Warrantless Entry Civil Rights Bill

Summary#

HB 4114, titled “Relating to law enforcement operations,” is an enacted Oregon law that creates a new state civil claim; it does not amend an existing Act in the supplied text. Its stated subject is law enforcement operations, but it does not state a separate goal. The law takes effect on passage under its emergency clause; the supplied copy does not give the passage date.

  • Certain property owners, occupants and people lawfully present may sue an individual acting under color of law (using legal authority) for entering without a court-issued warrant, unless a judicially recognized exception to the warrant requirement applies.
  • “Property” includes buildings, structures, land and curtilage (the area around a home); some vehicles; places of worship; schools and other educational facilities; medical treatment facilities; and any place where someone has a reasonable expectation of privacy.
  • A successful plaintiff may receive actual economic and noneconomic damages, equitable relief (such as a court order), and other appropriate relief.
  • Courts must award reasonable attorney fees and costs to a winning plaintiff. They may award fees and costs to a defendant for defending claims the court finds frivolous.
  • The new claim cannot be brought against a person subject to suit for the injury under federal law, 42 U.S.C. § 1983. The bill includes law enforcement agencies and officers among those examples.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners, occupants and people lawfully present: You may bring this new claim if an individual acting under color of law enters covered property without a court-issued warrant and no recognized warrant exception applies. The bill does not require a particular type or amount of injury to bring the claim.
  • People seeking relief: If you win, the court must award reasonable attorney fees and costs, as well as any damages or other relief the law allows. A defendant may receive fees and costs for defending claims found frivolous.
  • Law enforcement agencies and officers: The new claim cannot be brought against a person subject to suit for the injury under section 1983; the bill expressly includes agencies and officers in its examples. The bill does not change the warrant requirement itself.
  • Other individuals acting under color of law: They may face the new claim if the conditions are met and the section 1983 exclusion does not apply.
  • Anyone bringing a claim: The action must start within two years after the claim arises.

Money#

No publicly available information on the law’s public cost is included in the supplied materials.

  • The law sets no public appropriation, fee or fine.
  • It requires courts to award reasonable fees and costs to a successful plaintiff and allows them for defendants defending claims found frivolous. The materials do not estimate how often claims may be brought or what these awards may cost.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not explain how the new claim interacts with other state or federal claims.
  • The law does not set rules for how claims must be filed or decided, or require reporting or oversight.
  • It does not define “under color of law” or “reasonable expectation of privacy.”
  • The supplied enrolled copy leaves the approval and filing dates blank, so the exact date the law took effect is not available.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the law is that it gives some people a state-court remedy for warrantless entries that do not qualify for a recognized exception.
  • The bill allows courts to award damages and equitable relief, which may address different kinds of harm or seek a court order.
  • Requiring fees for successful plaintiffs may make it more practical to bring a valid claim; allowing fees for frivolous claims may deter baseless ones.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill does not explain how its new claim fits with existing legal claims, especially given its exclusion for people subject to suit under section 1983.
  • The bill does not set detailed filing or decision rules. How the undefined terms apply may depend on courts.
  • The two-year limit may bar a claim brought after that period, even if the person later learns of the entry; the bill does not describe exceptions to the limit.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1637595

    Defeated40 members voted

    House Motion to substitute Minority Report

    AGAINST · 34FOR · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    34Against

    • Democratic33
    • Republican1

    6For

    • Republican4
    • Democratic2

    20 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1637596

    Passed40 members voted

    House Third Reading

    FOR · 36AGAINST · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    36For

    • Democratic36

    4Against

    • Republican4

    20 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1630859

    Passed8 members voted

    House Committee Do pass with amendments. (Printed A-Eng.)

    FOR · 5AGAINST · 3

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5For

    • Democratic5

    3Against

    • Republican3