Summary#
The passed bill creates the Trusts and Succession (Scotland) Act. Its short-title clause gives the year as 2023, although the supplied text also refers to a 2024 Act, so the year is inconsistent in the material provided. The Act sets new rules for trusts and changes some succession rules; its stated goal is to update how trusts are managed and who inherits.
- Trust rules cover trustee appointments and removals, decision-making, investment, information for beneficiaries, duties and liability. The bill also repeals the Trusts (Scotland) Act 1921 and amends other laws.
- Trustees generally gain broad powers over trust property, subject to the trust deed, their duties and other laws. They may delegate powers, appoint agents and nominees, and invest in a wide range of assets. Investment decisions must take account of suitability and appropriate diversification; trustees usually must obtain and consider proper advice.
- The Act creates rules for private purpose trusts, which are for a specific non-charitable, non-public purpose and are not solely for named beneficiaries. A truster may appoint a supervisor to oversee the purpose; the supervisor has specified rights and duties.
- Courts gain powers to change trust purposes in some circumstances and to approve certain changes or endings of private trusts. These powers have limits, including rules for beneficiary agreement or approval.
- Succession changes include giving a surviving spouse or civil partner the whole intestate estate when there is no “prior relative,” and extending a court-application period from 6 to 12 months. The Act also changes a rule about divorce, dissolution or annulment and a “special destination” (a direction about who receives property).
What it means for you#
- Trustees: They must meet care and information duties, and follow rules for decisions and investments. They may use agents and nominees, but must keep nominee arrangements under review and act if they consider intervention necessary. Trust property may pay for insurance against trustees’ personal liability.
- Beneficiaries and potential beneficiaries: Trustees must tell some people about the trust and provide information on request, subject to exceptions. The Act does not require trustees to share every requested item: for example, there is a presumption against disclosing deliberations, reasons for decisions or letters of wishes.
- People setting up or overseeing trusts: A truster may provide for a protector, who can have powers such as directing the removal or addition of a trustee. A supervisor may be appointed for a private purpose trust. Neither role is a new independent public body.
- Charities: For trusts created after the relevant rule starts, trustees selling heritable property to a charity are not under a duty to achieve best value. They must still meet duties to act in the charity’s interests.
- Spouses and civil partners: The intestacy change applies to deaths after that rule starts. The supplied text does not give enough of the existing succession law to explain all the circumstances in which a person counts as a “prior relative.”
- People using trusts: The Act does not itself create a public trust service, a benefit payment, a tax change or a general process for applying to have a trust reviewed.
Money#
No cost estimate is in the available material.
- Trust property may pay for trustee insurance and reasonable fees for agents.
- A court-supervision order requires the accountant of court to examine and audit trustees’ accounts annually. The materials give no estimate of public or trust costs.
- The Act allows regulations to set commencement dates and make some further changes; no cost for this work is given.
What is unclear#
- The text says most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers. The supplied material does not identify those dates. It says the divorce and intestacy provisions start three months after Royal Assent.
- The parent laws and explanatory notes are not supplied, so I could not verify how much of the trust wording is new compared with the law already in force. The text does identify repeals and amendments, but does not provide a full current-law comparison.
- The supplied text conflicts on whether the Act’s short-title year is 2023 or 2024.
- The meaning and practical reach of some terms, including “material change in circumstances” and “prior relative,” are not explained fully in the supplied material.
- The text sets out some court powers and information duties, but it does not give a single application or review process for every trust matter.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make trust administration more workable by setting clearer rules for trustee decisions, appointments, powers and liability.
- A possible argument for the broad investment power is that it gives trustees more choice, while advice and duties of care remain part of the rules.
- A possible argument for supervisors and protectors is that they can provide oversight of trustees, including for private purpose trusts.
- The succession changes could clarify who inherits in a specified intestacy situation and give a survivor more time to apply to court.
Case against#
- One concern is that broad trustee powers to invest, delegate and use nominees may make it harder for beneficiaries to monitor decisions, even though information duties and other safeguards apply.
- The Act’s safeguards depend in part on court involvement, but the materials do not estimate court workload or costs.
- It is unclear how the new trust rules interact in practice with existing arrangements, since the supplied material does not include a full comparison with current law.
- A possible trade-off is that allowing a charitable trust to sell property to another charity without achieving best value may help charities transfer property, but could mean a lower sale price than the highest available.