomorrow.
Ms. Fatima Shaban
Thank you to the member for Newmarket–Aurora for speaking about the budget and health care. The government frequently points to the nearly $100 billion being spent on health care, but Ontarians deserve to know not just how much is being spent, but how effectively that money is being used. Hospitals across Ontario have relied on expensive private staffing agencies to fill vacancies, with some agencies charging several times the hourly rate of directly employed nurses. My question to the member of Newmarket–Aurora is, why isn’t this government investing more effectively in recruiting and retaining permanent health care workers up front instead of leaving hospitals to pay a premium for private agency staff to fill the gaps? Wouldn’t it make more fiscal sense to invest in a stable health care workforce rather than continuing to pay higher costs to address staffing shortages after they occur?
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
Thank you to the member opposite—my first question from her—and welcome to the chamber. Your question—I think it’s interesting, because you may or may not be aware that our government has been investing significantly in the Learn and Stay program. That is specifically to ensure that we have more health care workers, specifically nurses, specifically PSWs. We are also investing in new medical schools. We talked the other day about TMU, also York University in York region—so important. There will be seats there for, specifically, primary care physicians. And I speak with my local hospital often, because they are going to be taking the residents of that hospital.
M. Stephen Blais
Merci pour votre présentation ce matin. Monsieur le Président, le gouvernement prévoit un déficit de 16,9 milliards de dollars, mais en même temps, il réduit les moyens des organismes français et francophones. Comment le gouvernement peut-il protéger nos communautés franco-ontariennes quand il coupe les services offerts aux organismes communautaires qui desservent la communauté franco-ontarienne?
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
Merci beaucoup, monsieur le député, pour la question. Je ne suis pas sûre de cette question parce que je sais bien que notre ministère des Affaires francophones vient d’annoncer plus d’argent pour la communauté francophone. Juste ce week-end passé, j’ai fait une annonce avec ma communauté francophone en région de York. On a annoncé des fonds pour la communauté, surtout pour les programmes d’âgées. Je sais bien que ce n’est pas juste la région de York. C’est d’autres régions aussi. Je sais bien qu’il y a des fonds pour Windsor et Ottawa aussi. Donc, j’entends la question; cependant je sais bien qu’il y a des fonds maintenant pour la région de York pour la francophonie.
Mr. Brian Riddell
My question is to the member from Newmarket. I was very intrigued by your statement today—the fact that the government has helped companies keep their employees going. I know in Cambridge, with nuclear technology—BWXT and Eclipse Automation—wonderful things are happening. I was just wondering if you could elaborate more on the companies you spoke about, and how they’re saving jobs in this crazy time we live in today.
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
To my colleague: Thank you very much for the question. I think it is a great question, and that’s why I used just two examples in my community. I will go back to some of the initial conversations I had with both those businesses—Bramden Precision and Exco Engineering—when Trump was first elected. Those conversations were like, “This is going to kill our businesses. What can we possibly do?” Businesses want to ensure their businesses can thrive and that their workers can thrive. That is why, as I noted, I am so happy our government came up with the Ontario Together Fund, because this has helped spur on—
Ms. Sandy Shaw
Speaker, there is nothing in this fall economic statement that will help steelworkers in Hamilton. The Conservative government must know that right now 500-plus steelworkers are being laid off in Hamilton. The steelworkers in Hamilton have an 80-year history, so Ontario-made steel is critical. It’s critical to our national sovereignty and to our industrial sovereignty. So far, this government has been missing in action when it comes to making sure that we don’t lose this important source of sovereignty in our province. Will this government be prepared to commit to some bold action to save those jobs, including public ownership of a sector that is so vital to our economy?
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
I thank the member from Hamilton West–Ancaster–Dundas. Our government understands the challenges that are facing workers, especially in Hamilton. Having grown up there, I recall many, many years, even when I was younger, when jobs were threatened. And this is really a time in our history that is unprecedented. But this is why Ontario and the federal government recently announced an $8.7-billion action plan, and that is specifically to strengthen our steel, our automotive and our critical mineral sectors. These investments are intended to support the industry modernization as well as strengthen domestic supply chains—
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
Thank you. I recognize the member from Toronto–St. Paul’s.
MPP Stephanie Smyth
To the member from Newmarket–Aurora: You said at the end of your speech that the common thread here is protecting Ontario workers, protecting jobs and the opportunities of tomorrow. But this clearly, Speaker, does not extend to early childhood educators in this province, who will not be getting a $1 increase in pay in 2027. This is already a profession that is often undervalued, under-recognized, disrespected. That $1 increase could have maybe given some hope for what the future would look like for ECEs, and without it, recruiting, retaining those workers who look after our children, our most precious resource—so I want to ask the member: Is this the one sector you just don’t seem to care about, early childhood educators—a dollar-a-year increase?
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
I appreciate the question from the member opposite. Look, this comes down to affordability, cost of living. We all know that that has been increasing. And these are some of the changes and things the government has done to help with these increasing costs, everything from looking at the gas tax, how we can reduce that gas tax and what we’ve done to make it permanent beyond what we said was a temporary fix. A lot of those caregivers have to get to their work by vehicle. This is helping them. We are looking at measures that will help reduce costs, put money back in people’s pockets. If they’re taking the transit, they would be saving with the One Fare program, Mr. Speaker.
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
For a quick question, I recognize the member from Lambton–Kent–Middlesex.
Mr. Steve Pinsonneault
Thank you, Speaker, and through you to the presenter: As a former small business owner—I know you’ve talked a little bit more about the big business. Small business is the backbone of our economy. We cut the corporate business tax by 37%, and it has saved $5,000 annually. You mentioned that we never raised a tax; we grow our GDP. Can you elaborate on the importance of small businesses and how we’re working to improve them?
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
Thank you to my colleague for the question. Small businesses are the backbone of our communities, and especially in my riding of Newmarket–Aurora, where more than 60% of the businesses are small business. I was a small business owner myself. Mr. Speaker, yes, the reduction—
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
Thank you very much. It is now time for further debate.
MPP Alexa Gilmour
Good morning. Thank you, Speaker. As always, it’s a privilege to rise in this House and be the voice of the good people of Parkdale–High Park. Today, I’m going to speak to the fiscal updates. But before I do, I want to recognize that we have a gallery full of educators and young people here today. Yesterday, I spoke about the cuts to them in a number of areas, and I just want to recognize that they are here and I’m grateful for them in the House today. Thank you. Speaker, I’m going to say something that might be a surprise. I’m going to say that this bill gives me hope. Yes, you have heard it right. I know it’s probably not what you expected. I’m sorry to my colleagues, but it is true. This bill gives me hope, and here is why this bill gives me hope: Maybe, just maybe, this fall economic statement will finally put to rest the myth that Conservative governments are prudent stewards of our provincial economy. Never has a government spent so much money and delivered so little for the people of Ontario. For months, we have had one story after another about taxpayers’ dollars wasted by this Conservative government on private jets, on five-star hotels, on sushi-rolling classes—$10,000 at Toronto’s premier tapas bar—that is a lot of tapas—and all the while doing insider deals, shelling out big bucks to lobbyists and developers. If you are thinking that that doesn’t sound very fiscally responsible, well, just take a look at the government’s report card in this fall economic statement. We have a ballooning deficit of $17 billion—yes, billion—up 3.1% from this year’s budget; interest and other debt-servicing charges that are rising faster than projected. And this is not the result of increased spending on public services, Speaker—no. Funding for Ontario’s public services remains frozen below inflation, with no increase to reflect the cost and pressures on families. That is already after massive cuts to education, to health care, to social services in this year’s budget and eight years of chronic underfunding by the Ford Conservative government. Ontarians are paying the price for this government’s fiscal mismanagement. Conservatives have had opportunity after opportunity for eight years to invest in our public health care system, to create good jobs and bring measures to make life more affordable. Instead, they have delivered backroom deals for wealthy insiders. Here is what everyday Ontarians are facing, while the ministers eat steak and lobster dinner on taxpayers’ dimes: Children are going hungry. One in eight children living in Toronto now rely on the food bank. That is up from one in 15 just a few short years ago. People are working multiple jobs and relying on food banks because the housing costs are so high and the incomes haven’t kept pace. After paying for housing, food bank clients have a median of $8 a day left for food and other essentials. One in four food bank clients are spending their entire income—can you imagine?—on housing, with nothing left for basic necessities. What good is a government if it is not looking after these individuals? Unemployment is soaring. There are 800,000 Ontarians currently out of work while these ministers eat steak and lobster dinners and live in five-star luxury hotels. One in two young people in our province are unemployed and looking for work. Two of them live in my basement. These are hundreds of thousands of Ontarians who are falling behind, and they are getting no help from this government. The Ontario NDP under Marit Stiles’s leadership has brought common-sense solutions, like stabilizing the rent, lowering the cost of groceries and creating good jobs for Ontarians, that the Conservative government has voted down over and over again. And then they have the gall to tell us with $100 million in advertising dollars—our taxpayers’ dollars—that they are providing relief for families and individuals. They have the gall to say that they are fiscally responsible. Spending money on advertising dollars does not make that so. And all the while, the deficit continues to grow, and the people of this province—with as much collective wealth as ours—are struggling to put food on their table. Many Ontarians are struggling to keep a roof over their heads. Conservative governments have given developers and big landlords everything they asked for, and yet it hasn’t worked. Housing starts have fallen every year in Ontario since 2022. Speaker, I am the official shadow minister for women’s social and economic opportunities. I would be remiss not to stand up for them because this government continues to invest in manufacturing and skilled trades—we need it. But it completely ignores health care, child care, education, community services—in other words, the care economy, which is the invisible foundation of our entire economy. It is the space largely dominated by women and gender-diverse people, and this government doesn’t seem to notice or care. This government’s refusal to invest in our social infrastructure weakens our province and it reflects deep fiscal irresponsibility—
The Deputy Speaker (Mr. Ric Bresee)
I’m sorry to interrupt, but the time is now for morning routine. It’s time for members’ statements.
Second reading debate deemed adjourned.
Members’ Statements
Municipal elections
Mr. John Jordan
It’s been almost two weeks, but I want to welcome all my colleagues back to Queen’s Park, especially the three new members, and I would like to congratulate the mayors and reeves that were elected and acclaimed in my riding in the recent municipal elections. Their willingness to serve and lead is vital to building strong, vibrant communities. There were six newly elected mayors and reeves among the 12 regions in my riding: Nicki Gowdy, mayor of Central Frontenac; Scott Cameron, reeve of Drummond/North Elmsley; Wesley Pugh, reeve of Lanark Highlands; Ed McPherson, mayor of Perth; Chris Cummings, mayor of Smiths Falls; and RoxAnne Darling, reeve of Tay Valley. I’d also like to congratulate the six returning municipal leaders: Richard Kidd, reeve of Beckwith township and warden of Lanark county; Toby Randell, mayor of Carleton Place; Christa Lowry, mayor of Mississippi Mills and Chair of ROMA; Karen Jennings, reeve of Montague township; Gerry Litchy, mayor of North Frontenac; and Ron Vandewal, mayor of South Frontenac. I look forward to working with all our elected mayors, reeves, deputies and councillors in the coming months and years on local constituent and stakeholder concerns and continued collaboration on improving and growing the communities that we mutually serve. Congratulations and best wishes to all our newly elected and returning municipal councillors.
Queensway Carleton Hospital
Ms. Chandra Pasma
This year, the Queensway Carleton Hospital celebrates its 50th anniversary. Since opening its doors on October 5, 1976, QCH has been the place our community has turned to for care, compassion and support. This milestone is about much more than a building. It is about the people who have made QCH what it is today: the physicians, nurses, health care workers, support staff and volunteers who have spent the past five decades caring for our families, friends and neighbours. It is about the stories of the thousands of patients and their families who found the help, the advice, the tests and the treatments that they needed, who welcomed new babies to the family and said goodbye to beloved family members within its walls. It’s about the innovations that have changed how care is provided, from the first locker for lady doctors to the opening of the Acute Care for the Elderly Unit to the newborn primary care pilot project. But as we celebrate this remarkable anniversary, we also have to acknowledge the challenges. The hospital was built to serve 100,000, and now it serves 500,000. Underfunding from the Conservative government has led to staffing cuts and patients being treated in the hallway. As QCH enters its next 50 years, I remain committed to fighting for the necessary funding to right-size the hospital, reverse the cuts to nurses and health care workers and end hallway medicine. Congratulations to the Queensway Carleton Hospital on 50 years of exceptional care, and thank you to everyone who contributed to this amazing legacy.
Ordre de Jacques-Cartier
Mme Lucille Collard
Il y a 100 ans, le 22 octobre 1926, dans le sous-sol du presbytère de l’église Saint-Charles-Borromée à Eastview, aujourd’hui Vanier, naissait une organisation qui allait profondément marquer l’histoire de la francophonie canadienne : l’Ordre de Jacques-Cartier, mieux connu sous le nom de « La Patente ». À une époque où les droits des francophones étaient constamment menacés, des hommes ont décidé de s’organiser pour défendre leur langue, leur culture et leurs intérêts. Pendant près de 40 ans, cette société secrète a exercé une influence considérable, favorisant notamment la présence des francophones dans la fonction publique. Bien que ses méthodes fondées sur le secret et l’influence puissent aujourd’hui susciter des questions, son rôle dans notre histoire demeure indéniable. Speaker, comme députée d’Ottawa–Vanier, je suis particulièrement fière que cette histoire ait pris naissance chez nous; 100 ans plus tard, nous pouvons mesurer le chemin parcouru tout en reconnaissant que la défense de nos droits linguistiques demeure un travail de chaque génération. Je tiens à saluer le Muséoparc Vanier, qui souligne ce centenaire par une exposition consacrée à cette page fascinante de notre histoire. L’histoire de « La Patente » nous rappelle que les droits dont nous jouissons aujourd’hui sont le fruit de la détermination de celles et ceux qui nous ont précédés. À nous maintenant de poursuivre leur oeuvre ouvertement, fièrement et collectivement.
Riding of Markham–Unionville
Mr. Billy Pang
Over the summer recess, I had the privilege of spending time across Markham–Unionville, connecting with the people I’m proud to represent. From cultural celebrations and community events to meetings with seniors, students, families, local businesses and community organizations, every conversation reminded me of what makes our riding so special. I was especially pleased to recognize the achievements of our young people, honour dedicated senior volunteers and celebrate residents who take pride in beautifying our neighbourhood through our annual landscaping awards. Above all, Speaker, these visits were about listening. Residents shared their experiences, ideas and concerns about health care, education affordability and community safety. Their perspectives helped me better understand local priorities and guide the work I do on their behalf. To every resident who took the time to speak with me, and to every volunteer and community organization working to make Markham–Unionville a better place: Thank you. As the fall session gets under way, I remain committed to bringing my constituents’ concerns to Queen’s Park and continuing to serve the people of Markham–Unionville wholeheartedly.
Caregivers
Mr. Tom Rakocevic
Right now, a mother has quit her job to take care of a child facing a chronic illness. A son has dropped his work hours to part-time to take care of his dying father. A wife is barely keeping afloat as she cares for her young children and now her husband, who is unable to work as he slowly recovers from a terrible accident. Parents are caring for a child with autism. Children are caring for parents with dementia. They are all caregivers, and the emotional, physical and financial costs of their efforts are back-breaking. Dollars are stretched thin. Many begin to struggle keeping a roof over their heads and to put food on their table. Their hard-earned savings are drained away. Eventually, their own health is affected under the stress. But who can they reach out to for help? We can help them. That is why the people put us here. We, the NDP official opposition, have introduced a bill to give caregivers sustainable financial relief that they desperately need while they support their loved ones. Thank you to my colleague from Niagara Falls for again tabling this important motion. Other provinces have a caregiver benefit, but not Ontario. Well, it’s time to change that here. We are calling on this government to vote for our motion and create a caregiver benefit here in Ontario.
KidsAbility
Mr. Brian Riddell
Good morning. I rise today to recognize a wonderful community organization in Waterloo region, KidsAbility. I recently had the privilege of touring the Cambridge facility where I saw first-hand a team of dedicated and compassionate professionals working together to provide children with the specialized care and support they need to reach their full potential. KidsAbility not only helps children overcome challenges in learning and development but also supports their transition into the public school system, giving them greater opportunity to participate, learn and thrive. One innovation that particularly stayed with me from my visit was seeing a new technology called brain-computer interface. This technology allows the children to turn their thoughts into actions, including communicating, painting and playing. For some children, it creates an opportunity to communicate in ways they never could before. Madam Speaker, it is difficult to put into words what it means for a parent to finally be able to understand their children’s thoughts, personality and their individual capabilities. Imagine going years without being able to fully communicate with your own child, then finally having the opportunity to see the humour, the wit, the intelligence you have never seen or expected from your own child. I want to recognize the incredible staff, volunteers and supporters for their work that they do every day to give children new opportunities and help them show the world who they truly are.
Recycling
Ms. Peggy Sattler
Speaker, London is the Forest City, and Londoners are proud of our environmental leadership. We hold annual events like Earthfest and the Green Leader Awards. We participate in the Million Tree Challenge. We’re ranked number one out of 30 Canadian cities for our environmental quality. We also understand the importance of the three Rs as one of the ways that everyday citizens can make a difference, which is why the Ford government’s botched blue box overhaul is so problematic. We all remember the rocky implementation of producer responsibility in January. Requiring the companies that make the packaging to pay for recycling was a good idea, but the new program eliminated blue box pickup for thousands of small businesses, non-profits, churches, and more. Now, after pressure from the companies about the cost of running the new program, the Ford government wants to cut it back. For Londoners, at least with producer responsibility we were able to recycle flexible plastics. After less than a year, we are now being told that flexible plastics may no longer be collected, that bundles of cardboard and overflow recycling bags may no longer be allowed, and that unwilling communities may find themselves home to new dumps and garbage incinerators. Speaker, we see the reality of climate change every day around us. We need to expand recycling and strengthen environmental protection, not weaken it.
Skilled trades
Mr. David Smith
As we begin a new session of the Legislature, I’m proud to share the work happening across my riding of Scarborough Centre to create opportunities for our young people and strengthen our community. In July, I hosted my inaugural Youth Skilled Trades and Careers Expo, welcoming more than 500 young people in attendance and over 30 organizations. Minister Piccini, Minister Lecce, PA Firin and PA Sabawy were all in attendance. People explored skilled trades and connected with employers and training institutions. Attendees also participated in culinary workshops where they prepared food and learned proper kitchen techniques. Madam Speaker, I will be hosting my second inaugural trade—this weekend, on the 7th and 8th. I have more than 50 organizations registered to date. Attendees will have opportunities to take part in hands-on activities and participate in on-the-spot interviews. I was honoured to introduce the private member’s bill that established Ontario’s Skilled Trades Week, recognizing the 144 skilled trades that help build our province. As we prepare for Remembrance Day, let us honour the courage and sacrifice of our men and women who served our country, Canada.
Robert T. James Mitchell
MPP Paul Vickers
Today I rise to recognize 20 years since the passing of Corporal Robert T. James Mitchell, a proud member of the Royal Canadian Dragoons from Owen Sound, who made the ultimate sacrifice while serving our country in Afghanistan on October 3, 2006. Two decades have passed, but the memory of Corporal Mitchell and the sacrifice he made in service to Canada remains very much alive in our community. His courage, dedication and commitment to serving others are qualities that his family and community members will forever remember. I want to take a moment to recognize his mother, Carol, whose strength and continued commitment to keeping Corporal Mitchell’s memory alive is truly remarkable. The loss of a loved one in service to our country is something no family should have to endure, and her efforts to ensure his story continues to be told are deserving of our deepest respect and gratitude. I would also like to recognize and thank the freedom riders for their work in preserving his memory and for hosting the 20th anniversary memorial in Owen Sound last month, as well as for all the work they do to help our returning veterans find a place in their communities once again. As we mark this 20th anniversary and as we approach Remembrance Day next week, let us remember Corporal Mitchell and recognize all those who have served and have given the ultimate sacrifice in defence of our country. Lest we forget.
Introduction of Visitors
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
Members, if I could direct your attention to the Speaker’s gallery. Sitting in the Speaker’s gallery, I am proud to introduce and welcome to Queen’s Park some of the newly elected municipal councillors from Hamilton: Jason Farr, Matt Francis, Nicole Trombetta, Jonathan Stathakos, Mark Daly, Fred Bennink, Colleen Stewart and Rick Kunc. Congratulations, and welcome to Queen’s Park.
Hon. Kevin Holland
I would like to welcome three members from Thunder Bay. Joining us from Lakehead University are Dr. Gautam Das and Ben Hubbard, and from the Ontario Association of Radiologists, my good friend and neighbour Erin Arps.
Hon. Nolan Quinn
Today, I would like to welcome my wonderful parents, Frank and Karen Quinn, to watch question period.
Applause.
Hon. Charmaine A. Williams
Today is Take Our Kids to Work Day, so grade 9 students across Ontario are going to work with their parents. And today, I brought my twins, Lily and Vi, to the Legislature to shadow me. So welcome to Queen’s Park.
Mr. Rob Cerjanec
I would like to welcome my nephew Mason Ouellette to the House today for Take Our Kids to Work Day.
Hon. Peter Bethlenfalvy
I would like to welcome, from the great riding of Pickering–Uxbridge, my page Jai Khandan’s parents, Preeyaunta Khandan and Khandan Sanmuganathan. Welcome to the Legislative Assembly.
Hon. Rob Flack
I would like to welcome to the House Father Jim Mockler, upstairs there. He is the chaplain to the police services in London and also to the Aylmer police college. Welcome, Father Mockler.
M. Guy Bourgouin
J’aimerais souhaiter la bienvenue à l’ACÉPO, mais en particulier à quelqu’un qui vient de mon comté, Natalie Joncas-Raymond. Bienvenue à Queen’s Park.
Ms. Mary-Margaret McMahon
I would like to welcome some wonderful people from Windsor who gave us a great tour of Ojibway Prairie Provincial Park: lovely Laura Foy, and expert botanist—and her husband— awesome Andrew Campbell. Also from beautiful Beaches–East York: lively Lauren Guy-Cowan, who is an incredible young leader and former eco tiger.
Ms. Aislinn Clancy
I would like to welcome my son, James Fobel, here for Take Our Kids to Work Day, and his friend George Benham. Welcome to your House.
MPP Tyler Watt
It’s my pleasure to welcome the Ontario Confederation of University Faculty Associations. We have Mayurika Chakravorty from Carleton, Daniel Paré from Ottawa University, Dwayne Collins from Trent University—my alma mater. We have Rob Kristofferson from OCUFA, the president, and we also have the fabulous Jenny Ahn, the executive director. Welcome to your House.
Mr. Robert Bailey
I would like to welcome my chief of staff today, Anthony Rizzetto. For bring your child to work, he’s got his son Joseph with him. Welcome to Queen’s Park.
Hon. Natalia Kusendova-Bashta
I would like to welcome the elected mayor of Mississauga, Mr. Alvin Tedjo. Welcome to the House.
M. Andrew Dowie
Je reconnais Emmanuelle Richez, conseillère scolaire du Conseil scolaire Viamonde. Bienvenue à Queen’s Park.
Mme Chandra Pasma
J’aimerais souhaiter la bienvenue aux membres de l’ACÉPO qui sont venus nous parler de l’éducation francophone aujourd’hui, particulièrement le président, Denis Labelle; la directrice générale, Isabelle Girard; et d’Ottawa, Samia Ouled Ali, Jacinthe Marcil, Christian-Charle Bouchard et Jean-François Bélanger. Bienvenue.
Mme France Gélinas
J’aimerais souhaiter la bienvenue aux représentants de l’ACÉPO, Denis Labelle et Natalie Joncas-Raymond, qui sont du conseil scolaire du Nord-Est, ainsi que Francine Vaillancourt, Anne-Marie Gélineault—pas Gélinas, Gélineault—et Carl Dussault du Conseil scolaire du Grand Nord. Bienvenue à Queen’s Park.
Ms. Bobbi Ann Brady
I would like to introduce legislative page Ramina Ramanathan from Haldimand–Norfolk, who attends Langton Public School. I had the pleasure of having lunch with Ramina last week and am proud to report that she loves to play football and she likes to swim. I know she is serving this Legislature very well.
Mr. Jeff Beattie
Speaker, it’s my honour to join you in welcoming the members of the Hamilton city council. But in addition to all of the fine folks there, I want to offer a special welcome and congratulations to arguably the best constituency city office manager in the city. Jackie Coffey is in the House today.
Mr. Terence Kernaghan
It’s my honour to welcome representatives from OCUFA in London, including Ben Muller and Thomas Peace, as well as Jun Nogami, Ana Duff and Lucas Savino. I’m looking forward to our meeting. I also want to welcome the Canadian Federation of Students. I’m also looking forward to that meeting.
Hon. Sylvia Jones
Please join me in welcoming the Ontario Association of Medical Radiation Sciences, the professional association that represents Ontario medical radiation and diagnostic imaging professionals. Welcome.
Hon. Todd J. McCarthy
I’d like to welcome to Queen’s Park today the newly elected mayor of Clarington, His Worship Tom Dingwall. Welcome to the House.
Hon. David Piccini
I’m pleased to welcome legislative page Robert Kennedy, his family Brian Tinker, Alex Tinker and David Kennedy, who are here. It’s a tremendous source of pride to see a young student from Trinity College School here serving as a legislative page. Welcome to Queen’s Park.