Malpractice cost study to curb healthcare costs

Summary#

S-3345 is a Rhode Island Senate resolution that creates a 12-member special legislative commission; it does not amend an existing Act. The commission’s stated goal is to study medical malpractice claims and insurance costs, and recommend ways to lower health care costs while protecting patients and helping retain and attract needed providers.

  • The commission must study lawsuits, claims, settlements and administrative filings, and their relationship to providers’ malpractice insurance costs.
  • It must also study whether malpractice-claim risk is connected to shortages in certain specialties or areas, and the effect of insurance premiums and claims on statewide health care costs.
  • The commission may recommend solutions, including legal reforms, and must report its findings and recommendations to the Senate by October 1, 2027. It expires January 31, 2028.
  • The 12 members include three senators; representatives of four named organizations; two hospital or large-practice risk management specialists; two members of the public; and one patient advocate. The Senate President appoints the senator members and the other appointees specified in the resolution, and appoints the chair.
  • State departments and agencies must provide advice and information the commission considers necessary or desirable. Members receive no compensation.

What it means for you#

  • Health care providers and patients: The resolution does not change malpractice rules, insurance premiums, patients’ rights, or access to care. It creates a commission to study these issues and make recommendations.
  • State departments and agencies: They must provide the commission with advice and information it considers necessary or desirable.
  • Taxpayers: The resolution allows the commission to be allotted annual budget resources, but does not itself specify an amount.
  • The public: Two commission members must be members of the general public, and one must be a patient advocate. The resolution does not set out how those members are chosen beyond Senate President appointments.

Money#

The resolution allows budget resources for the commission, but no cost estimate is provided.

  • Commission members receive no compensation.
  • The Joint Committee on Legislative Services must provide suitable quarters.
  • No publicly available information on the amount or source of any budget resources, or other staffing or operating costs.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not set out the commission’s research methods, meeting schedule, or how it will obtain information from providers, insurers, or other private parties.
  • It does not specify how the commission should handle confidential or sensitive information.
  • It does not define the scope of a “comprehensive” study or explain how the commission should measure the link between malpractice risk, provider shortages, and health care costs.
  • The resolution says appointments and an organizing meeting are to occur by September 18, 2026, but the supplied material does not say whether they occurred.
  • The resolution requires a report by October 1, 2027, but does not require the Senate or any other body to adopt the recommendations.

Case for#

  • A commission could bring together medical, legal, insurance, hospital, risk management, public, and patient perspectives to examine the issues.
  • Studying claims, settlements, administrative filings, and insurance costs together may help identify where costs or access problems arise.
  • The commission is directed to consider both reducing costs and protecting patients, rather than treating either goal as the only priority.
  • Recommendations could give lawmakers a basis for considering changes, including legal reforms, without changing malpractice rules before the study is completed.

Case against#

  • The commission can recommend changes but cannot itself change malpractice law, insurance costs, or access to care.
  • Its study may be limited because the resolution does not give it a stated process for obtaining information from private providers or insurers.
  • It is unclear how the commission will distinguish correlation from cause when examining whether malpractice-claim risk is linked to provider shortages or higher costs.
  • The resolution permits budget resources but gives no estimate, so the public cost of the study is unknown.