Municipal tax-rate cap seeks voter approval

Summary#

HB 2889, “Providing for limitations on municipal real property tax rate increases,” would add a new chapter to Pennsylvania’s Title 53; it is not yet law. It would limit certain municipalities’ annual real property tax rate increases, with a voter referendum as the exception. The stated aim, reflected in the title, is to limit those increases.

  • For covered municipalities, the annual increase in the municipal property-tax rate could not exceed the lower of 4% or the preceding year’s regional Consumer Price Index increase. If that index is negative, the permitted increase would be 0%.
  • The limit would cover the aggregate rate for municipal purposes or a separate municipal real property tax levy. It would not cover first- or second-class cities, counties or school districts.
  • Voters could approve an increase above the limit. The municipal governing body would have to authorize the referendum by resolution at least 60 days before the election. The ballot question must state the proposed increase and resulting millage rate; an accompanying statement must explain the added revenue’s purposes and the consequences of rejecting the increase.
  • After a countywide reassessment, the first year’s limit would be measured against a revenue-neutral rate (one that would produce the same aggregate tax on properties in the prior-year tax list), rather than the pre-reassessment rate.
  • The rate limit would apply to taxes levied for fiscal years beginning on or after January 1, 2028. The bill has been introduced and referred to the House Local Government Committee.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners in covered municipalities: The bill would limit increases in the municipal tax rate, not individual tax bills. A property’s bill could still change as its assessed value changes.
  • Municipalities: They would have to stay within the rate limit or obtain voter approval for a larger increase. If seeking approval, they must follow the bill’s referendum steps.
  • Voters: A majority of those voting on the referendum question would have to approve an above-limit increase.
  • Residents of excluded jurisdictions: The bill would not limit property-tax rates set by first- or second-class cities, counties or school districts. It does not directly change those taxes.
  • Residents generally: The bill does not create a rebate, reduce property assessments, or cap the total amount of property tax owed.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill gives no estimate of municipal or election-administration costs.
  • A municipality seeking a higher increase would have to arrange a referendum and prepare the required statement; the bill does not estimate the cost of that work.
  • The bill states no appropriation, fee, fine or direct payment to taxpayers.

What is unclear#

  • The text does not define “applicable region” for the Consumer Price Index or explain how to choose the region.
  • The bill does not explain how the limit would apply if a municipality has multiple levies or how the rates would be calculated in particular cases.
  • The supplied material does not include the current text of Title 53. It therefore does not show how the bill’s new limit would interact in practice with existing limits in the laws it says it overrides.
  • The text does not specify when a referendum could be held if the required timing does not fit an election schedule, or how to handle a failed or delayed vote.
  • The bill is at the introduced stage, so passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A limit tied to inflation, with a 4% ceiling, could make municipal tax-rate increases more predictable.
  • The referendum exception would allow a municipality to seek voter approval for a larger increase rather than making that increase without a vote.
  • Requiring the ballot question and accompanying statement to disclose the proposed rate and use of added revenue could give voters information about the proposal.
  • The reassessment rule could prevent a change in assessed values alone from creating room for a larger rate increase.

Case against#

  • The limit could restrict municipalities’ ability to raise property-tax rates when their costs or revenue needs rise faster than the cap.
  • The only stated route above the limit is a referendum, which requires advance planning and voter approval; the bill provides no other exception.
  • The bill does not define which CPI region applies or explain how the cap works across multiple municipal levies, leaving important implementation questions.
  • Because the bill limits rates rather than individual tax bills, it would not guarantee that a property owner’s bill stays the same or rises only by the cap.