Synthetic Media Would Face New Rules

Summary#

The Prevention of Deceptive Artificial Intelligence Act would create a new Saskatchewan law and amend the Consumer Protection and Business Practices Act, The Election Act, 1996, The Local Government Election Act, 2015 and The Privacy Act. Its stated goal is to prevent deceptive uses of synthetic media; that goal is not a guaranteed result. The supplied bill appears to be at first reading, has no assent date, and would start only on a date set by order of the Lieutenant Governor in Council.

  • It would prohibit a person from knowingly using synthetic media deceptively: with intent to make someone reasonably believe it is authentic, where that belief is reasonably likely to cause substantial harm to a person or a significant risk to public safety.
  • People who create, publish, distribute or use synthetic media that is reasonably likely to be mistaken for authentic would generally have to disclose that it contains synthetic media. If technically feasible, it would also need a persistent marking, which may be machine-readable. An exception applies when its artificial nature would be apparent to a reasonable person.
  • Deceptive use would become a civil wrong (a tort). A person could bring a court action without proving damage. A court could award damages and order steps such as removing or de-indexing content; these are court powers, not automatic outcomes.
  • The amendments would add disclosure rules for synthetic media in election advertisements, add synthetic-media practices to consumer-protection law, and address synthetic media in privacy and intimate-image law. The existing Acts were not supplied, so the full change against current law cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • People who make or share synthetic media: The bill covers content that imitates a person or an event, including content generated or materially altered by AI or other prescribed technology. The disclosure duty can apply even when the use is not deceptive, if the content is likely to be mistaken for authentic and the exception does not apply.
  • People depicted or impersonated: They could bring a tort action over a deceptive use without proving damage. A defendant could not avoid the action just because a computer created the content, or because the defendant did not create it, if they knowingly published, distributed or used it deceptively.
  • Election advertisers: Knowingly distributing an election advertisement containing synthetic media would require a clear, prominent disclosure that meets format-specific rules. The rule would not apply if an ordinary voter would reasonably recognize the ad as parody or satire.
  • Businesses and people represented in ads: The bill would add synthetic-media uses involving false endorsements and certain other representations to the consumer-protection law. The supplied materials do not include the existing provisions those additions refer to.
  • People affected by synthetic intimate images: The Privacy Act amendment would include certain synthetic images in its intimate-image definition. It would also require courts to treat a minor’s involvement as an aggravating factor in specified privacy or intimate-image cases; courts may award aggravated damages.
  • The public: The bill does not ban synthetic media generally. It preserves lawful uses, including parody and satire, unless the use meets the definition of deceptive use.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a government budget, staffing amount, fee or fine.
  • Courts could award damages and order other remedies in civil cases. The bill gives no estimate of how often that might happen or the amounts involved.
  • Regulations could set detailed disclosure and marking standards, but the bill gives no cost estimate for meeting them.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give a start date; it would take effect by order of the Lieutenant Governor in Council.
  • It does not set out a process for complaints, court cases, disclosure enforcement, timelines or appeals.
  • “Substantial” harm and “significant” risk are not defined in the bill. The government could make regulations that define or change the meaning of terms and exempt classes of people, activities or circumstances.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied. The exact effect of the consumer-protection, election and privacy amendments—and how they interact with current rules—could not be checked.
  • The bill does not estimate public or private costs, or explain how compliance would be monitored.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that realistic fabricated content can mislead people and cause serious personal harm or public-safety risks. A legal prohibition aimed at knowingly deceptive uses targets that conduct rather than synthetic media as a whole.
  • Disclosure duties could help people recognize realistic synthetic content, while the exception for content obviously artificial avoids requiring labels in every case.
  • A civil action without proof of damage, along with possible removal, correction and other court orders, could give a person legal options when deceptive content spreads.
  • The election amendments would require clear disclosures in synthetic-media ads while excepting ads recognizable as parody or satire.

Case against#

  • The bill’s definitions and broad regulation-making powers leave important details to later rules. The government could also exempt groups or activities, so the practical scope is not settled by the bill alone.
  • The disclosure duty applies more broadly than the ban: it can cover synthetic media likely to be mistaken for authentic even when it does not meet the bill’s harm-and-intent test.
  • Court orders could require removal or de-indexing by internet intermediaries or other people and organizations. The bill does not explain how those parties would receive notice or take part in a case.
  • The bill gives no estimate of compliance costs or likely litigation costs. Without the parent Acts, it is also unclear how much the amendments add to existing consumer, election and privacy protections.