Summary#
The Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Act 2024 amends several existing Scottish laws and establishes some new legal arrangements, including a Victims and Witnesses Commissioner and a Sexual Offences Court. Its stated goal is to improve victims’ and witnesses’ experiences and make criminal justice decisions fairer, clearer and more transparent.
- An independent Commissioner must promote victims’ and witnesses’ rights, monitor service standards, and may investigate criminal justice bodies’ regard for those rights. The Commissioner cannot intervene in an individual case or undermine independent decisions by criminal justice bodies.
- The Act adds duties and powers concerning trauma-informed practice in criminal and civil proceedings, court scheduling, and fatal accident inquiries. Some duties are to have regard to the desirability of trauma-informed practice; they do not guarantee a particular outcome.
- It changes victims’ rights to receive information and make representations, including about some prosecution decisions and prisoner-release decisions. Police Scotland must pass a victim’s details to suitable support services if the victim asks and consents.
- It replaces the “not proven” verdict with guilty or not guilty. In solemn jury trials, a guilty verdict needs at least 8 of 12 jurors, 9 of 13, or 10 of 14 or 15. A trial may continue with 12 jurors after a juror dies or is discharged, if the court finds that is in the interests of justice.
- It establishes a Sexual Offences Court for listed sexual offences triable on indictment. If an indictment includes a listed sexual offence, the Court may also try the other offences on that indictment, subject to stated exceptions.
- The Act also changes protections and procedures for vulnerable people, including anonymity for victims of listed offences and special measures for vulnerable parties in civil cases. It makes breaching certain protective orders from elsewhere in the UK a criminal offence in Scotland.
What it means for you#
- Victims and witnesses: The Commissioner can investigate how a criminal justice body has considered victims’ and witnesses’ rights, interests and views, but cannot decide or remedy your individual case. The Commissioner must prepare and review a Victims’ Charter describing possible interactions with the justice system, communications, rights and ways to uphold those rights.
- Victims: If you ask to be referred to support services and consent, the competent authority must pass your details to suitable providers as soon as reasonably practicable. You can instead ask for information to contact providers yourself, or later stop a referral. The Act also requires prosecutors to inform victims, as soon as reasonably practicable, when they decide not to prosecute or to discontinue proceedings. Information about certain plea agreements is required when a victim has asked to receive it; timing can be delayed in the interests of justice.
- People involved in civil cases: Courts must order a requested special measure for a party who meets the Act’s specified vulnerability test, or explain why they do not. For other parties, a court may order a measure if the legal conditions are met. Measures include a screen, a live video link or a supporter.
- People accused of sexual offences: In the Sexual Offences Court, an accused person cannot conduct their own case at a hearing where a witness will give evidence. If they lack a solicitor and the court is not satisfied they intend to get one, the court must appoint one.
- The public: Publishing information likely to identify a victim of a listed offence is generally prohibited during the victim’s lifetime, with exceptions in the Act. Breach can bring a fine or imprisonment: up to 12 months on summary conviction, or up to 2 years on indictment.
- People subject to qualifying protective orders from elsewhere in the UK: Knowingly breaching an order, without reasonable excuse, can be an offence in Scotland if the conduct would also be an offence where the order applies. The maximum sentence is capped by the penalty available there.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- The Commissioner’s office must prepare annual budget proposals for approval and may appoint staff, subject to approval of staff numbers. The Act also allows payments for the Commissioner’s remuneration, pensions and expenses.
- The Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service may pay remuneration and expenses to some Sexual Offences Court judges. Scottish Ministers must provide for payment of solicitors appointed by a court in civil cases covered by the new register rules.
- The Act does not give estimates for staffing, court operations, legal aid, training, or other implementation costs.
What is unclear#
- Most provisions start on dates set by Scottish Ministers; the Act does not give those dates. The material does not show which provisions have commenced.
- The existing Acts being amended were not supplied in their full current form. I could not verify from the available material exactly which rules are new and which change existing practice, including the full eligibility rules for victim notifications.
- The Act does not set out the Commissioner’s staffing level, yearly budget, or how many investigations will be carried out. It also does not create a process for the Commissioner to resolve individual complaints.
- Some practical details depend on later regulations or court rules, including parts of the civil-case special measures, court procedure, and the operation of the solicitors’ register.
- The Act defines trauma-informed practice in broad terms, but the available material does not explain how courts will apply it in particular situations or measure compliance.
Case for#
- The Commissioner could give victims and witnesses a dedicated, independent office to examine wider problems across criminal justice bodies, without taking over decisions in individual cases.
- Clearer information rights and a required route to support services could make it easier for victims to understand decisions and find help.
- Advance evidence and other special measures could reduce the need for vulnerable witnesses or parties to give evidence in person, while the Act preserves exceptions where fairness or the interests of justice require them.
- Replacing three verdicts with two and setting clear jury thresholds could make the verdict system easier to understand.
Case against#
- The Act creates substantial new court, staffing, training and administrative duties, but the available material does not estimate their costs or explain how they will be resourced.
- The new jury rules change both the available verdicts and the number of jurors needed for a guilty verdict. The Act does not establish what effect those changes will have on trial outcomes.
- The Sexual Offences Court, required legal representation for accused people at witness hearings, and new evidence procedures could add demands on courts and legal services; the Act gives no estimate of capacity or delay.
- The Commissioner can investigate system-wide issues but cannot resolve an individual’s case. The Act does not set out how its recommendations will lead to changes if a body disagrees with them.